Option to Add a Toploader is temporarily disabled. Due to the global toploader shortage, we are offering a Toploader Buyback Program.
Top
OldsThumper's Hall of Fame Baseball Cards
Sort By
Listings
 
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Baseball (60)
2020's (2)
2010's (20)
2000's (31)
1990's (4)
1980's (3)
Listings 1 - 60 of 60
2000 Topps Gallery - Heritage - Proof #TGH3

Greg Maddux

2019 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Red Prizm #261

Tier III - Nolan Ryan

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - Heritage Collection #HC-25

Babe Ruth

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - Heritage Collection #HC-2

Nolan Ryan

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - Heritage Collection #HC-5

Roberto Clemente

2020 Topps Update Series - 20 Years of the Captain Commemorative Patches #20YCC-11

Derek Jeter

2000 Topps Gallery - Heritage - Proof #TGH18

Tony Gwynn

2019 Topps Update Series - 150th Anniversary Manufactured Patch - 150th Anniversary #AMP-MR

Mariano Rivera #/150

2019 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Green and Yellow Hyper Prizm #290

Tier III - Tony Gwynn

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - Heritage Collection #HC-8

Kirby Puckett

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - Timeline #TL-8

Lou Gehrig, Cal Ripken Jr.

2017 Topps Update Series - MLB MVP Award Medallions #MVPR-CJ

Chipper Jones

1996 Topps Stadium Club - Mickey Mantle #MM1

Mickey Mantle

2019 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Red Mojo Prizm #256

Tier III - Mariano Rivera #/299

2000 Topps Gallery - Heritage - Proof #TGH4

Mike Piazza

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - [Base] - Sample Silver #126.1

Roberto Clemente (Cap Fully Visible)

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - [Base] #147

Cal Ripken Jr.

2019 Topps Finest - Finest Careers Die-Cut #FC-MR1

Mariano Rivera

2018 Panini Diamond Kings - DK Materials - Holo Silver #DKM-MP

Mike Piazza #/99

2017 Topps - MLB All-Star Game Patches #ASL-IR

Ivan Rodriguez

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - Heritage Collection #HC-24

Cal Ripken Jr.

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - Heritage Collection #HC-23

Rickey Henderson

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - Heritage Collection #HC-4

Ted Williams

2019 Topps Archives - [Base] - Silver #44

1958 Design - Jackie Robinson #/99

2019 Topps - 1984 Topps Baseball All-Stars - 150th Anniversary #84AS-OS

Ozzie Smith #/150

2007 Topps Heritage - 1958 Mickey Mantle Home Run Champion #MHRC42

Mickey Mantle

2007 Topps Heritage - 1958 Mickey Mantle Home Run Champion #MHRC6

Mickey Mantle

2000 Topps Gallery - Heritage - Proof #TGH20

Cal Ripken Jr.

2020 Panini Donruss Optic - Retro 1986 - Holo Prizm #R86-3

George Brett

2019 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Blue Prizm #279

Tier III - George Brett

1982 Baseball Card News - [Base] - History of Baseball Cards Backs #3

Stan Musial

2002 Fleer Platinum - Cornerstones - Numbered #15 CS

Willie McCovey, Ernie Banks #/500

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - Heritage Collection #HC-9

Andre Dawson

2019 Topps Update Series - [Base] #US21.2

SP Legend Variation - Willie Mays

2000 Topps - Hank Aaron Reprints #5

Hank Aaron (1958 Topps)

2016 Topps - MLB Debut Medallions #MDM-MP

Mike Piazza

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - [Base] #139

Nolan Ryan

2000 Topps Gallery - Heritage - Proof #TGH10

Randy Johnson

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - [Base] - Bronze Foil #143

Lou Gehrig

2019 Topps - Faces of the Franchise #FOF-16

Christian Yelich, Robin Yount, Rollie Fingers

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - [Base] - Sample Silver #127

Babe Ruth

2001 Topps Archives - [Base] #9

Willie Mays

2002 Fleer Platinum - Cornerstones #BTGS

Bill Terry, George Sisler

2 from
$3.70
1996 Topps Stadium Club - Mickey Mantle #MM2

Mickey Mantle

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - [Base] - Sample Silver #143

Lou Gehrig

1996 Topps - Mickey Mantle Commemorative Reprints - Finest #11

Mickey Mantle (1961 Topps)

2019 Topps - Faces of the Franchise #FOF-22

Starling Marte, Roberto Clemente, Honus Wagner

2019 Topps - [Base] #565.2

SP Greats Variation - Catfish Hunter

2001 Topps - Golden Anniversary #GA11

Cal Ripken Jr.

1996 Topps Stadium Club - Mickey Mantle #MM13

Mickey Mantle

2019 Topps - Evolution Of: Team Logos/Uniforms #EL-7

Mike Trout, Rod Carew [EX to NM]

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - Heritage Collection #HC-22

Catfish Hunter

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - Heritage Collection #HC-19

Paul Molitor

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - Heritage Collection #HC-12

Juan Marichal

2017 Panini Donruss - [Base] - Stat Line Career #180

Frank Thomas #/500

2019 Topps Chrome Update Series - Target The Family Business #FBC-1

Ken Griffey Jr.

1980-86 Cramer Baseball Legends - [Base] #13

Lou Gehrig

2019 Topps Chrome Update Series - Target 150 Years of Professional Baseball #150C-22

Hank Aaron

2002 Donruss Diamond Kings - Heritage Collection #HC-16

Randy Johnson

1980-86 Cramer Baseball Legends - [Base] #10

Sandy Koufax

Go to page
Page 1 of 1