By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
Indianapolis Colts Hall of Fame Football Cards Graded
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Sold Out
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Football (769)
2020's (40)
2010's (30)
2000's (163)
1990's (527)
1980's (6)
1960's (2)
1950's (1)
Listings 1 - 100 of 769
2017 Panini Prizm - NFL MVPs - Gold Mojo Prizm #35

Peyton Manning [BGS 9 MINT] #/10

$471.10
1998 SP Authentic - [Base] #14

Future Watch - Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/2,000

$1,404.99
1998 Flair Showcase - [Base] - Legacy Collection Row 3 #3

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/100

$1,432.66
1998 Bowman Chrome - [Base] - Interstate Refractor #1

Peyton Manning [BGS 9 MINT]

$1,131.10
2017 Panini Phoenix - Retired Patches #RP-PM

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/10

$230.88
1998 Upper Deck SPx Finite - [Base] #181

Rookies - Peyton Manning [PSA 7 NM] #/1,998

$580.55
2020 Panini National Treasures - Treasure Chest #TC-HOF

Andre Reed, Barry Sanders, Cris Carter, Curtis Martin, Earl Campbell, Eric Dick…

$908.90
2001 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Refractor #98

Peyton Manning [SGC 10 GEM] #/999

$746.10
1998 Topps Stars - [Base] #67

Peyton Manning [BGS 9.5 GEM MINT] #/8,799

$581.10
2003 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection - Ultimate Signatures - Gold #US-PM

Peyton Manning [PSA 7 NM] #/50

$580.00
2017 Panini Select - [Base] - Light Blue Prizm #146

Premier Level Die-Cut - Peyton Manning [BGS 9 MINT] #/99

$120.88
1998 Bowman Chrome - Preview #BCP1

Peyton Manning [BGS 9.5 GEM MINT]

$498.60
1998 Upper Deck Encore - Super Powers #S8

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$471.10
1998 Bowman - Scout's Choice #SC1

Peyton Manning [BGS 9.5 GEM MINT]

$470.00
1998 Bowman Chrome - [Base] #1

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$335.60
1998 Bowman Chrome - Preview - Refractor #BCP1

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$340.28
2010 Topps Finest - [Base] #10

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$186.66
2010 Panini Rookies & Stars - [Base] #152

Elements - Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$186.66
2009 SP Threads - [Base] #76

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$186.66
2008 Score - [Base] #127

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$186.66
2000 SPx - [Base] #34

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$186.66
1999 Leaf Rookies & Stars - [Base] #86

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$186.66
1999 Topps Finest - [Base] #142

Sensations - Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$186.66
2009 Donruss Gridiron Gear - [Base] #73

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

2 from
$37.74
2002 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] - Super Bowl Predictor Red #162

Dwight Freeney [PSA 9 MINT] #/29

$448.90
2020 Panini Phoenix - Regeneration #5

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$438.82
2009 Upper Deck Football Heroes - [Base] - Gold Autographs #32

Peyton Manning [SGC 8 NM/Mt] #/10

$406.00
1998 Playoff Momentum SSD - [Base] #98

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$396.10
2010 Score - NFL Players - Red Zone #16

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/100

$394.45
2000 Topps Finest - [Base] - Gold Refractor Die-Cut #44

Marvin Harrison [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/300

$369.70
2023 Panini Limited - Limited INK - Amethyst Spotlight #LI-PM

Peyton Manning [BGS Authentic] #/10

$274.18
1994 SP - [Base] #3

Premier Prospects - Marshall Faulk [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$689.99
1999 Skybox Molten Metal - Gridiron Gods - Gold #13GG

Edgerrin James [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$285.00
1998 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] #195

1998 NFL Draft Pick - Peyton Manning [BGS 9 MINT]

$285.00
1998 Skybox EX 2001 - Stardate 2001 #15 S

Peyton Manning [SGC 9.5 Mint+]

$285.00
1998 Bowman - [Base] #1

Peyton Manning [CSG 10 Gem Mint]

$285.00
1998 Topps Chrome - [Base] #165

Draft Picks - Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$225.60
1998 Topps Finest - [Base] #121

Rookie - Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$217.90
1998 Topps Chrome - [Base] #165

Draft Picks - Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

3 from
$115.20
2020 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Red Prizm #91

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$284.99
2019 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Red Prizm #142

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$284.99
1998 Bowman's Best - [Base] #112

Peyton Manning [BGS 9 MINT]

4 from
$50.12
1998 Collector's Edge 1st Place - [Base] #135.2

Peyton Manning (1998 Rookie Record Setter) [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$284.98
2009 Donruss Classics - [Base] - Timeless Tributes Platinum #44

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/25

$230.18
1998 Ultra - [Base] #201

Rookie - Peyton Manning [BGS 9 MINT]

$274.00
1998 Skybox EX 2001 - [Base] #54

Peyton Manning [BGS 9.5 GEM MINT]

$269.60
1998 Playoff Contenders - Leather Footballs - Silver #37

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$257.50
1998 Topps Finest - [Base] #121

Rookie - Peyton Manning [BGS 8.5 NM‑MT+]

2 from
$57.75
1994 SP - [Base] - Die-Cut #3

Premier Prospects - Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

$253.10
2007 Upper Deck Artifacts - NFL Facts #NF-PM

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$231.10
2008 Topps Finest - [Base] #3

Peyton Manning [SGC 100 PRISTINE]

$231.10
2003 Donruss Elite - Back to the Future #BF-3

Marvin Harrison [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/1,000

$231.10
1998 Skybox EX 2001 - Stardate 2001 #15 S

Peyton Manning [BGS 9 MINT]

$231.10
1994 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] - Super Teams Winners Super Bowl XXIX #327

Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

$231.10
1994 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] - Members Only #327

Marshall Faulk [PSA 8.5 NM‑MT+]

$231.10
1998 Topps Finest - [Base] #121

Rookie - Peyton Manning [BGS 9 MINT]

2 from
$102.60
1998 Upper Deck Encore - Super Powers #S8

Peyton Manning [BGS 9 MINT]

$230.00
1998 Playoff Momentum SSD - Headliners #16

Peyton Manning [BGS 9 MINT]

$230.00
1998 Metal Universe - [Base] #189

Peyton Manning [SGC 9.5 Mint+]

$230.00
1998 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] #195

1998 NFL Draft Pick - Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$173.90
1999 Topps Chrome - Record Numbers - Refractor #RN9

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$229.99
1998 Ultra - [Base] #416

Rookie - Peyton Manning [BCCG 10 Mint or Better]

2 from
$229.99
2000 Score - Complete Players - Green #CP 18

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$228.90
1998 Topps Stadium Club - Prime Rookies #PR10

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$224.50
2006 Donruss Gridiron Gear - [Base] - Silver #46

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$220.10
2005 Leaf Rookies & Stars Longevity - [Base] #43

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$220.10
2003 Leaf Limited - [Base] - Silver Spotlight #40

Johnny Unitas [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/75

$209.10
1999 Pacific Paramount - [Base] - Holo-Silver #101

Peyton Manning [BGS 9.5 GEM MINT] #/99

$207.95
1999 Pacific Aurora - Complete Players #5

Peyton Manning [TAG 8 NM MT] #/299

$203.60
1998 Topps - [Base] #360

Draft Picks - Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

4 from
$100.72
2000 Donruss Preferred QBC - Lettermen #LM01

Peyton Manning [BGS 9.5 GEM MINT] #/1,000

$198.10
1999 Bowman - Unexpected Delights #U2

Early Risers - Peyton Manning [BGS 9.5 GEM MINT]

$197.00
1998 Ultra - [Base] #201

Rookie - Peyton Manning [BGS 8.5 NM‑MT+]

$197.00
1998 Bowman - [Base] - Interstate #1

Peyton Manning [BGS 8 NM‑MT]

$197.00
2004 Topps Pristine - [Base] #35

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$187.10
1996 Topps Finest - [Base] #243

Marvin Harrison [BGS 9.5 GEM MINT]

$186.00
1998 Topps Chrome - [Base] #165

Draft Picks - Peyton Manning [BGS 8.5 NM‑MT+]

$177.22
1998 Skybox EX 2001 - [Base] #54

Peyton Manning [BGS 9 MINT]

2 from
$49.70
1995 Classic Pro Line - Autographs #_MAFA.1

Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT] #/1,030

$181.60
1998 Leaf Rookies & Stars - [Base] #270

Power Tools - Peyton Manning [BGS 9 MINT]

$180.50
2009 Donruss Limited - Pro Bowl Materials Quads - Prime #3

Andre Johnson, Reggie Wayne, Wes Welker, Tony Gonzalez [SGC 9 MINT] #…

$177.20
1998 Collector's Edge 1st Place - [Base] #135.3

Peyton Manning (1998 Top Rookie AFC) [BGS 9.5 GEM MINT]

$176.10
2018 Panini Black Friday - Panini Collection #PM

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/199

$176.10
2000 Topps Finest - Finest Moments - Refractor Autographs #FM9

Edgerrin James [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$176.10
2007 Leaf Limited - [Base] #42

Peyton Manning [BGS 9.5 GEM MINT] #/659

$176.10
2003 Upper Deck Super Bowl XXXVII - Stadium Giveaway [Base] #SB-8

Peyton Manning [BGS 9.5 GEM MINT]

$176.10
2002 Topps Finest - [Base] #1

Peyton Manning [CGC 10 Gem Mint]

$176.10
1999 Score Supplemental - 2000 Quantum Leaf Previews #QLP-7

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$176.10
1998 SP Authentic - Maximum Impact #SE11

Peyton Manning [SGC 10 GEM]

$176.10
2000 Topps Finest - [Base] - Gold Refractor Die-Cut #44

Marvin Harrison [PSA 9 MINT] #/300

$176.09
1998 Topps Chrome - [Base] #165

Draft Picks - Peyton Manning [BGS 9 MINT]

$175.00
1998 Score - [Base] #233

Rookie - Peyton Manning [BGS 9 MINT]

$175.00
1998 Flair Showcase - [Base] - Row 3 #3

Peyton Manning [BGS 9.5 GEM MINT]

$175.00
1998 Upper Deck UD Choice - [Base] #193

Rookie Class - Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$174.99
1998 Fleer Brilliants - [Base] #120

Peyton Manning [BGS 9 MINT]

$174.99
1998 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookie Edition - [Base] #91

Rookie Diamond - Peyton Manning [CGC 10 Gem Mint]

$174.99
1999 Topps Finest - Future's Finest #FF7

Edgerrin James [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/500

$173.89
2007 Topps Finest - [Base] - Green Refractor #1

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/199

$165.26
2003 Leaf Limited - [Base] - Gold Spotlight #42

Marvin Harrison [PSA 9 MINT] #/25

$165.10
1998 Skybox EX 2001 - Stardate 2001 #15 S

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$164.00
<< 1 2 3 4 5 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 8