Buy Now, Ship Later: Save on shipping, consolidate orders, and avoid short-term delays due to high seasonal volume.

By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
Indianapolis Colts MultiSport Cards
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Sold Out
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
MultiSport (389)
2020's (43)
2010's (173)
2000's (86)
1990's (81)
1980's (6)
Listings 1 - 100 of 389
1996 Score Board All Sport PPF - [Base] - Gold #142

Marvin Harrison

10 from
$1.81
1994 Classic 4 Sport - Classic Picks #P2

Marshall Faulk #/24,900

11 from
$2.38
2002-03 Upper Deck UD Superstars - Legendary Leaders Triple #MM/PM/SY-L

Mark McGwire, Peyton Manning, Steve Yzerman #/250

$97.99
2023 Panini National Convention - VIP #N4

Anthony Richardson

18 from
$2.78
1996 Assets - Phone Cards - $1 #7

Marshall Faulk [EX to NM]

$1.92
2023 Panini National Convention - [Base] - Orange #18

Jonathan Taylor #/199

$6.29
2024 Panini Black Friday - Football - Holo #FB21

Peyton Manning #/150

2 from
$9.74
1997 Score Board Talkn' Sports - $1 Phone Cards #2

Marshall Faulk [EX to NM]

$1.40
2012 Topps National Convention - Gypsy Queen Minis #GQF1

Andrew Luck

$11.75
2022 Panini National Convention - [Base] - Red #13

Jonathan Taylor #/99

$3.99
2002-03 Upper Deck UD Superstars - [Base] #105

Edgerrin James

3 from
$2.44
2002-03 Upper Deck UD Superstars - [Base] #106

Peyton Manning

10 from
$1.23
1996 Score Board All Sport PPF - [Base] - Gold #90

Marshall Faulk

$2.01
2002-03 Upper Deck UD Superstars - Rookie Review #R4

Vince Carter, Peyton Manning

6 from
$2.38
1996 Clear Assets - [Base] #36

Marshall Faulk

9 from
$0.91
2013 Panini Father's Day - [Base] - Lava Flow #7

Andrew Luck #/25

4 from
$7.14
2000 Sports Illustrated for Kids Series 2 - [Base] #915

Edgerrin James [Good to VG‑EX]

2 from
$1.29
2000 Sports Illustrated for Kids Series 2 - [Base] #874

Flashback - Peyton Manning

7 from
$1.52
2006-07 Upper Deck Tuff Stuff - Magazine Insert [Base] #TSUD-15

Peyton Manning

6 from
$1.31
2008 Donruss Americana Sports Legends - Museum Collection - Gold #MC-26

Eric Dickerson #/100

2 from
$3.70
2022 Panini National Convention - National - Orange #N3

Peyton Manning #/199

4 from
$4.27
2024 Panini National Convention - Rookies - Foil #RC2

Laiatu Latu

12 from
$0.92
1996 Assets - Phone Cards - Hot Print $2 #4

Isaac Bruce

2 from
$5.19
1996 Assets - Phone Cards - $10 #4

Marshall Faulk

$3.47
1996 Score Board Autographed Collection - Game Breakers - Gold #GB26

Marvin Harrison

5 from
$2.87
1996 Assets - [Base] - Hot Print #10

Marshall Faulk

4 from
$1.52
1997 Score Board Talkn' Sports - $1 Phone Cards #2

Marshall Faulk

2 from
$3.24
2008 Donruss Americana Sports Legends - Museum Collection #MC-26

Eric Dickerson #/1,000

13 from
$1.34
1996 Assets - Phone Cards - Hot Print $2 #7

Marshall Faulk

3 from
$2.99
2010 Panini National Convention - Certified #PM

Peyton Manning

4 from
$1.40
2006 Sports Illustrated for Kids Series 4 - [Base] #26

Edgerrin James [Poor to Fair]

$9.74
1994 Classic 4 Sport - High Voltage #HV5

Marshall Faulk #/5,495

2 from
$8.59
2009 Upper Deck National Convention - [Base] #NC-23

Peyton Manning

2 from
$5.18
2009 Upper Deck 20th Anniversary Retrospective - [Base] #1990

Sports - Peyton Manning

2 from
$2.78
1995 Sports Illustrated for Kids Series 2 - [Base] #384

Marshall Faulk [EX to NM]

2 from
$0.96
2023 Panini National Convention - [Base] #18

Jonathan Taylor

12 from
$1.09
2014 Panini Black Friday - [Base] #7

Andrew Luck

16 from
$0.74
1995 Classic Images Four Sport - Images 95 Preview #IP3

Marshall Faulk #/5,000

3 from
$2.84
2024 Panini National Convention - [Base] - Blue #13

Anthony Richardson #/50

$12.04
2024 Panini National Convention - [Base] - Orange #13

Anthony Richardson #/199

$2.27
2023 Panini National Convention - Rookies #RC3

Anthony Richardson #/499

12 from
$2.93
2023 Panini National Convention - Rookies - Orange #RC3

Anthony Richardson #/199

$17.79
2009 Upper Deck 20th Anniversary Retrospective - [Base] #1184

Sports - Peyton Manning

3 from
$2.28
2001 Upper Deck Super Bowl Card Show - e-Cards - Scratched #PM

Peyton Manning

4 from
$5.41
1996 Score Board Autographed Collection - Game Breakers - Gold #GB19

Marshall Faulk

2 from
$23.54
1996 Score Board Autographed Collection - Game Breakers #GB26

Marvin Harrison

2 from
$7.44
1996 Score Board Autographed Collection - Game Breakers #GB19

Marshall Faulk

2 from
$14.34
2024 Panini Black Friday - Football - Purple #FB21

Peyton Manning #/25

2 from
$14.34
1987 Motto Game Cards - [Base] #655

Indianapolis Colts

2 from
$1.40
2024 Panini National Convention - Rookies - Orange #RC2

Laiatu Latu #/199

4 from
$1.34
2024 Panini National Convention - Rookies #RC2

Laiatu Latu #/399

7 from
$1.05
2021 Panini National Convention VIP Gold Pack - [Base] #17

Peyton Manning

3 from
$1.69
1995 Classic Images Four Sport - Clear Excitement #E2

Marshall Faulk [EX to NM] #/300

$39.64
2023 Panini National Convention - Rookies #RC15

Josh Downs #/499

6 from
$3.07
1995 Classic Images Four Sport - [Base] #39

Marshall Faulk

43 from
$0.80
2024 Panini National Convention - [Base] - Red #13

Anthony Richardson #/99

2 from
$17.79
2016 Panini National Convention - [Base] #28

Andrew Luck

18 from
$0.61
2023 Panini National Convention VIP Gold Pack - [Base] #RC3

Anthony Richardson

6 from
$21.82
2015 Panini Black Friday - [Base] #44

Phillip Dorsett #/599

22 from
$0.78
2004 National Trading Card Day - [Base] #UD-11

Peyton Manning

59 from
$0.82
2008 Upper Deck 20th Anniversary - [Base] #UD-21

Peyton Manning

38 from
$0.99
2019 Panini National Convention - [Base] - Explosion #11

Andrew Luck #/40

$4.45
1996 Score Board All Sport PPF - [Base] #90

Marshall Faulk

33 from
$0.74
2012 Panini Black Friday - Panini Collection #14

Andrew Luck

8 from
$2.27
1989 Foot Locker Slam Fest - [Base] #4

Eric Dickerson [EX to NM]

$1.69
2024 Panini National Convention - [Base] #13

Anthony Richardson

9 from
$0.98
2024 Panini National Convention - [Base] - Foil #13

Anthony Richardson

4 from
$1.58
2010 Sports Illustrated for Kids Series 4 - [Base] #446

Peyton Manning

2 from
$5.72
2017 Sports Illustrated for Kids Series 5 - [Base] #621

T.Y. Hilton

2 from
$3.07
2024 Panini National Convention - Rookies - Blue #RC2

Laiatu Latu #/50

2 from
$6.29
2012 Panini Toronto Fall Expo - Score Hot Rookies #7

Andrew Luck #/399

2 from
$6.00
1996 Classic Visions Signings - [Base] #31

Marshall Faulk

7 from
$0.89
2009 Upper Deck National Convention - VIP #VIP-9

Peyton Manning

35 from
$1.28
2024 Panini Black Friday - Football - Blue #FB21

Peyton Manning #/50

$12.04
1989 Sports Illustrated for Kids Series 1 - [Base] #86

Eric Dickerson

11 from
$1.20
2006 Upper Deck Hawaii Trade Conference - Autographs #HTC-10

Peyton Manning #/15

$470.00
1995 Classic 5 Sport Signings - [Base] - Red Foil Signature #S94

Marshall Faulk #/1,995

20 from
$2.54
2022 Panini National Convention - [Base] - Orange #13

Jonathan Taylor #/199

3 from
$6.29
2019 Panini National Convention - Legends #PM.2

Peyton Manning (Colts) #/299

$6.29
2008 Sports Illustrated for Kids Series 4 - [Base] #307

Peyton Manning

$79.89
2012 Panini National Convention - [Base] #21

Rookie - Andrew Luck #/499

15 from
$3.90
2012 Panini National Convention - [Base] - Cracked Ice #21

Rookie - Andrew Luck #/25

$22.00
1995 Sports Illustrated for Kids Series 2 - [Base] #384

Marshall Faulk [Poor to Fair]

3 from
$2.19
2017 Panini National Convention - VIP Prizm #20

Peyton Manning

22 from
$1.39
2024 Panini National Convention - [Base] - Cracked Ice #13

Anthony Richardson #/25

$8.36
1995 Sports Illustrated for Kids Series 2 - [Base] #384

Marshall Faulk [Good to VG‑EX]

$3.22
1996 Sports Illustrated for Kids Series 2 - [Base] #476

Jim Harbaugh

7 from
$1.03
1991 Classic Draft Picks - [Base] #136

Shane Curry

3 from
$0.99
1996 Score Board All Sport PPF - [Base] #142

Marvin Harrison

25 from
$0.99
2014 Panini Father's Day - #WhoDoYouCollect Memorabilia #AL3

Andrew Luck

3 from
$3.99
2024 Panini Black Friday - Football #FB21

Peyton Manning

$6.29
2019 Panini National Convention - Materials #DL

Darius Leonard

$3.27
2015 Panini National Convention - [Base] #19

Andrew Luck

41 from
$0.63
2019 Panini National Convention - Rookies #RC16

Parris Campbell #/299

19 from
$0.93
1993 Sports Illustrated for Kids Series 2 - Uncut 9-Card Sheet #118-126

Nancy Kerrigan, Steve Young, Sarah Billmeier, Juan Gonzalez, Karl Malone, Andre…

$21.38
2004 Sports Illustrated for Kids Series 3 - Uncut 9-Card Sheet #361-369

Todd Helton, Peja Stojakovic, Freddy Adu, Courtney Kupets, Marc Bulger, Kerry W…

$4.85
2000 Sports Illustrated for Kids Series 2 - [Base] #915

Edgerrin James

5 from
$3.13
2024 Panini National Convention - Rookies - Red #RC2

Laiatu Latu #/99

$2.55
2023 Panini National Convention VIP Gold Pack - [Base] - Red Sparkle Prizm #RC3

Anthony Richardson #/199

3 from
$52.29
1996 Assets - Clear Assets - A Cut Above #CA11

Marshall Faulk

7 from
$1.17
<< 1 2 3 4 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 4