By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
Indianapolis Colts Hall of Fame Serial Numbered Football Cards Graded PSA
Sort By
Listings
Listings 1 - 83 of 83
1998 SP Authentic - [Base] #14

Future Watch - Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/2,000

$1,404.99
2017 Panini Phoenix - Retired Patches #RP-PM

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/10

$230.88
1998 Upper Deck SPx Finite - [Base] #181

Rookies - Peyton Manning [PSA 7 NM] #/1,998

$580.55
2003 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection - Ultimate Signatures - Gold #US-PM

Peyton Manning [PSA 7 NM] #/50

$580.00
2001 Fleer Ultra - [Base] - Platinum Medallion #228P

Peyton Manning [PSA 7 NM] #/50

$396.10
2010 Score - NFL Players - Red Zone #16

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/100

$394.45
2009 Donruss Classics - [Base] - Timeless Tributes Platinum #44

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/25

$257.57
2003 Donruss Elite - Back to the Future #BF-3

Marvin Harrison [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/1,000

$231.10
2003 Leaf Limited - [Base] - Silver Spotlight #40

Johnny Unitas [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/75

$209.10
1995 Classic Pro Line - Autographs #_MAFA.1

Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT] #/1,030

$181.60
2018 Panini Black Friday - Panini Collection #PM

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/199

$176.10
1998 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] - First Day Issue #73

Marvin Harrison [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/200

$176.10
1999 Topps Finest - Future's Finest #FF7

Edgerrin James [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/500

$173.89
2003 Leaf Limited - [Base] - Gold Spotlight #42

Marvin Harrison [PSA 9 MINT] #/25

$165.10
2000 Leaf Limited - [Base] #170

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/2,000

$143.10
1999 Donruss Elite - Passing the Torch #3

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/1,500

$143.09
2007 Topps Finest - [Base] - Green Refractor #1

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/199

$142.14
2004 Fleer Authentix - [Base] - Mezzanine Bronze #54

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/50

$121.10
2002 SP Legendary Cuts - [Base] #168

Destined for Glory - Dwight Freeney [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/1,100

2 from
$121.10
2011 Panini Crown Royale - [Base] - Green #78

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/10

$120.00
2009 Topps - [Base] - Gold #300

Pro Bowl - Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/2,009

$114.68
1999 Fleer Focus - [Base] - Stealth #36

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/300

$114.10
2005 Ultimate Collection - Ultimate Game Jerseys - Spectrum #GJ-PM

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/25

$103.74
2024 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Purple Ice Prizm #126

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/225

$102.60
2002 Topps Pristine - [Base] #127

Dwight Freeney [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/999

$101.45
2022 Panini Classics - Monday Night Heroes - Blue #MN-6

Eric Dickerson [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/5

$98.00
1998 Topps Stars - [Base] #67

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/8,799

$93.40
2006 Playoff Absolute Memorabilia - Team Quads - Spectrum #TQ-5

Peyton Manning, Marvin Harrison, Edgerrin James, Reggie Wayne [PSA 6 …

$92.25
2002 Bowman - [Base] - Silver #164

Dwight Freeney [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/250

$92.20
2024 Topps Chrome - Autographs - Green Geometric Refractor #BA-EJA

Edgerrin James [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/99

$91.10
1999 Fleer Focus - [Base] - Stealth #36

Peyton Manning [PSA 7 NM] #/300

$91.10
2016 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Blue Wave Prizm #125

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/149

$83.65
2024 Topps Midnight - Constellations - Dusk #C-22

Peyton Manning, Eli Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/75

$81.90
2024 Topps Resurgence - [Base] - White Surge Refractor #44

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/125

$37.63
1998 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookie Edition - White Onyx Rookies #ON1

Peyton Manning [PSA 7 NM] #/2,250

$76.74
1999 Pacific Revolution - [Base] - Opening Day #73

Edgerrin James [PSA 6 EX‑MT] #/68

$76.15
2005 Leaf Certified Materials - [Base] - Mirror Blue Materials #53

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/50

$70.40
1997 Leaf - Run & Gun #15

Marshall Faulk, Jim Harbaugh [PSA 7 NM] #/3,500

$70.40
2000 Collector's Edge Masters - [Base] #76

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/2,000

$70.39
2024 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Red Wave Prizm #126

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/149

$68.10
2021 Panini Donruss Elite - Field Vision - Orange #FV10

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/25

$62.88
2009 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Copper Refractor #TC96

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/649

$62.88
2022 Panini National Treasures - [Base] - Gold #21

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/35

$58.90
2003 Leaf Rookies & Stars - [Base] - Longevity #36

Peyton Manning [PSA 5 EX] #/100

$58.90
2010 Score - All-Pro - Scorecard #1

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/499

$58.33
1999 Flair Showcase - [Base] #176

Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT] #/1,999

2 from
$38.19
2024 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Aqua Refractor #86

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/199

$57.74
2005 Leaf Certified Materials - Fabric of the Game #FG-96

Randy Moss, Marvin Harrison [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/100

$57.74
1998 Leaf Rookies & Stars - Game Plan #2

Peyton Manning [PSA 7 NM] #/5,000

$57.70
2001 Upper Deck - [Base] - Gold #68

Peyton Manning [PSA 7 NM] #/100

$56.60
1999 Donruss Preferred QBC - X-Ponential Power #5b

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/2,500

$56.60
1999 Upper Deck Century Legends - [Base] - Die-Cut #88

Marshall Faulk [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/100

$48.32
1998 Collector's Edge Masters - [Base] - 50-Point Gold #S182

Marshall Faulk [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/150

$48.32
2011 Topps Finest - [Base] - X-Fractor #80

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/399

$53.15
1999 Playoff Prestige SSD - [Base] - Spectrum Blue #B053

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/500

$52.00
2015 Topps Finest - [Base] - Blue Refractor #136

Andre Johnson [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/250

$47.40
1998 Topps Stars - [Base] - Gold #67

Peyton Manning [PSA 7 NM] #/1,999

$47.40
1995 Select Certified Edition - Select Few - Dufex #3

Marshall Faulk [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/2,250

$47.39
2002 Fleer Tradition - [Base] - Tiffany #222

Edgerrin James [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/225

$47.17
2020 Panini Phoenix - Flame Throwers - Bronze #23

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/50

$40.50
1995 Collector's Edge - Sunday Ticket Time Warp #5

Dick Butkus, Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT] #/10,000

$40.50
1998 Upper Deck SPx Finite - [Base] #287

Extreme Talent - Peyton Manning [PSA 6 EX‑MT] #/7,200

$38.50
2002 Fleer Tradition - [Base] - Mini #222

Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT] #/125

$39.45
1999 Fleer Mystique - [Base] #107

Rookie - Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT] #/2,999

$35.90
1999 Fleer Focus - [Base] #149

Rookie - Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT] #/2,500

$34.75
1999 Donruss Preferred QBC - National Treasures #21

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/2,000

$34.75
2000 Collector's Edge Graded - [Base] - Uncirculated #147

Marvin Harrison [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/5,000

$33.59
1999 Donruss - Elite Inserts #EL18

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/2,500

$29.00
1999 Donruss - Elite Inserts #EL18

Peyton Manning [PSA 7 NM] #/2,500

$29.00
2000 Collector's Edge Graded - [Base] - Uncirculated #150

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/5,000

6 from
$24.86
1999 Collector's Edge Masters - [Base] - Galvanized #85

Marvin Harrison [PSA 9 MINT] #/1,000

2 from
$24.86
2000 Collector's Edge Graded - [Base] - Uncirculated #148

Edgerrin James [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/5,000

5 from
$24.34
1994 Classic Images - All-Pro #A20

Marshall Faulk [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/2,600

$27.84
1999 Collector's Edge Masters - [Base] - Galvanized #86

Edgerrin James [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/1,000

$25.54
2000 Leaf Certified - Fabric of the Game #FG-61

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/500

$23.25
2000 Collector's Edge Graded - [Base] - Uncirculated #148

Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT] #/5,000

$12.88
2005 Ultimate Collection - [Base] #39

Peyton Manning [PSA 7 NM] #/550

$23.24
1999 Playoff Prestige SSD - [Base] - Spectrum Blue #B152

Repeat Performers - Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/500

$22.10
1999 Fleer Focus - [Base] #149

Rookie - Edgerrin James [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/2,500

$15.20
2000 Collector's Edge Graded - [Base] - Uncirculated #147

Marvin Harrison [PSA 9 MINT] #/5,000

$16.34
1999 Donruss Elite - Primary Colors - Yellow #2

Marshall Faulk [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/1,875

$17.49
1996 Collector's Edge - Proteges #5

Marshall Faulk, Terrell Davis [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/1,500

$15.78
1996 Donruss - [Base] - Press Proof #235

Rookie - Marvin Harrison [PSA 5 EX] #/2,000

$13.93
Go to page
Page 1 of 1