Buy Now, Ship Later to save on shipping, consolidate your orders, and avoid peak holiday shipping times.

By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
New York Yankees Hall of Fame Baseball Cards Ungraded
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Sold Out
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Baseball (31,531)
2020's (4,527)
2010's (6,204)
2000's (12,444)
1990's (4,484)
1980's (2,587)
1970's (652)
1960's (438)
1950's (158)
1940's (26)
1930's (10)
1920's (1)
Listings 1 - 100 of 31,531
2022 Topps Diamond Icons - Immortal Cut Signatures #ICS-JD

Joe DiMaggio #/1

$2,886.81
1990 Upper Deck - Reggie Jackson Baseball Heroes #9.2

Reggie Jackson (Autographed) #/2,500

$2,230.28
2021 Topps Rip - [Base] - Red #40

Derek Jeter #/1

$1,350.11
1999 Topps Tek - [Base] - Gold Pattern 26 #24B

Derek Jeter #/10

$910.66
2024 Topps Tier One - Tier One Sluggers Triple Autograph Relics #T1ST-JOR

Derek Jeter, David Ortiz, Alex Rodriguez #/10

$1,736.10
2012 Panini National Treasures - [Base] - Nicknames Prime Button #125

Derek Jeter #/4

$1,020.44
2004 Leaf Certified Materials - [Base] - Gold Mirror Bat #233

Babe Ruth #/25

$1,624.95
2017 Panini National Treasures - 16-Player Materials Booklet #PMB1-16

Barry Larkin, Cal Ripken, Frank Thomas, George Brett, Greg Maddux, Ken Griffey …

$1,571.10
1996 Select Certified Edition - [Base] - Mirror Red #100

Derek Jeter #/90

$1,570.00
2008 Topps - New York Stadiums Commemorative Manufactured Patches #CPR-DJ

Derek Jeter #/100

$646.17
1997 Score Team Collection - New York Yankees - Premier Club #3

Derek Jeter

$1,194.54
2022 Topps Diamond Icons - Icons of the Diamond Autographs - Canary #IOTD-DJ

Derek Jeter #/10

$959.89
2021 Topps Sterling - Sterling Strikes Autograph Relics - Silver #STAR-MR

Mariano Rivera #/1

$959.89
2019 Panini National Treasures - 16 Player Materials Booklets - Holo Silver #16-DEC

Mickey Mantle, Hoyt Wilhelm, Whitey Ford, Frank Robinson, Johnny Bench, Rod Car…

$1,131.10
2008 Playoff Prime Cuts - Material Combos #7

Lou Gehrig, Roberto Clemente [Uncirculated] #/25

$1,076.10
2012 SP Signature Edition - Enshrinement Triple Signatures #E3-KFC

Sandy Koufax, Whitey Ford, Steve Carlton [COMC RCR Mint or …

$1,130.50
1967 Topps - [Base] #150

Mickey Mantle [Good to VG‑EX]

$580.50
2025 Topps Diamond Icons - Iconic Chrome Autographs #ACC-DJ

Derek Jeter #/25

$1,130.00
2008 SP Legendary Cuts - Legendary Memorabilia - Violet #LM-BR

Babe Ruth #/25

$690.44
2008 Ultimate Collection - Double Memorabilia Autographs #UM-RJ

Reggie Jackson #/5

$470.66
2002 Fleer Ultra - Fall Classic - Autographs #_DEJE

Derek Jeter [BGS Encased]

$824.01
1964 Topps - [Base] - Venezuelan #50

Mickey Mantle [Poor to Fair]

2 from
$965.28
1958 Topps - [Base] #150

Mickey Mantle [Good to VG‑EX]

$1,019.40
2001 Upper Deck Hall of Famers - Game Jersey #J-LG

Lou Gehrig

$773.87
1969 Topps - [Base] #500.2

Mickey Mantle (Last Name in White) [COMC RCR Poor]

$954.00
2009 Topps Sterling - Career Chronicles Relics Triple #3CCR-99

Lou Gehrig [Noted] #/25

$916.00
2010 Topps Sterling - Sterling Pairs Relics #SPR-7

Mickey Mantle, Mark Teixeira #/10

$867.10
2018 Panini Flawless - Greats Dual Memorabilia Autographs - Ruby #GDM-MR

Mariano Rivera [Uncirculated] #/10

$910.00
1961 Post - [Base] #4.2

Mickey Mantle (Perforated) [Good to VG‑EX]

$274.20
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Blue Rainbow Foil Autographs #346-A

1971 Topps Baseball - C.C. Sabathia by Action Bronson [Uncirculated] #/10

$909.99
2001 Upper Deck - Pinstripe Exclusives Joe DiMaggio - Game-Used Jersey #JD-CJ2

Mickey Mantle, Joe DiMaggio [Good to VG‑EX] #/100

$558.44
2022 Topps Stadium Club Members Only Derek Jeter - The Captain's Career - Gold #CC-39

Derek Jeter #/2

$856.10
2005 Donruss Signature Series - Hall of Fame - Bat #HOF-31

Babe Ruth

$525.77
1959 Topps - [Base] #10

Mickey Mantle [Good to VG‑EX]

3 from
$580.00
2011 Topps Triple Threads - Legends Triple Relics #TTRL-5

Joe DiMaggio #/36

$525.44
2010 Topps Update Series - All-Star Jumbo Patch #ASJP-CCS

C.C. Sabathia #/6

$800.27
2021 Panini Immaculate Collection - [Base] - Red #5

Mickey Mantle #/15

$318.66
2008 Playoff Prime Cuts - Material Quads #8

Lou Gehrig, Hank Aaron, Ted Williams, Willie Mays [Uncirculated] #/25

$761.52
1955 Bowman - [Base] #202

Mickey Mantle [Poor to Fair]

$795.60
2024 Panini National Treasures - Material Treasures - Emerald #MT-LG.1

Lou Gehrig #/5

$788.99
1947-66 Exhibits - W461 #_MIMA.2

Mickey Mantle (Batting Close-up; First Name Not Outlined in White) [Good t…

$746.10
1996 Pinnacle - Skylines #8

Wade Boggs

$745.00
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Artist Proof Silver Frame #328

Mikael B. - Mickey Mantle (1990 Topps Baseball) [Uncirculated] #/51

$744.99
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Artist Proof Silver Frame #321

Keith Shore - Mickey Mantle (1952 Topps Baseball) [Uncirculated] #/51

$744.99
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Artist Proof Silver Frame #174

1956 Topps Baseball - Mickey Mantle by The Shoe Surgeon [Uncirculated] #/51

$744.99
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Rainbow Foil #77

1961 Topps Baseball - Mickey Mantle by Joshua Vides [Uncirculated] #/70

$744.99
1954 Bowman - [Base] #65

Mickey Mantle [Poor to Fair]

$1,019.95
1966 Topps - [Base] #50

Mickey Mantle

$439.20
2019 Topps Allen & Ginter - Autographed Relic Book Cards #ARBC-MR

Mariano Rivera #/10

$691.09
2022 Topps Diamond Icons - Dual Player Dual Relic Book - Red #DPDR-JM

Mariano Rivera, Derek Jeter #/5

$439.39
2006 Bowman Sterling - [Base] - Black Refractor #BS-MCM

Mickey Mantle [Uncirculated] #/25

$689.95
2024 Topps Tier One - Autographed Tier One Relics #T1AR-DJ

Derek Jeter #/25

$688.35
2012 SP Signature Edition - Superstars Triple Signatures #SU3-AL-SS

Derek Jeter, Jed Lowrie, Alexei Ramirez #/10

$673.50
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Artist Autographs #70.2

1969 Topps Baseball - Lou Gehrig by Lauren Taylor (Red Ink) [Uncirculated] #/20

$634.99
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Artist Proof Silver Frame #608

Joshua Vides - Derek Jeter (2014 Topps Baseball) [Uncirculated] #/51

$634.99
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Rainbow Foil #250

1957 Topps Baseball - Lou Gehrig by Joshua Vides [Uncirculated] #/70

$634.99
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Rainbow Foil #70

1969 Topps Baseball - Lou Gehrig by Lauren Taylor [Uncirculated] #/70

$634.99
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Rainbow Foil #262

1958 Topps Baseball - Mickey Mantle by Brittney Palmer [Uncirculated] #/70

$634.99
2007 Topps Triple Threads - Double Combo Relics - Sepia #1

Mickey Mantle, Joe DiMaggio [Good to VG‑EX] #/27

$581.10
2009 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection - Ultimate Eight Memorabilia #U8M-15

Joe DiMaggio, Yogi Berra, Phil Rizzuto, Whitey Ford, Phil Hughes, Reggie Jackso…

$553.60
2020 Leaf Lumber Kings - Bat Rack Four - Silver #BR4-04

Babe Ruth, Mickey Mantle, Roger Maris, Reggie Jackson #/5

$553.60
1957 Jay Publishing World Series Pack - [Base] #_MIMA

Mickey Mantle

$581.05
2021 Panini National Treasures - Triple Legend Duos Booklets #TLDB-6

Albert Pujols, Lou Gehrig, Jimmie Foxx #/25

$581.05
1996 Leaf Signature Series - Autographs - Silver #_MARI

Mariano Rivera [Noted]

$580.49
1959 Topps - [Base] #10

Mickey Mantle

$853.57
2022 Topps Gold Label - [Base] - Class 2 Gold #78

Derek Jeter #/1

$580.00
1960 Topps - [Base] #350

Mickey Mantle [Poor to Fair]

2 from
$231.10
2011 Topps Triple Threads - Relic Double Combos - Sepia #TTRDC-8

Chase Utley, Dustin Pedroia, Robinson Cano, Jackie Robinson, Ryne Sandberg, Joe…

$579.99
1937 Goudey Thum-Movies Baseball Series - R342 [Base] - Blue Cover #4

Joe DiMaggio [Good to VG‑EX]

$579.99
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Artist Proof Silver Frame #473

1961 Topps Baseball - Mickey Mantle by Lauren Taylor [Uncirculated] #/51

$579.99
1939 Play Ball - [Base] #48.3

Lefty Gomez (Sample Overprint Back)

$579.99
2012 Topps - Classic Walk-Offs Relics #CWR-MM

Mickey Mantle #/50

$340.44
2001 Topps Tribute - Bat Relics #RB LG

Lou Gehrig

$340.44
2008 SPx - Babe Ruth American Legend - Boxscore #BR44

Babe Ruth #/1

$340.44
2008 Bowman Sterling - [Base] #BS-MM

Mickey Mantle

$340.44
2001 Upper Deck Sweet Spot - Game-Used Jerseys #J-MM

Mickey Mantle

2 from
$340.44
2001 Upper Deck Hall of Famers - Bat #B-MM

Mickey Mantle

$340.44
1998 Pinnacle - Epix Season - Purple #E8

Derek Jeter

$579.95
1967 Coke Bottle Caps - [Base] - Coke #V8

Mickey Mantle

$367.43
2005 Upper Deck Trilogy - Generations Present - Gold Materials #PR-DJ

Derek Jeter [EX to NM] #/25

$120.06
2014 Topps Allen & Ginter's - [Base] - Mini Red Bordered #41

Lou Gehrig #/33

$120.06
2024 Bowman Chrome - Prospects - Gold Refractor #BCP-253

Retrofractor - Lou Gehrig #/50

$574.61
2002 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection - Ultimate Game Jerseys - Tier 1 #JB-MM

Mickey Mantle #/99

$327.24
1976 Topps - [Base] - Topps Vault Blank Back #_LOGE

Lou Gehrig [Uncirculated]

$541.50
2021 Panini National Treasures - Decades Autograph Booklets - Holo Gold #DB-5

Bob Gibson, Brooks Robinson, Willie McCovey, Ernie Banks, Don Larsen, Bill Maze…

$526.10
1996 Sportflix - [Base] - Artist Proof #139

Derek Jeter

$526.10
2025 Topps Dynamic Duals - Online Exclusive [Base] - Gold #39

Francisco Lindor, Derek Jeter #/1

$476.60
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Artist Proof Silver Frame #368

1958 Topps Baseball - Derek Jeter by Morning Breath [Uncirculated] #/51

$524.99
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Artist Proof Silver Frame #370

Chuck Styles - CC Sabathia (1994 Topps Baseball) [Uncirculated] #/51

$524.99
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Artist Proof Silver Frame #471

2021 Topps Baseball - Babe Ruth by Gregory Siff [Uncirculated] #/51

$524.99
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Artist Proof Silver Frame #530

2021 Topps Baseball - Derek Jeter by DJ Skee [Uncirculated] #/51

$524.99
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Artist Proof Silver Frame #287

1966 Topps Baseball - Babe Ruth by Toy Tokyo [Uncirculated] #/51

$524.99
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Rainbow Foil #287

1966 Topps Baseball - Babe Ruth by Toy Tokyo [Uncirculated] #/70

$524.99
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Rainbow Foil #143

2016 Topps Baseball - CC Sabathia by Joshua Vides [Uncirculated] #/70

$524.99
2021 Topps Project 70 - Online Exclusive [Base] - Artist Proof Silver Frame #9

1961 Topps Baseball - Derek Jeter by New York Nico [Uncirculated] #/51

2 from
$258.60
2025 Topps Diamond Icons - Autographs #AC-DJ

Derek Jeter #/25

$493.05
2003 Leaf Certified Materials - [Base] - Mirror Gold Materials #121

Derek Jeter #/25

$471.10
2018 Panini National Treasures - 16 Player Materials Booklets #16-AM

Adrian Beltre, Albert Pujols, Brian Dozier, Carlos Correa, Corey Kluber, Eric H…

$471.10
2017 Leaf Babe Ruth Immortal Collection - Yankee Stadium Seat - Blue Spectrum #YS-18

Babe Ruth #/50

$470.28
2009 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection - Ultimate Six Memorabilia #U6M-23

Joe DiMaggio, Ted Williams, Roberto Clemente, Derek Jeter, Daisuke Matsuzaka, J…

$470.00
<< 1 2 3 4 5 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 316