Buy Now, Ship Later: Save on shipping, consolidate orders, and avoid short-term delays due to high seasonal volume.

By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
Gary Sheffield All Baseball Cards
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Sold Out
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Baseball (3,357)
MultiSport (30)
Listings 1 - 100 of 3,387
1989 Upper Deck - [Base] #13.2

Star Rookie - Gary Sheffield (Right Side Up SS on Front) [BAS BGS Aut…

$97.97
2022 Topps Archives Signature Series - Retired Player Edition Buybacks #90T-718

Gary Sheffield (1990 Topps) [Buyback] #/1

$271.13
1997 Bowman's Best - Mirror Image - Reverse Refractor #MI6

Juan Gonzalez, Jose Guillen, Gary Sheffield, Richard Hidalgo

$257.49
2001 SP Authentic - [Base] #61

Gary Sheffield [JSA Certified COA Sticker]

$150.14
2024 Topps Triple Threads - Autograph Relic Combos - Amethyst #ARC-SRW

Gary Sheffield, Iván Rodríguez, Dontrelle Willis #/27

$175.28
2025 Topps Series 1 - 1990 Topps Baseball Autographs - Black #90A-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/10

$175.00
1995 Topps Stadium Club - Clearcut #13

Gary Sheffield [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$175.00
2024 Topps Pristine - Pristine Pieces Autograph Relics - Gold Refractor #PPAR-GS

Gary Sheffield [SGC 10 GEM] #/50

$165.10
2020 Leaf In The Game Used Sports - Baseball Redraft - Platinum Blue Spectrum #BBR-09

Gary Sheffield, Matt Williams, Kevin Brown, Bo Jackson #/7

$163.71
2015 Panini National Treasures - Game Ball Signatures #42

Gary Sheffield #/20

$158.78
2002 Donruss Classics - New Millennium Classics #NMC-55

Gary Sheffield [EX to NM] #/500

$45.31
2025 Topps Chrome - Chrome Legends Autographs - Orange Refractor #CLA-GS

Gary Sheffield [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/25

$149.70
2021 Topps Archives Signature Series - Retired Player Edition Buybacks #04TT-TT18

Gary Sheffield (2004 Topps Total Topps) [Buyback] #/1

$143.76
2023 Panini National Treasures - Definitive Ink - Holo Silver #DI-GS

Gary Sheffield #/10

$126.60
1998 Bowman Chrome - [Base] - Golden Anniversary Refractor Missing Serial Number #68

Gary Sheffield

$121.10
2025 Leaf Seasons in the Sun - Signature Souvenir - Holo Pattern Dots #SSO-GS1

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated] #/6

$52.64
2004 Topps Heritage - [Base] #47

Gary Sheffield

$31.36
2004 Donruss Diamond Kings - [Base] - Silver Framed Signatures #82

Gary Sheffield #/5

$115.24
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.2

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes on Back) [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$115.24
2013 Topps Supreme - Retired and Active Autographs - Black #SA-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/5

$115.24
2004 Leaf Certified Cuts - [Base] - Marble Gold Position Materials Signatures #208

Gary Sheffield #/10

$64.02
2001 Upper Deck Reserve - Game-Used Base and Ball Triple #B-BSH

Barry Bonds, Todd Helton, Gary Sheffield

2 from
$46.43
2023 Leaf Metal - Autographs - Printing Plate Yellow #BA-GS1

Gary Sheffield #/1

$114.39
1992 Upper Deck - [Base] #84

Bloodlines - Gary Sheffield, Dwight Gooden [BAS BGS Authentic]

$103.75
2001 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection - Ultimate Signatures - Silver #GS

Gary Sheffield #/24

$41.83
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.1

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes* on Back) [BAS Authentic]

$86.25
1993 Classic Best Gold Minor League - Autographs #_GASH

Gary Sheffield [BAS BGS Authentic] #/2,050

$80.73
2020 Topps Allen & Ginter's - [Base] #331

Short Print - Gary Sheffield [BAS BGS Authentic]

$93.39
2025 Leaf A Bronx Legacy - Penstripes - Silver Spectrum Holofoil #P-GS1

Gary Sheffield #/2

$92.25
1991 Topps - [Base] - Factory Set Collector's Edition (Tiffany) #68

Gary Sheffield [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$87.71
2006 Bowman Originals - Buyback Autographs #3.2

Gary Sheffield (2003 Bowman Chrome) [Buyback] #/6

$92.24
2004 Leaf Certified Materials - Fabric of the Game - AL/NL Autographs #FG-164

Gary Sheffield #/10

$69.54
2004 Leaf Certified Materials - Fabric of the Game - Autographs #FG-164

Gary Sheffield #/10

$69.54
2021 Topps Rip - [Base] #50

Gary Sheffield #/99

2 from
$34.84
2024 Panini National Treasures - Timeless Talents Signatures #TTS-GS

Gary Sheffield #/49

$86.79
1999 Topps Finest - [Base] - Gold Refractor #99

Gary Sheffield #/100

$78.17
1996 Select Certified Edition - [Base] - Blue #3

Gary Sheffield #/180

2 from
$46.24
2020 Topps Chrome Black - Chrome Black Autographs #CBA-GS

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated]

$49.70
1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.2

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes on Back) [BAS Authentic]

$72.87
2022 Leaf Lumber - Silver Sluggers Relics #SS-09

Jorge Posada, Carlos Delgado, Bret Boone, Vernon Wells, Manny Ramirez, Todd Hel…

$52.87
2004 SP Authentic - SP Buyback Autographs #75

Gary Sheffield #/43

$80.74
2007 Upper Deck Spectrum - Aligning the Stars #AS-GRS

Ken Griffey Jr., Manny Ramirez, Gary Sheffield #/99

$80.74
1989 Fleer - [Base] - Glossy #196

Gary Sheffield [PSA 9 MINT]

$80.74
2018 Panini Flawless - Legendary Signatures - Ruby #LS-GS

Gary Sheffield #/20

$79.60
2021 Topps Tier One - Prime Performers Autographs - Bronze Ink #PPA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

$76.15
1996 Upper Deck - Diamond Destiny - Gold #DD20

Gary Sheffield

$75.29
1989 Upper Deck - [Base] #13.2

Star Rookie - Gary Sheffield (Right Side Up SS on Front) [PSA 10 GEM&…

$92.24
1989 Bowman - [Base] - Collector's Edition (Tiffany) #142

Gary Sheffield [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$37.63
2010 Topps Tribute - Relic Autographs #TAR-GS

Gary Sheffield #/99

$37.34
1989 Topps - [Base] #343.1

Future Star - Gary Sheffield (Small Gap Between Hat and Future Stars Header) [P…

$25.52
2024 Topps Five Star - Autographs #FSA-GS.1

Gary Sheffield [PSA 7 NM]

$69.25
2023 Topps Five Star - Silver Signatures #SS-GS

Gary Sheffield #/40

$69.25
2001 Fleer Triple Crown - [Base] - Home Runs Blue #26

Gary Sheffield #/43

$69.24
1989 Score - [Base] #625

Gary Sheffield [BAS BGS Authentic]

$59.04
2001 Donruss Elite - Primary Colors - Yellow Die-Cut #PC-32

Gary Sheffield #/75

$47.63
1989 Upper Deck - [Base] #13.1

Star Rookie - Gary Sheffield (Upside Down SS on Front) [PSA 8 NM̴…

$64.65
2021 Topps Tier One - Clear One Autographs #C1A-GS

Gary Sheffield #/10

$63.50
2005 Topps Pristine - [Base] #195

Base Rare - Gary Sheffield #/100

3 from
$37.73
2002 Donruss Elite - [Base] - Aspirations Die-Cut #132

Gary Sheffield #/11

$55.14
1989 Fleer - [Base] #196

Gary Sheffield [PSA 7 NM]

$58.90
2021 Topps Chrome Platinum Anniversary - Autographs - Gold Refractor #PA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/50

$58.27
2022 Topps Museum Collection - Archival Autographs - Copper #AA-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/50

$58.04
2022 Topps On Demand Dynamic Duals - [Base] - Autographs #12-A

Gary Sheffield, Dontrelle Willis

$58.04
2008 Bowman Chrome - [Base] - Orange Refractor #152

Gary Sheffield #/25

$58.04
2022 Topps Archives - 1992 Topps MLB Debut Autographs - Silver #72DB-GS

Gary Sheffield #/99

$37.92
2024 Panini Boys of Summer - Fabric of the Game Signatures - Leather #44

Gary Sheffield #/25

2 from
$28.99
2025 Leaf A Bronx Legacy - Penstripes - Green Spectrum Holofoil #P-GS1

Gary Sheffield #/5

$58.03
2021 Topps Archives Signature Series - Retired Player Edition Buybacks #16TA-158

Gary Sheffield (2016 Topps Archives) [Buyback] #/42

$57.75
1989 Upper Deck - [Base] #13.2

Star Rookie - Gary Sheffield (Right Side Up SS on Front) [BGS 9.5 GEM…

$35.90
2021 Topps Clearly Authentic Autographs - 1986 Topps Baseball - Green #86TBA-GS

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated] #/99

$32.44
2022 Topps Museum Collection - Archival Autographs #AA-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/125

$31.59
2021 Topps Chrome Platinum Anniversary - Autographs #PA-GS

Gary Sheffield

$29.29
2021 Topps Tier One - Tier One Talent Autographs #T1TA-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/300

3 from
$28.14
2022 Topps Pristine - Slice of the Star Autograph Relics #SSAR-GA

Gary Sheffield

$57.74
2010 Topps Tribute - Relic Autographs - Black #TAR-GS4

Gary Sheffield #/50

$57.74
2012 Topps Museum Collection - Signature Swatches Autograph Dual Relics #SSADR-GS

Gary Sheffield #/99

$57.74
1989 Topps - [Base] - Collector's Edition (Tiffany) #343

Future Star - Gary Sheffield [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$57.74
2004 Fleer National Pastime - Signature Swings - Gold #SSA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

$43.67
2005 Playoff Absolute Memorabilia - Absolutely Ink - Spectrum Single Materials #AI-116

Gary Sheffield #/50

$43.45
1993 Fleer Ultra - [Base] #122

Gary Sheffield [CAS Certified Sealed]

$17.68
1998 Donruss Preferred - Great X-Pectations - Executive Proof #16

Gary Sheffield, Richard Hidalgo

$56.89
2001 SP Authentic - [Base] - Missing Serial Number #155

SP Superstars - Gary Sheffield

$56.89
1997 Pinnacle Certified - Certified Team - Gold Promotional Sample #16

Gary Sheffield

$56.89
2024 Topps Inception - Dawn of Greatness Autographs - Blue #DGA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

$56.60
1989 Topps - [Base] #343.1

Future Star - Gary Sheffield (Small Gap Between Hat and Future Stars Header) [B…

$56.60
2022 Topps On Demand Dynamic Duals - [Base] - Blue Autographs #12-A

Gary Sheffield, Dontrelle Willis #/25

2 from
$55.45
1987 ProCards Minor League - [Base] #239

Gary Sheffield [SGC 92 NM/MT+ 8.5]

$55.45
1989 Topps - [Base] #343.1

Future Star - Gary Sheffield (Small Gap Between Hat and Future Stars Header) [B…

$54.30
2024 Leaf Collective - Press Pass Autographs - Green Shimmer #20A-GS1

Gary Sheffield #/6

2 from
$23.24
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones - [Base] - Blue #52-275

Gary Sheffield (2007 - 450 Career Home Runs (480 Total)) #/10

$21.59
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones - [Base] - Blue #52-276

Gary Sheffield (2007 - 450 Career Home Runs (480 Total)) #/10

$21.59
1992 Leaf - [Base] - 2014 Leaf Memories Buyback Gold #446

Gary Sheffield #/5

2 from
$46.24
1998 Topps - [Base] #166

Gary Sheffield [BAS Authentic]

$44.58
2005 eTopps - [Base] - Anaheim #53

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated] #/1

$52.00
1997 Pinnacle Certified - Certified Team - Gold #16

Gary Sheffield #/499

$51.95
2023 Leaf Vivid - Autographs - Purple Prismatic #BA-GS1

Gary Sheffield #/2

$51.65
2004 Skybox Autographics - Autographs - Silver #A-GS

Gary Sheffield #/100

$50.85
2025 Topps Tier One - Autographed Tier One Relics - Blue Dual #AT1R-GS

Gary Sheffield #/99

2 from
$40.79
2000 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Refractor #105

Gary Sheffield

$49.93
2013 Topps Supreme - Retired and Active Autographs - Black #SA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/5

$34.16
<< 1 2 3 4 5 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 34