Buy Now, Ship Later: Save on shipping, consolidate orders, and avoid short-term delays due to high seasonal volume.

By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
Gary Sheffield Rookie Card All Baseball Cards
Sort By
Listings
Listings 1 - 67 of 67
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.2

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes on Back) [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$115.24
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.1

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes* on Back) [BAS Authentic]

$86.25
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.2

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes on Back) [BAS Authentic]

$72.87
1989 Fleer - [Base] - Glossy #196

Gary Sheffield [PSA 9 MINT]

$80.74
1989 Bowman - [Base] - Collector's Edition (Tiffany) #142

Gary Sheffield [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$37.63
1989 Topps - [Base] #343.1

Future Star - Gary Sheffield (Small Gap Between Hat and Future Stars Header) [P…

$25.52
1989 Score - [Base] #625

Gary Sheffield [BAS BGS Authentic]

$59.04
1989 Fleer - [Base] #196

Gary Sheffield [PSA 7 NM]

$58.90
1989 Topps - [Base] - Collector's Edition (Tiffany) #343

Future Star - Gary Sheffield [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$57.74
1989 Topps - [Base] #343.1

Future Star - Gary Sheffield (Small Gap Between Hat and Future Stars Header) [B…

$56.60
1989 Topps - [Base] #343.1

Future Star - Gary Sheffield (Small Gap Between Hat and Future Stars Header) [B…

$54.30
1989 Bowman - [Base] - Collector's Edition (Tiffany) #142

Gary Sheffield

$86.45
1989 Topps - [Base] #343.1

Future Star - Gary Sheffield (Small Gap Between Hat and Future Stars Header) [C…

$41.65
1989 Topps - [Base] - Collector's Edition (Tiffany) #343

Future Star - Gary Sheffield

$115.24
1989 Topps - [Base] - Collector's Edition (Tiffany) #343

Future Star - Gary Sheffield [PSA 7 NM]

$35.90
1989 Fleer - [Base] #196

Gary Sheffield [PSA 9 MINT]

6 from
$10.03
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.2

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes on Back) [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$15.19
1989 Fleer - [Base] - Glossy #196

Gary Sheffield [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$24.35
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.2

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes on Back) [BGS 8 NM‑MT]

$23.25
1989 Fleer - [Base] - Glossy #196

Gary Sheffield [BCCG 9 Near Mint or Better]

$22.06
1989 Fleer - [Base] - Glossy #196

Gary Sheffield [PSA 7 NM]

$22.10
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.1

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes* on Back) [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$20.95
1989 Topps - [Base] #343.1

Future Star - Gary Sheffield (Small Gap Between Hat and Future Stars Header) [P…

$27.74
1989 Bowman - [Base] #142

Gary Sheffield [PSA 9 MINT]

4 from
$15.61
1989 Fleer - [Base] #196

Gary Sheffield [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

3 from
$13.48
1989 Score - [Base] #625

Gary Sheffield [CSG 6.5 Ex/NM+]

$13.48
1989 Fleer - [Base] - Glossy #196

Gary Sheffield [Poor to Fair]

$16.64
1989 Score - [Base] #625

Gary Sheffield [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$16.35
1989 Bowman - [Base] #142

Gary Sheffield [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

3 from
$12.33
1989 Fleer - [Base] - Glossy #196

Gary Sheffield

6 from
$13.61
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.2

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes on Back) [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$10.60
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.2

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes on Back) [PSA 6 EX‑MT]

$12.85
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.1

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes* on Back) [BGS 8 NM‑MT]

$12.28
1989 Topps - [Base] #343.1

Future Star - Gary Sheffield (Small Gap Between Hat and Future Stars Header) [G…

6 from
$6.28
1989 Score - [Base] #625

Gary Sheffield [PSA 7 NM]

$11.74
1989 Fleer - [Base] #196

Gary Sheffield [BGS 9 MINT]

$11.18
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.1

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes* on Back) [Noted]

$8.59
1989 Score - [Base] #625

Gary Sheffield [CSG 7.5 Near Mint+]

$7.73
1989 Topps - [Base] #343.1

Future Star - Gary Sheffield (Small Gap Between Hat and Future Stars Header) [C…

$6.29
1989 Score - [Base] #625

Gary Sheffield [Noted]

2 from
$0.82
1989 Score - [Base] #625

Gary Sheffield [EX to NM]

8 from
$1.40
1989 Sportflics - [Base] #41

Gary Sheffield

2 from
$2.78
1989 Sportflics - [Base] #223

Gary Sheffield, Gregg Jefferies, Sandy Alomar

4 from
$2.38
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.1

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes* on Back) [EX to NM]

22 from
$1.04
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.2

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes on Back) [EX to NM]

17 from
$0.74
1989 Bowman - [Base] #142

Gary Sheffield

17 from
$1.21
1989 Topps - [Base] #343.2

Future Star - Gary Sheffield (No Gap Between Hat and Future Stars Header)

50 from
$0.71
1989 Score - [Base] #625

Gary Sheffield

184 from
$0.70
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.2

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes on Back) [Good to VG‑EX]

3 from
$1.40
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.1

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes* on Back) [Good to VG‑E…

6 from
$0.89
1989 Topps - [Base] #343.2

Future Star - Gary Sheffield (No Gap Between Hat and Future Stars Header) [EX&n…

3 from
$0.77
1989 Sportflics - [Base] #223

Gary Sheffield, Gregg Jefferies, Sandy Alomar [EX to NM]

$2.83
1989 Score - [Base] #625

Gary Sheffield [Poor to Fair]

$2.83
1989 Fleer - [Base] #196

Gary Sheffield [Good to VG‑EX]

2 from
$0.83
1989 Topps - [Base] #343.1

Future Star - Gary Sheffield (Small Gap Between Hat and Future Stars Header)

441 from
$0.80
1989 Fleer - [Base] #196

Gary Sheffield

340 from
$0.75
1989 Topps - [Base] #343.1

Future Star - Gary Sheffield (Small Gap Between Hat and Future Stars Header) [N…

$2.27
1989 Fleer - [Base] #196

Gary Sheffield [EX to NM]

5 from
$1.19
1989 Topps - [Base] #343.1

Future Star - Gary Sheffield (Small Gap Between Hat and Future Stars Header) [E…

16 from
$0.80
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.1

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes* on Back)

269 from
$0.69
1989 Bowman - [Base] #142

Gary Sheffield [Good to VG‑EX]

$2.03
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.2

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes on Back)

248 from
$0.65
1989 Topps - [Base] #343.1

Future Star - Gary Sheffield (Small Gap Between Hat and Future Stars Header) [P…

3 from
$1.40
1989 Bowman - [Base] #142

Gary Sheffield [EX to NM]

7 from
$1.06
2008 Upper Deck Documentary - [Base] #409

Gary Sheffield

5 from
$1.40
1989 Bowman - [Base] #142

Gary Sheffield [Noted]

7 from
$1.37
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.1

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes* on Back) [Poor to Fair]

$1.39
Go to page
Page 1 of 1