By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
Indianapolis Colts Football Cards Graded PSA
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Sold Out
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Football (1,005)
2020's (426)
2010's (170)
2000's (120)
1990's (251)
1980's (30)
1970's (7)
1960's (1)
Listings 1 - 100 of 1,005
1998 SP Authentic - [Base] #14

Future Watch - Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/2,000

$1,404.99
2012 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Black Refractor #1

Andrew Luck [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/299

$275.10
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Red Wave Prizm Autographs #343

Rookies - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/149

$1,295.00
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Blue Ice Prizm #343

Rookies - Anthony Richardson [PSA 9 MINT] #/99

$1,186.10
1998 Topps Chrome - [Base] #165

Draft Picks - Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$1,447.77
2017 Panini Phoenix - Retired Patches #RP-PM

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/10

$230.88
2012 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Blue Refractor #1

Andrew Luck [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/199

$230.88
2012 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Prism Refractor #1

Andrew Luck [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/216

2 from
$230.88
2012 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Military Refractor #1

Andrew Luck [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/499

10 from
$120.88
1998 Upper Deck SPx Finite - [Base] #181

Rookies - Peyton Manning [PSA 7 NM] #/1,998

$580.55
2012 Topps Chrome - [Base] - BCA Refractor #1

Andrew Luck [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/399

2 from
$208.88
2020 Panini Select - Select Signatures - Green Prizm #SS-JTA

Jonathan Taylor [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/5

$966.10
2012 Panini Contenders - [Base] #201.1

Rookie Ticket RPS - Andrew Luck (Ball in Right Hand) [PSA 9 MINT] #/5…

$186.88
2012 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Retail X-Fractor #1

Andrew Luck [PSA 10 GEM MT]

14 from
$90.64
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Silver Prizm Autographs #343

Rookies - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT]

2 from
$286.10
2003 Bowman Chrome - [Base] - Gold Refractor #126

Dallas Clark [PSA 9 MINT] #/50

$635.00
2023 Panini Select - Rookie Signatures - Silver Prizm #RSI-ARI

Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/199

$498.60
2012 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Blue Refractor #1

Andrew Luck [PSA 9 MINT] #/199

$121.10
2003 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection - Ultimate Signatures - Gold #US-PM

Peyton Manning [PSA 7 NM] #/50

$580.00
2018 Panini Contenders - [Base] #319

Rookie Ticket/Rookie Ticket Variation - Darius Leonard [PSA 10 GEM&nb…

$120.88
2012 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Prism Refractor #1

Andrew Luck [PSA 9 MINT] #/216

3 from
$103.52
2012 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Retail Purple Refractor #1

Andrew Luck [PSA 9 MINT] #/499

5 from
$70.17
2012 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Retail Orange Refractor #1

Andrew Luck [PSA 10 GEM MT]

2 from
$46.20
2023 Panini Clearly Donruss - [Base] - Pink #52

Rated Rookie - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/10

$553.60
2023 Panini Clearly Donruss - [Base] - Blue Autographs #52

Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/99

$526.10
1998 Upper Deck Encore - Super Powers #S8

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$471.10
2023 Panini Mosaic - [Base] - White Sparkle Prizm #282

Rookies - Anthony Richardson [PSA 9 MINT]

$385.10
1998 Bowman Chrome - [Base] #1

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$395.00
2010 Topps Finest - [Base] #10

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$186.66
2010 Panini Rookies & Stars - [Base] #152

Elements - Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$186.66
2009 SP Threads - [Base] #76

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$186.66
2008 Score - [Base] #127

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$186.66
2000 SPx - [Base] #34

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$186.66
1999 Leaf Rookies & Stars - [Base] #86

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$186.66
1999 Topps Finest - [Base] #142

Sensations - Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$186.66
2009 Donruss Gridiron Gear - [Base] #73

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

2 from
$31.65
2002 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] - Super Bowl Predictor Red #162

Dwight Freeney [PSA 9 MINT] #/29

$448.90
2024 Panini Prizm - [Base] - No Huddle Neon Green Prizm #303

Rookies - Adonai Mitchell [PSA 9 MINT] #/10

$440.10
2023 Panini Phoenix - [Base] - Blue Ice Autographs #103

Rookies - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/15

$396.10
2001 Fleer Ultra - [Base] - Platinum Medallion #228P

Peyton Manning [PSA 7 NM] #/50

$396.10
2014 Panini National Treasures - Signatures - Black #S-AL

Andrew Luck [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/3

$396.10
1998 Playoff Momentum SSD - [Base] #98

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$396.10
2023 Topps Composite - Topps Chrome Autographs - Orange Geometric Refractor #TCA-AR

Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/25

$338.35
2010 Score - NFL Players - Red Zone #16

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/100

$394.45
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Blue Wave Prizm #343

Rookies - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/199

$368.60
1998 Skybox Premium - [Base] - Star Rubies #51

Aaron Bailey [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/50

$360.90
1996 Select Certified Edition - [Base] - Premium Stock #91

Marvin Harrison [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$341.10
2023 Topps Composite - Topps Chrome Black Autographs #TCBA-AR

Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$291.60
2023 Topps Composite - Chrome Radiating Rookies #CRR-3

Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$291.60
2020 Panini Mosaic - [Base] - Reactive Green Mosaic Prizm #276

NFL Debut - Jonathan Taylor [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$275.10
1998 Bowman Chrome - Preview - Refractor #BCP1

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$434.60
1998 Press Pass - Autographs #_PEMA

Peyton Manning [PSA 6 EX‑MT]

$340.00
2020 Panini Mosaic - Rookie Autographs Mosaic #RA16

Jonathan Taylor [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$340.00
2020 Panini Phoenix - Regeneration #5

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$328.82
2012 Topps Chrome - 1957 Design - Refractor #2

Andrew Luck [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/99

2 from
$327.90
2020 Panini Mosaic - [Base] - Fluorescent Pink Mosaic Prizm #214

Rookies - Michael Pittman Jr. [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/10

$313.60
1994 SP - [Base] #3

Premier Prospects - Marshall Faulk [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$689.99
1999 Skybox Molten Metal - Gridiron Gods - Gold #13GG

Edgerrin James [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$285.00
1998 Topps Chrome - [Base] #165

Draft Picks - Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$225.60
1998 Topps Finest - [Base] #121

Rookie - Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$217.90
1998 Topps Chrome - [Base] #165

Draft Picks - Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

3 from
$102.59
2020 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Red Prizm #91

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$284.99
2019 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Red Prizm #142

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$284.99
1998 Collector's Edge 1st Place - [Base] #135.2

Peyton Manning (1998 Rookie Record Setter) [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$284.98
2009 Donruss Classics - [Base] - Timeless Tributes Platinum #44

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/25

$257.57
2024 Topps Chrome - All-Etch Autographs - Red Refractor #AEA-AR

Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/5

$258.60
1998 Playoff Contenders - Leather Footballs - Silver #37

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$257.50
2012 Topps Chrome - [Base] - BCA Refractor #1

Andrew Luck [PSA 9 MINT] #/399

$52.46
1994 SP - [Base] - Die-Cut #3

Premier Prospects - Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

$253.10
2020 Panini Contenders Optic - [Base] #116

Rookie Ticket RPS Autographs - Jonathan Taylor [PSA 9 MINT]

$231.10
2007 Upper Deck Artifacts - NFL Facts #NF-PM

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$231.10
2003 Donruss Elite - Back to the Future #BF-3

Marvin Harrison [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/1,000

$231.10
1994 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] - Super Teams Winners Super Bowl XXIX #327

Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

$231.10
1994 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] - Members Only #327

Marshall Faulk [PSA 8.5 NM‑MT+]

$231.10
1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning - [Base] #_PEMA.2

Peyton Manning (Holding jersey) [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$230.00
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Silver Prizm #304.2

Rookie Variation - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$89.38
2023 Topps Composite - Resurgence Amped Up Patch Autographs - Red Power Surge Refractor #RAUPA-AR

Anthony Richardson [PSA 9 MINT] #/5

$229.99
2000 Score - Complete Players - Green #CP 18

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$228.90
2006 Donruss Gridiron Gear - [Base] - Silver #46

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$220.10
2005 Leaf Rookies & Stars Longevity - [Base] #43

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$220.10
2023 Panini Certified - New Generation Jerseys - Mirror Purple #NGJM-23

Anthony Richardson [PSA 9 MINT] #/10

$214.60
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Silver Prizm Autographs #343

Rookies - Anthony Richardson [PSA 9 MINT]

$209.10
2003 Leaf Limited - [Base] - Silver Spotlight #40

Johnny Unitas [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/75

$209.10
2023 Panini Mosaic - Kaleidoscopic #KA-3

Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$169.50
1998 Topps - [Base] #360

Draft Picks - Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

3 from
$120.00
1999 Topps Chrome - Record Numbers - Refractor #RN9

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$197.16
2023 Panini Donruss Optic - Rookie Recruits - Black Pandora Prizm #1

Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/25

$191.99
2004 Topps Pristine - [Base] #35

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$187.10
2023 Panini Donruss Optic - [Base] - Teal Velocity Prizm #247

Rated Rookie - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$181.60
1995 Classic Pro Line - Autographs #_MAFA.1

Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT] #/1,030

$181.60
2023 Panini Donruss Optic - Mythical #22

Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$176.10
2020 Panini Origins - Rookie Autographs - Blue #RA-MP

Michael Pittman Jr. [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/49

$176.10
2018 Panini Black Friday - Panini Collection #PM

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/199

$176.10
1998 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] - First Day Issue #73

Marvin Harrison [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/200

$176.10
1999 Score Supplemental - 2000 Quantum Leaf Previews #QLP-7

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$176.10
1998 Upper Deck UD Choice - [Base] #193

Rookie Class - Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$174.99
2023 Panini Mosaic - [Base] - Reactive Yellow Mosaic Prizm #282

Rookies - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT]

2 from
$40.73
2020 Panini Select - [Base] - Cosmic Prizm #262

Club Level - Michael Pittman Jr. [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$174.95
1999 Topps Finest - Future's Finest #FF7

Edgerrin James [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/500

$173.89
2013 Panini Crown Royale - [Base] - Retail Black Die-Cut Crown #141

Jack Doyle [PSA 7 NM] #/1

$169.49
<< 1 2 3 4 5 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 11