By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
bmcards_stl's Hall of Fame Pre-Rookie Card Baseball Cards
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Baseball (69)
2020's (18)
2010's (14)
2000's (15)
1990's (8)
1980's (13)
1970's (1)
Listings 1 - 69 of 69
2016 Topps Throwback Thursday #TBT - Online Exclusive [Base] #130

1990 Topps Design - Dwight D. Eisenhower [EX to NM] #/306

$34.74
2012 Panini Cooperstown - Bronze History #94

Ned Hanlon #/599

$14.33
1988 Fleer Update - [Base] - Glossy #U-74

John Smoltz

$11.69
1994 Ted Williams Card Company - [Base] #106

Bud Fowler

2 from
$10.87
1994 Ted Williams Card Company - [Base] #101

Willard Brown

$4.83
2004 Topps - 100th Anniversary of the Fall Classic Covers #FC1923

New York Yankees vs. New York Giants [EX to NM]

$15.19
2009 TRISTAR Obak - [Base] #93

Al Spalding

$5.42
1988 Fleer Update - [Base] - Glossy #U-89

Craig Biggio

$14.33
2004 Topps - 100th Anniversary of the Fall Classic Covers #FC1921

New York Giants vs. New York Yankees

$6.86
2019 Topps - Revolution of the Game #REV-11

Happy Chandler

$11.74
1987 The Sporting News Conlon Collection Baseball Immortals Series 2 - [Base] #53

Amos Rusie #/12,000

$11.74
2016 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Mini #24

Walter O'Malley

2 from
$7.43
2014 Panini Golden Age - [Base] - Mini Smith's Mello-Mint #4

Harry Wright

$7.14
2006 SP Legendary Cuts - [Base] #31

Hugh Duffy

$5.99
1994 Ted Williams Card Company - [Base] #103.1

Leon Day

$1.39
1987 The Sporting News Conlon Collection Baseball Immortals Series 2 - [Base] #35

Harry Hooper #/12,000

$5.99
1987 The Sporting News Conlon Collection Baseball Immortals Series 2 - [Base] #33

Hugh Duffy #/12,000

$5.99
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] #225

Cool Papa Bell

4 from
$5.13
2023 Panini Donruss - [Base] - Holo Orange #160

Cool Papa Bell

2 from
$4.84
2006 SP Legendary Cuts - [Base] #32

Kid Nichols

4 from
$3.98
2006 SP Legendary Cuts - [Base] #10

Elmer Flick

5 from
$2.83
1980-84 SSPC Baseball Immortals 1st Printing - [Base] #121

Chick Hafey

$2.72
2014 Panini Golden Age - Headlines #2

Eight Players Banned in Scandal

$2.51
2020 Panini Donruss - American Pride - Rapture #AP18

Tanner Allen, Ken Griffey Jr.

$1.57
2001 Fleer Greats of the Game - [Base] #134

Smokey Joe Williams

$1.39
1986 The Sporting News Conlon Collection Baseball Immortals Series 1 - [Base] #16

Miller Huggins #/12,000

$3.97
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Pulsar Prizm #225

Cool Papa Bell

$3.69
2020 Panini Donruss - American Pride - Vector #AP5

Austin Martin, Chipper Jones

3 from
$3.69
2009 TRISTAR Prospects Plus - [Base] #78

Diamond Duos - Ryne Sandberg, Brett Jackson

$3.69
2008 Upper Deck - Multi-Product Insert Yankee Stadium Legacy #YSL942

Joe McCarthy

$3.69
2008 Upper Deck - Multi-Product Insert Yankee Stadium Legacy #YSL749

Joe McCarthy

$3.69
1983 TCMA All-Time St. Louis Cardinals - [Base] - Brown Back #6

Chick Hafey

$3.69
1980-84 SSPC Baseball Immortals 1st Printing - [Base] - MLB Logo #121

Chick Hafey

$3.68
2006 SP Legendary Cuts - [Base] #85

Stan Coveleski

2 from
$3.64
1989 The Official Hall of Fame Fun & Fact Sticker Book Stickers - [Base] #86

Bill McKechnie

$3.41
1986 The Sporting News Conlon Collection Baseball Immortals Series 1 - [Base] #14

Mike Gonzalez, Frankie Frisch, Buzzy Wares #/12,000

2 from
$3.41
2013 Panini Cooperstown Collection - [Base] - Matrix #18

Miller Huggins #/325

$3.41
2014 Panini Golden Age - Star Stamps #2

Eddie Plank, Rube Waddell, Addie Joss, Lefty Williams

$3.35
2019 Topps - Revolution of the Game #REV-5

Albert Spalding

$2.13
2023 Panini Donruss - [Base] - Holo Blue #160

Cool Papa Bell

5 from
$1.67
1994 Ted Williams Card Company - [Base] #105

Rube Foster

$1.29
1992 Pacific McDonald's St. Louis Cardinals 100th Anniversary - [Base] #11

Chick Hafey

$3.12
2014 Panini Golden Age - [Base] - Mini MONO Green Back #19

Addie Joss

$3.11
1987 The Sporting News Conlon Collection Baseball Immortals Series 2 - [Base] #14

Chick Hafey #/12,000

$2.83
2016 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Mini #5

George Kelly

2 from
$2.83
2015 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Mini #56

George Kelly

$2.83
2008 Upper Deck - Multi-Product Insert Yankee Stadium Legacy #YSL750

Joe McCarthy

$2.83
2005 Hero Decks Presents St. Louis Baseball Heroes Playing Cards - [Base] #4C

Miller Huggins

$2.55
2005 Hero Decks Presents St. Louis Baseball Heroes Playing Cards - [Base] #8C

Chick Hafey

$2.55
2023 Panini Select - [Base] #66

Concourse - Pat Gillick

2 from
$2.54
2005 Upper Deck Classics - [Base] - Gold #16

Buck Leonard #/199

2 from
$2.54
1991 The Sporting News Conlon Collection - [Base] - No MLB Logo on Back #259

All Time Leader - Chick Hafey

$2.52
2024 Panini Prizm - [Base] #159

Cool Papa Bell

$2.49
2020 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Artist Proof Blue #8

Joe McCarthy

2 from
$2.49
2020 Panini Donruss - American Pride - Rapture #AP5

Austin Martin, Chipper Jones

$2.26
2014 Panini Golden Age - [Base] - Mini Hindu Brown Back #90

Marques Haynes

2 from
$2.24
2023 Panini Donruss - [Base] - Independence Day #160

Cool Papa Bell

$2.20
2018 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Artist Proof Gold #6

George Kelly #/99

$2.14
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Silver Prizm #293

Buck Leonard

$1.97
1981 Cramer Baseball Legends Series 2 - [Base] #58

Joe McCarthy

$1.97
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] #223

Dave Bancroft [EX to NM]

$1.96
2020 Panini Donruss - American Pride #AP5

Austin Martin, Chipper Jones #/999

$1.83
2023 Panini Select - [Base] #104

Premier Level - Cool Papa Bell

$1.68
2020 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Blue Frame #8

Joe McCarthy

$1.68
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] #223

Dave Bancroft

2 from
$1.67
1992 The Sporting News Conlon Collection - [Base] #657

Chick Hafey

$1.67
1977-84 TCMA Renata Galasso - [Base] #214

Series 5 - Max Carey

2 from
$1.37
2020 Panini Donruss - American Pride - Pink Fireworks #AP5

Austin Martin, Chipper Jones

$1.34
1992 The Sporting News Conlon Collection - [Base] #649

Miller Huggins

$1.34
Go to page
Page 1 of 1