By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
Indianapolis Colts Hall of Fame Football Cards Graded PSA 9 MINT
Sort By
Listings
Listings 1 - 100 of 137
1998 Upper Deck Encore - Super Powers #S8

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$471.10
2002 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] - Super Bowl Predictor Red #162

Dwight Freeney [PSA 9 MINT] #/29

$448.90
1998 Bowman Chrome - Preview - Refractor #BCP1

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$434.60
1998 Topps Chrome - [Base] #165

Draft Picks - Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$225.60
2020 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Red Prizm #91

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$284.99
1994 SP - [Base] - Die-Cut #3

Premier Prospects - Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

$253.10
1994 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] - Super Teams Winners Super Bowl XXIX #327

Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

$231.10
2000 Score - Complete Players - Green #CP 18

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$228.90
1998 Topps - [Base] #360

Draft Picks - Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

3 from
$120.00
1999 Topps Chrome - Record Numbers - Refractor #RN9

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$197.16
1995 Classic Pro Line - Autographs #_MAFA.1

Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT] #/1,030

$181.60
1999 Score Supplemental - 2000 Quantum Leaf Previews #QLP-7

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$176.10
2003 Leaf Limited - [Base] - Gold Spotlight #42

Marvin Harrison [PSA 9 MINT] #/25

$165.10
1998 Skybox EX 2001 - Stardate 2001 #15 S

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$164.00
1998 Playoff Contenders - Leather Footballs - Silver #37

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$153.00
1995 SP - Holoview #7

Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

$148.60
1998 Playoff Absolute Retail - [Base] #165

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$87.64
2000 Leaf Limited - [Base] #170

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/2,000

$143.10
1999 Donruss Elite - Passing the Torch #3

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/1,500

$143.09
1998 Bowman Chrome - [Base] #1

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

6 from
$69.25
2002 Bowman Chrome - [Base] #227

Rookie Autograph - Dwight Freeney [PSA 9 MINT]

$115.24
1995 Bowman's Best - Mirror Image Draft Picks - Refractor #2

Marshall Faulk, Tony Boselli [PSA 9 MINT]

$115.24
1998 Collector's Edge Odyssey - [Base] #212 S

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$110.65
1998 Leaf Rookies & Stars - [Base] #270

Power Tools - Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$109.50
2005 Ultimate Collection - Ultimate Game Jerseys - Spectrum #GJ-PM

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/25

$103.74
1994 Topps Stadium Club - Bowman's Best #1.2

Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

$103.74
1996 Pinnacle - [Base] - Trophy Collection #166

Rookie - Marvin Harrison [PSA 9 MINT]

$97.99
1998 Collector's Edge Advantage - [Base] - Silver #189

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$92.24
1998 Topps Action Flats - [Base] #K5

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$87.65
1998 Leaf Rookies & Stars - [Base] #233

Rookie - Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$173.90
1996 Topps Finest - [Base] #243

Marvin Harrison [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$32.80
1998 Flair Showcase - [Base] - Row 3 #3

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$86.49
1998 Bowman's Best - Performers #BP1

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$86.49
2024 Topps Resurgence - [Base] - White Surge Refractor #44

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/125

$37.63
1999 Collector's Edge 1st Place - Excalibur #X13

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$37.63
1997 Topps Finest - [Base] #161

Marvin Harrison [PSA 9 MINT]

$37.63
1999 Playoff Momentum SSD - [Base] #154

Rookie - Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$29.00
1998 Fleer Brilliants - [Base] #120

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$80.74
1996 Pinnacle - [Base] - Artist's Proof #166

Rookie - Marvin Harrison [PSA 9 MINT]

$80.74
1998 Topps Finest - [Base] #121

Rookie - Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$69.25
1998 Topps Season Opener - [Base] #1

Draft Picks - Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$76.15
1998 Playoff Momentum SSD - [Base] #98

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$75.00
1998 Skybox EX 2001 - [Base] #54

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$140.00
1998 Bowman's Best - [Base] #112

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$102.59
1998 Upper Deck UD Choice - [Base] #193

Rookie Class - Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$76.15
1998 Bowman - [Base] #1

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

5 from
$53.15
1998 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] #195

1998 NFL Draft Pick - Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

3 from
$48.84
2000 Collector's Edge Masters - [Base] #76

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/2,000

$70.39
1999 Upper Deck - [Base] #88

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$70.23
2009 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Copper Refractor #TC96

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/649

$62.88
1996 Bowman's Best - Mirror Image - Refractor #6

Rodney Hampton, Lawrence Phillips, Marcus Allen, Marshall Faulk [PSA 9&nbs…

$58.90
2010 Score - All-Pro - Scorecard #1

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/499

$58.33
1998 Topps Gold Label - [Base] - Class 1 #20

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

3 from
$68.10
1998 Skybox Thunder - [Base] #239

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$57.75
1996 SP - [Base] #18

Premier Prospects - Marvin Harrison [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$40.50
1999 Flair Showcase - [Base] #176

Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT] #/1,999

2 from
$38.19
1999 Topps Chrome - [Base] #145

1999 NFL Draft Pick - Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT]

10 from
$23.48
2024 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Aqua Refractor #86

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/199

$57.74
1999 Donruss Preferred QBC - X-Ponential Power #5b

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT] #/2,500

$56.60
2002 Playoff Contenders - [Base] #30

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$55.40
1999 Donruss Preferred QBC - [Base] #93

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$54.29
2009 Topps Chrome - [Base] #TC96.1

Peyton Manning (Blue Jersey) [PSA 9 MINT]

$53.15
2007 Topps Chrome - [Base] #TC5

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$53.15
1998 Pacific Omega - [Base] #101

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$51.99
1999 Leaf Rookies & Stars - [Base] #252

Rookie - Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT]

$53.14
2002 Upper Deck - UD Uniforms #UDU-PM

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$50.84
2020 Panini Mosaic - Men of Mastery - Mosaic Prizm #MM16

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$49.70
2024 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Silver Prizm #126

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$22.10
2000 Fleer Ultra - [Base] - Gold Medallion #150G

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$47.39
1998 Topps Stadium Club - Double Threat #DT1

Marshall Faulk, Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$35.04
2007 Topps Chrome - [Base] - X-Fractor #TC80

Marvin Harrison [PSA 9 MINT]

$46.24
1994 Score - [Base] #277

Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$40.50
2006 Topps Chrome - [Base] #8

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$41.65
1999 Bowman - [Base] #70

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$41.65
1995 SP - All-Pro #AP-1

Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

$41.65
1994 Topps - [Base] #445

Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

$41.65
1999 Skybox EX Century - [Base] #69

Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$34.74
1999 Topps Finest - [Base] #152

Rookies - Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$30.15
1998 Collector's Edge 1st Place - [Base] #135.3

Peyton Manning (1998 Top Rookie AFC) [PSA 9 MINT]

$75.21
1996 Select Certified Edition - [Base] #91

Marvin Harrison [PSA 9 MINT]

$41.65
1999 Bowman Chrome - [Base] #70

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$40.50
1995 Collector's Edge - Sunday Ticket Time Warp #5

Dick Butkus, Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT] #/10,000

$40.50
1999 Bowman Chrome - [Base] #161

Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT]

$30.15
1994 SP - [Base] #3

Premier Prospects - Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

27 from
$22.10
2002 Fleer Tradition - [Base] - Mini #222

Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT] #/125

$39.45
2017 Panini Classics - Classic Clashes #CC-TBPM

Tom Brady, Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$39.34
1999 Pacific Paramount - [Base] #100

Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT]

$35.90
1999 Fleer Mystique - [Base] #107

Rookie - Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT] #/2,999

$35.90
2001 Topps - [Base] - Topps Collection #136

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$25.55
2020 Panini Prizm - [Base] #91

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$34.75
2000 Bowman Chrome - [Base] #112

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$34.75
1999 Leaf Certified - Gold Future #4

Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT]

$34.75
1999 Fleer Focus - [Base] #149

Rookie - Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT] #/2,500

$34.75
1996 Topps - [Base] #426

96 Draft Pick - Marvin Harrison [PSA 9 MINT]

$34.75
1996 Fleer Metal - [Base] #135

Marvin Harrison [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$34.75
1994 Fleer Ultra - [Base] #133

Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

$34.75
1994 Select - [Base] #200

Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

$28.95
1999 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] #155

Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT]

$24.75
2008 Topps Chrome - [Base] #TC10

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$34.74
1999 Collector's Edge Odyssey - [Base] #65

Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT]

4 from
$30.14
<< 1 2 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 2