Update: Packages will be coming more quickly - we've shortened turnaround times for Bulk shipments, from 5 weeks to 3.

By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
rc_card_man's Hall of Fame Rookie Year Football Cards Ungraded
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Football (203)
2020's (1)
2010's (7)
2000's (25)
1990's (131)
1980's (20)
1970's (15)
1960's (2)
1950's (1)
1940's (1)
Listings 1 - 100 of 203
1981 Topps - [Base] #216

Joe Montana [Noted]

$728.37
2022 Panini Flawless Collegiate - Flawless Dual Signatures #DS-PITT

Dan Marino, Kenny Pickett [Noted] #/25

$514.22
1950 Bowman - [Base] #37

Bobby Layne [Noted]

$156.94
1977 Topps - [Base] #177

Steve Largent [Encased]

$89.15
1998 Collector's Edge 1st Place - [Base] #135.1

Peyton Manning (Base) [Noted]

$23.31
1998 Ultra - [Base] #201

Rookie - Peyton Manning [Encased]

$93.52
2001 Press Pass - Jersey #JC/LT

LaDainian Tomlinson [Noted] #/400

$83.09
1989 Score - [Base] #257

Barry Sanders [Noted]

$92.24
1984 Topps - [Base] #63

John Elway [Noted]

$57.98
1995 Classic NFL Draft - 1st Round Picks - Printers Proof Missing Serial Number #12

Warren Sapp [Encased] #/97

$57.74
2007 Topps Co-Signers - [Base] - Blue Changing Faces Hyper Gold #38.2

John Elway, Trent Edwards [Noted] #/25

$57.74
1998 Collector's Edge - Promos #_PEMA.1

Peyton Manning (No Relic) [Encased]

$26.75
1995-00 Athletes in Action Tract Cards - [Base] #_CUMA

Curtis Martin [Noted]

$56.89
1999 Fleer Focus - Feel The Game #10FG

Kurt Warner [Noted]

$56.89
1992 Pro Line Portraits - National Convention Stamp #_CHBE

Chris Berman, [Noted]

2 from
$56.89
2008 SPx - Winning Trios - Numbered to 49 #WT33

Peyton Manning, Matt Schaub, Joe Flacco [Noted] #/49

$56.89
1998 Playoff Momentum SSD - Team Threads - Road Jerseys #18

Peyton Manning [Noted]

$56.89
1948 Leaf - [Base] #37

George Connor [Noted]

$55.74
1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning - [Base] #_PEMA.11

Peyton Manning (Holo- arm back/ball out of picture) [Encased]

$55.45
2002 SP Authentic - [Base] #222

Rookie Authentics - Julius Peppers [Noted] #/850

$52.29
2001 Pacific Private Stock - [Base] - Premiere Date #161

LaDainian Tomlinson [Noted] #/95

$46.68
1979 Topps - [Base] #390

Earl Campbell [Noted]

$38.49
1998 Collector's Edge 1st Place - Successors #16

Peyton Manning [Encased]

$35.89
1991 Fleer Ultra - [Base] #283

Brett Favre [Encased]

$35.89
1998 Collector's Edge Supreme Season Review - [Base] #74B.1

Peyton Manning [Noted]

$35.04
1977 Topps - [Base] #177

Steve Largent [Noted]

$33.88
1964 Philadelphia - [Base] #14

Colts' Play of the Year [Noted]

2 from
$14.33
1991 Upper Deck - [Base] #13

Brett Favre [Encased]

3 from
$30.14
1975 Topps - [Base] #282

Lynn Swann [Encased]

$30.14
1991 Pro Set - [Base] #762

2nd Round Draft Choice - Brett Favre [Encased]

$30.10
1995 Signature Rookies Auto-Phonex - $2 Phone Cards - Autographs #26

Curtis Martin [Noted] #/3,750

3 from
$16.35
2003 Bowman - Fabric of the Future #FA-AJ

Andre Johnson [Noted]

$26.16
1998 Playoff Contenders - Touchdown Tandems #18 T

Peyton Manning, Marshall Faulk [Noted]

$28.13
1995 Signature Rookies - [Base] - International Signatures #21

Terrell Davis [Noted] #/2,750

$25.84
1981 Topps Coca-Cola Washington Redskins - [Base] #5

Art Monk [Encased]

$16.35
1991 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] #94

Brett Favre [Noted]

$23.54
1998 Playoff Momentum SSD - [Base] #131

Randy Moss [Noted]

$23.53
1998 Pacific - [Base] - Red #181

Peyton Manning [Noted]

$23.53
2015 Panini Black Gold - Franchise Gold - White Gold Foil #FG-14

Marshall Faulk, Steven Jackson, Todd Gurley II [Noted] #/25

$23.24
1998 Collector's Edge 1st Place - [Base] #157.2

Randy Moss (1998 Rookie Record Setter) [Encased]

$23.20
1995 Signature Rookies - [Base] - Signatures #49

Curtis Martin [Noted] #/7,750

$18.94
1998 Bowman - Scout's Choice #SC12

Randy Moss [Encased]

$18.31
2000 Topps - [Base] - Topps Collection #383

NFL Draft Pick - Brian Urlacher [Noted]

$17.79
1991 Upper Deck - [Base] #13

Brett Favre [Noted]

$17.79
2007 Donruss Threads - Rookie Collection Combo Materials #RCM-12

Patrick Willis, Jason Hill [Noted] #/500

$15.81
1995 Signature Rookies Auto-Phonex - $2 Phone Cards - Autographs #19

Terrell Davis [Noted] #/3,750

$16.64
1972 Topps - [Base] #157

Emmitt Thomas [Noted]

$16.64
1999 Collector's Edge Odyssey - [Base] #123

Kurt Warner [Encased]

$15.20
2017 Donruss Optic - Illusions - Blue Prizm #8

Lance Alworth, Mike Williams [Noted] #/149

$15.06
2000 Upper Deck Victory - [Base] #274

Victory Rookie - Brian Urlacher [Noted]

$14.92
1995 Superior Pix - [Base] - Autographs #65

Curtis Martin [Noted] #/4,000

$14.92
1995 SP - [Base] #18

Premier Prospects - Curtis Martin [Noted]

$14.34
1986 Topps - [Base] #275

Reggie White [Noted]

2 from
$5.14
2001 Fleer Tradition - Rookie Retro Threads #_LATO.2

LaDainian Tomlinson (Jersey) [Noted]

$12.04
1998 Fleer Tradition - Rookie Sensations #9 RS

Peyton Manning [Noted]

2 from
$12.04
1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning - [Base] #_PEMA.6

Peyton Manning (Silver- ball at chest) [Noted]

$8.59
1990 Topps - Wax Box Bottom - With Disclaimer #C

Joe Montana, Vince Newsome [Noted]

$8.25
1999 NFL Players Party (Stay Cool in School) - [Base] #_KUWA

Kurt Warner (Pacific Paramount) [Encased]

$8.13
1999 Collector's Edge Advantage - [Base] - Millenium Collection Blue #170

Edgerrin James [Encased]

$11.74
1997 Collector's Edge Extreme - [Base] - 50-Point #80

Tony Gonzalez [Noted]

$11.70
1997 SP Authentic - [Base] #11

Future Watch - Tony Gonzalez [Noted]

2 from
$7.02
1999 Pacific Crown Royale - Franchise Glory #19

Kurt Warner [Noted]

$11.58
2002 Pacific Heads Update - [Base] - Blue #77

Dwight Freeney [Noted]

$10.89
2007 Topps Draft Picks and Prospects (DPP) - [Base] - Chrome Silver Refractor #105

Patrick Willis [Noted] #/125

$10.60
1997 Collector's Edge Extreme - [Base] #80

Tony Gonzalez [Encased]

$10.34
1994 Signature Rookies - [Base] #4

Larry Allen [Noted] #/45,000

$9.74
1998 Press Pass - [Base] - Pick Offs Blue #50

Peyton Manning [Noted]

$6.98
1971 Topps - [Base] #114

Willie Lanier [Noted]

2 from
$7.44
2001 Stadium Club - [Base] #140

LaDainian Tomlinson [Noted]

$4.43
1995 Classic NFL Draft - 1st Round Picks - Printers Proof Missing Serial Number #12

Warren Sapp [Noted] #/97

3 from
$8.30
1996 Pro Line II Memorabilia - [Base] #59

Ray Lewis [Noted]

$7.44
1991 Action Packed Rookie Update - [Base] #21

Brett Favre [Noted]

$7.44
1982 Topps - [Base] #487

In Action - Ronnie Lott [Noted]

$7.44
1984 Topps - [Base] #124

Instant Replay - Dan Marino [Noted]

2 from
$3.70
1989 Pro Set - [Base] #32

Thurman Thomas [Noted]

$6.29
1999 Pacific Prism - [Base] #147

Champ Bailey [Noted]

$4.57
1989 Score - [Base] #258

Derrick Thomas [Noted]

3 from
$3.39
1979 Topps - [Base] #301

Team Leaders - Earl Campbell, Willie Alexander, Ken Burrough, Elvin Bethea [Not…

2 from
$2.96
1999 Collector's Edge 1st Place - Rookie Gamegear - Hologold #RG9

Champ Bailey [Noted]

$6.28
2000 Collector's Edge T3 - [Base] - Retail #161

Brian Urlacher [Noted]

$6.28
1997 Stadium Club - Never Compromise #NC3

Tony Gonzalez [Noted]

$5.74
1998 Topps Stadium Club - Prime Rookies #PR9

Randy Moss [Noted]

$3.00
1994 Fleer GameDay - [Base] #179

Marshall Faulk [Noted]

$5.37
2007 Press Pass - [Base] - Blue Reflectors #45

Darrelle Revis [Noted]

$5.14
1994 Classic NFL Draft - Game Card #GC 2

Marshall Faulk [Noted]

$5.14
1993 Score Select - [Base] #172

Jerome Bettis [Noted]

$5.14
1989 Pro Set - [Base] #490

Troy Aikman [Noted]

$5.14
1993 Topps - [Base] #275

Michael Strahan, Marcus Buckley [Noted]

$4.68
1981 Topps - [Base] #150

Kellen Winslow Sr. [Noted]

3 from
$3.36
1993 Action Packed - [Base] #172

Jerome Bettis [Noted]

2 from
$1.68
1998 Upper Deck SPx Finite - [Base] - Radiance #310

Extreme Talent - Charles Woodson [Noted] #/3,600

$4.87
1998 Leaf Rookies & Stars - Freshman Orientation #20

Charles Woodson [Noted] #/2,500

$4.87
1994 Collector's Edge - Boss Squad #1-3

Marshall Faulk, Jerome Bettis, Erric Pegram [Noted]

$4.85
2001 Fleer Authority - Authority Figure #17 AF

Emmitt Smith, Quincy Carter [Noted] #/1,750

$4.85
1999 Upper Deck Century Legends - [Base] #135

Edgerrin James [Noted]

$4.85
1996 Fleer Ultra Sensations - [Base] #58

Zach Thomas [Noted]

$4.85
1999 Pacific Aurora - [Base] #147

Champ Bailey [Noted]

$0.98
1995 Fleer Ultra - [Base] - Gold Medallion #471

Rookie - Warren Sapp [Noted]

$4.59
1996 Pro Line II Memorabilia - [Base] #95

Marvin Harrison [Noted]

$4.68
1989 Topps - [Base] #383

Michael Irvin [Noted]

2 from
$4.28
<< 1 2 3 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 3