This website uses technologies such as cookies to provide you a better user experience. To learn more refer to our Privacy Policy .

Top
Jay Payton Baseball Cards
Sort By
Listings
Listings 1 - 100 of 416
2005 Donruss - [Base] - Gold Press Proof #170

Jay Payton #/25

$11.93
2005 Donruss Diamond Kings - [Base] - Gold Signatures #186

Jay Payton #/5

$9.17
2006 Fleer - [Base] - Printing Plate Black #36

Jay Payton #/1

$23.43
2004 Donruss Throwback Threads - Player Threads - Signatures #PT-29

Jay Payton #/25

$18.83
2004 Donruss Timeless Treasures - [Base] - Bronze #57

Jay Payton #/100

$26.20
1997 Bowman - Autograph - Gold Ink #CA61

Jay Payton

$29.29
2004 Playoff Absolute Memorabilia - [Base] - Spectrum Silver Signatures #165

Jay Payton #/100

$3.42
2000 Topps New York City Subway Series - Fan Fare Encased Tokens #SSR7

Jay Payton [Noted]

$29.28
2005 Donruss Diamond Kings - [Base] - Red Framed Signatures #186

Jay Payton #/50

$29.28
2001 Topps Finest - Authentic Autograph #FA-JP

Jay Payton [BGS 9.5 GEM MINT]

$15.20
2004 Playoff Honors - [Base] - Gold Signatures #161

Jay Payton #/50

$23.54
2005 Leaf - [Base] - Gold Press Proof #164

Jay Payton #/25

$14.34
2009 Upper Deck - [Base] - Gold #39

Jay Payton #/99

$23.25
2004 Leaf - [Base] - Press Proof Gold #128

Jay Payton [Noted] #/25

$8.43
2005 Donruss Studio - [Base] - Private Signings Platinum #49

Jay Payton #/10

$21.24
2005 Topps Cracker Jack - [Base] - Mini Blue #99

Jay Payton [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/50

$18.65
2003 Donruss Elite - [Base] - Status Gold Die-Cut #104

Jay Payton #/24

$17.79
2003 SPx - [Base] - Spectrum #43

Jay Payton #/24

$17.79
2002 Palm Beach Post New York Mets Spring Training - [Base] #22

Jay Payton

$17.79
2001 Donruss - [Base] - Baseball's Best Gold #135

Jay Payton

$17.78
2001 Pacific - [Base] - Retail LTD #275

Jay Payton #/85

2 from
$3.69
2006 Topps Heritage - [Base] #296

Jay Payton

2 from
$4.27
2005 Donruss Diamond Kings - [Base] - Blue Framed #186

Jay Payton #/100

2 from
$1.68
1998 Donruss Elite - [Base] - Status Executive Proof #109

Jay Payton

$14.34
2005 Uno Boston Red Sox - [Base] #G9

Jay Payton [EX to NM]

$10.89
2001 Fleer Futures - [Base] - Black Gold #101

Jay Payton #/499

$12.89
1996 Best Minor League - Autographs #_JAPA

Jay Payton [EX to NM]

$12.04
1995 SP Top Prospects - Destination The Show #DS20

Jay Payton

2 from
$9.74
2001 SPx - Winning Materials Triple Jersey Combo #PPV

Jay Payton, Mike Piazza, Robin Ventura

8 from
$5.14
1997 Best Autograph Series - Autographs #_JAPA

Jay Payton

6 from
$2.15
1995 Best - [Base] #84

Jay Payton [CAS Certified Sealed]

$11.75
2001 Donruss - [Base] - Chicago Sun-Times Collection #135

Jay Payton #/5

$11.18
2000 Pacific Omega - [Base] #227

Juan Pierre, Jay Payton #/999

3 from
$10.66
1998 Donruss Collections - Donruss Elite - Prized Collections #PC509

Jay Payton

$10.55
1995 Best - Autographs #_JAPA

Jay Payton [Good to VG‑EX]

$9.74
2004 Leaf Certified Materials - [Base] - White Mirror Autographs #90

Jay Payton #/100

2 from
$5.92
2003 Topps 205 - [Base] - Drum Back Mini #201

Jay Payton

$9.45
2004 Leaf Limited - [Base] - Spotlight Gold #57

Jay Payton #/25

$9.44
2005 Donruss Champions - [Base] - Impressions Materials #34

Jay Payton

4 from
$2.27
1996 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Refractor #141

Jay Payton

3 from
$8.59
1995 Bowman's Best - Blue - Refractor #62

Jay Payton

$6.29
2006 Upper Deck Special F/X - [Base] - Red #330

Jay Payton #/50

$4.72
2003 Playoff Piece of the Game - Player Collection #_JAPA

Jay Payton #/100

3 from
$3.42
2005 Donruss Prime Patches - Major League Materials - Double Swatch #MLM-4

Jay Payton #/150

$8.59
2005 Uno Boston Red Sox - [Base] #Y9

Jay Payton

$6.58
2004 Leaf Certified Cuts - [Base] - Marble Red Signatures #158

Jay Payton #/100

$5.37
2004 Leaf Certified Cuts - [Base] - Marble Blue #158

Jay Payton [EX to NM] #/50

$8.58
2006 Upper Deck Sweet Spot - Super Sweet Swatch - Platinum #SW-JA

Jay Payton #/45

2 from
$6.29
2001 Pacific Private Stock - Game-Used Gear #118

Jay Payton

2 from
$4.80
2005 Uno Boston Red Sox - [Base] #B9

Jay Payton

$6.50
2001 SPx - [Base] - Spectrum #74

Jay Payton #/50

$8.30
2003 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Refractor #305

Jay Payton #/699

$8.30
2002 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Gold Refractor #378

Jay Payton [EX to NM]

$8.02
2003 Leaf - Clean Up Crew #5

Larry Walker, Todd Helton, Jay Payton

$7.44
2005 Donruss Prime Patches - Major League Materials - Jersey Number Patch #MLM-4

Jay Payton #/111

$7.10
2001 Topps Finest - Authentic Autograph #FA-JP

Jay Payton

2 from
$6.75
2001 Bowman's Best - Locker Room Collection Jerseys #LRCJ-JP

Jay Payton

4 from
$5.99
2005 Donruss Prime Patches - Major League Materials - Jumbo Swatch #MLM-4

Jay Payton [Noted] #/500

$4.34
2001 Topps - [Base] #293

Jay Payton

4 from
$3.69
2001 Fleer Showcase - Autographics #_JAPA

Jay Payton

3 from
$3.30
1997 Select - [Base] - Artist's Proof #137

Jay Payton

2 from
$2.96
2004 Leaf Certified Materials - [Base] - Red Mirror Autographs #90

Jay Payton #/250

5 from
$3.41
2004 Donruss Leather & Lumber - [Base] - Silver Signatures #122

Jay Payton #/50

$6.87
2004 Fleer Authentix - [Base] - Club Box #43

Jay Payton #/25

$6.29
2004 Fleer Authentix - [Base] - Balcony #43

Jay Payton #/100

$6.29
1999 Skybox Thunder - [Base] - Rave #229

Jay Payton #/150

$6.29
2004 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Gold Refractor #23

Jay Payton

$6.29
2002 Upper Deck MVP - Souvenir Jerseys #J-JP

Jay Payton

2 from
$6.29
2004 Donruss Team Heroes - [Base] - Showdown Gold #142

Jay Payton #/10

$5.43
2001 Fleer Futures - [Base] - Black Gold #101

Jay Payton [EX to NM] #/499

$3.99
2004 Leaf Certified Materials - [Base] - Blue Mirror #90

Jay Payton #/50

3 from
$3.39
2001 Topps Finest - Finest Moments - Refractor #FM6

Jay Payton

$9.74
2001 Topps Heritage - [Base] #312

Jay Payton

3 from
$4.59
1997 Donruss Signature Series - Authentic Signatures #_JAPA

Jay Payton [EX to NM]

2 from
$3.69
1996 Best Minor League - Autographs #_JAPA

Jay Payton

4 from
$3.12
1995 Topps - [Base] #443

Jay Payton

4 from
$1.16
2004 Donruss World Series - [Base] - Platinum Holofoil 25 #WS-146

Jay Payton #/25

$5.99
2000 Pacific Private Stock - [Base] - Premiere Date #93

Jay Payton #/34

$5.99
1996 Bowman's Best - [Base] - Atomic Refractor #111

Jay Payton

$5.99
2004 Donruss Studio - [Base] - Private Signings Gold #160

Jay Payton #/17

$4.64
2004 Donruss Classics - [Base] - Timeless Tributes Green #98

Jay Payton #/50

3 from
$3.27
2009 Topps - [Base] - Target Throwback #189

Jay Payton

2 from
$2.27
2004 Playoff Honors - [Base] - Credits Bronze #161

Jay Payton #/100

$1.91
2001 SPx - Winning Materials Triple Jersey Combo #PPV

Jay Payton, Mike Piazza, Robin Ventura [Good to VG‑EX]

$5.60
2005 Donruss Prime Patches - Major League Materials - Jumbo Swatch #MLM-4

Jay Payton #/500

4 from
$2.29
2003 Topps Heritage - [Base] #397

Jay Payton

$5.14
2007 Topps Heritage - [Base] #121

Jay Payton

8 from
$2.73
2002 Topps - [Base] - Gold #378

Jay Payton #/2,002

4 from
$2.15
2005 Donruss - [Base] - Blue Press Proof #170

Jay Payton #/100

$5.13
2005 Leaf - [Base] - Blue Press Proof #164

Jay Payton #/75

$5.13
2004 Upper Deck Etchings - Baseball Etching Bats - Blue #BE-JP

Jay Payton

2 from
$3.81
2004 Donruss - [Base] - Press Proof Blue #258

Jay Payton #/100

$4.85
2000 Pacific Crown Royale - [Base] - Numbered Rookies #91

Jay Payton #/499

5 from
$1.32
2004 Playoff Honors - [Base] - Silver Signatures #161

Jay Payton #/100

$4.84
2001 Pacific - [Base] - Extreme LTD #275

Jay Payton #/45

2 from
$4.68
2000 Pacific Crown Royale - [Base] - Premiere Date #91

Jay Payton #/121

2 from
$3.77
2003 Donruss Studio - [Base] - Studio Proof #120

Jay Payton #/100

3 from
$1.35
2002 Fleer Tradition - [Base] #371

Jay Payton

3 from
$1.23
2001 Fleer Showcase - Autographics - Silver #_JAPA

Jay Payton #/250

2 from
$4.82
2004 Donruss Throwback Threads - Player Threads #PT-29

Jay Payton #/250

$4.80
<< 1 2 3 4 5 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 5