By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
BMSCards's Hall of Fame Baseball Cards Ungraded
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Baseball (425)
2020's (85)
2010's (123)
2000's (74)
1990's (121)
1980's (20)
1970's (1)
1960's (1)
Listings 1 - 100 of 425
2001 Upper Deck Hall of Famers - [Base] #19

Willie Mays

$1.40
2015 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Silver #54

Gary Carter #/99

$17.50
1998 Ultra - Millennium Men #4 MM

Derek Jeter

$7.15
2003 Donruss Team Heroes - [Base] - Stat Line #228

Billy Wagner #/88

$14.05
2013 Panini Select - [Base] - Silver Prizm #123

Chipper Jones [EX to NM]

$14.05
2003 Topps Gallery - [Base] - Artist Proof #62

CC Sabathia

$12.04
2011 Topps - [Base] - Cognac Diamond Anniversary #530.2

SP - Legend Variation - Sandy Koufax

$17.50
1999 Topps Tek - [Base] - Pattern 11 #31B

Jeff Bagwell

$11.75
2001 Fleer Focus - ROY Collection #20 ROY

Jackie Robinson

$6.29
1999 SPx - Premier Stars #PS17

Greg Maddux

$6.29
2013 Panini Golden Age - [Base] - Nadja Caramels Mini #20

Edd Roush

$11.74
2003 Topps Gallery - [Base] - Artist Proof #92

Ivan Rodriguez

$11.74
1997 Upper Deck Collector's Choice - Clearly Dominant #CD4

Ken Griffey Jr. [EX to NM]

$11.74
1994 Upper Deck Fun Pack - [Base] #200

Ken Griffey Jr., Don Mattingly [Good to VG‑EX]

$10.03
2015 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Silver Prizm #168

Tony Gwynn [EX to NM]

$9.45
2015 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Mini #240

Mariano Rivera

$9.45
2004 Donruss Studio - Players Collection Relics - Red #PC-86

Scott Rolen #/150

$9.45
2003 Topps Gallery - [Base] - Artist Proof #75

Larry Walker

$9.45
1998 Ultra - Top 30 #23 T3

Ken Griffey Jr. [EX to NM]

$9.45
2021 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Plum Framed #9

Honus Wagner

$9.44
2018 Panini Contenders Draft Picks - [Base] - Draft Ticket #11.1

Craig Biggio (Pinstriped Jersey, Sunglasses) #/99

$9.17
2003 Donruss Studio - Stars #SS-7

Frank Thomas

$6.00
2011 Topps Lineage - [Base] - Diamond Anniversary #13

Cal Ripken Jr.

$4.57
1996 Topps Stadium Club - Mickey Mantle #MM13

Mickey Mantle

$1.69
2020 Topps - Decades Best Series 2 - Gold #DB-18

Pitchers - Fergie Jenkins #/50

$7.44
2004 Donruss Studio - [Base] - Studio Proofs Silver #71

Larry Walker #/100

$7.44
2017 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Brown Framed #38

Tony Lazzeri #/49

$7.44
2017 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Brown Framed #25

Luke Appling #/49

$7.44
2021 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Red White & Blue Prizm #157

Tier II - Rickey Henderson

$6.00
2013 Bowman - [Base] - Gold Border #141

Mariano Rivera

$1.98
2015 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Silver #108

Nellie Fox #/99

$7.15
2005 Upper Deck - Season Opener Jerseys #OD-JT

Jim Thome

$7.15
2021 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Artist Proof Gold #25

Joe Morgan #/49

$6.29
2007 SP Legendary Cuts - [Base] #110

Joe Sewell #/550

$6.29
1994 Topps Stadium Club - Super Team #15

Baltimore Orioles

$6.29
2021 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Red White & Blue Prizm #241

Tier III - Sandy Koufax [EX to NM]

$6.00
2021 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Plum Framed #74

Roberto Clemente

$6.00
2021 Panini Diamond Kings - Legacy Lithographs - Holo Blue #LL-18

David Ortiz #/99

$6.00
2020 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Gray Frame #118

SP - Johnny Bench

$6.00
2015 Bowman Chrome - [Base] - Refractor #52

Joe Mauer [EX to NM] #/499

$6.00
2015 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Gold #101

Mel Ott #/25

$6.00
2003 Donruss Classics - Legends of the Fall #LF-3

Roberto Clemente #/2,500

$6.00
2001 Topps Chrome - Through the Years Reprints #26

Tom Seaver

$6.00
1996 Pinnacle Summit - [Base] - Above and Beyond #76

Jim Thome

$6.00
2015 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Blue Framed #142

Whitey Ford #/99

2 from
$5.43
2015 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Silver #22

Cal Ripken #/99

3 from
$5.14
1996 Upper Deck - Retail Predictor #R24

Ken Griffey Jr.

$4.85
2020 Topps Allen & Ginter's - [Base] - Hot Box Silver Portrait #108

Gary Carter

$3.99
2015 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] #65

Jackie Robinson

$3.99
2013 Topps Museum Collection - [Base] #19

Hank Aaron

$3.99
1994 Fleer - Team Leaders #4

Frank Thomas

$3.42
2017 Panini Donruss Optic - [Base] - Pink Prizm #164

Tony Gwynn

$2.84
1993 Studio - Frank Thomas Collection #3

Frank Thomas

$2.84
1998 Metal Universe - Universal Language #8UL

Cal Ripken Jr.

$2.27
1994 Upper Deck All-Time Heroes - [Base] #10

Off the Wire - Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays

$2.27
2004 Upper Deck - Famous Quotes #Q-17

Tommy Lasorda

$1.98
2001 Fleer Platinum - Grandstand Greats #20 GG

Frank Thomas

$1.98
1996 Topps Stadium Club - Mickey Mantle #MM16

Mickey Mantle

$1.98
1998 Skybox EX 2001 - [Base] #3

Greg Maddux

$1.69
2021 Panini Mosaic - All-Time Greats - Red Mosaic #ATG3

Ichiro

$5.72
1987 Burger King All-Pro - [Base] - Complete Panel #13-14

Don Mattingly, Ozzie Smith

$5.72
2021 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Blue & Carolina Blue Prizm #40

Jeff Bagwell

$5.43
2004 Donruss Studio - Heroes of the Hall #HH-2

Gary Carter #/999

$5.43
2002 Topps Chrome - 1952 Reprints - Refractor #52R-7

Phil Rizzuto [EX to NM]

$5.43
2021 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Red Prizm #49

Jack Morris

$5.14
2015 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Blue Framed #65

Ichiro #/99

$5.14
2015 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Blue Framed #56

George Kelly #/99

$5.14
1993 Score - The Franchise #17

Barry Larkin [EX to NM]

$5.14
2021 Panini Mosaic - All-Time Greats - Red Mosaic #ATG8

Kirby Puckett

$4.85
2011 Topps Lineage - [Base] - Platinum Diamond Anniversary #87

David Ortiz

$4.85
2007 SP Legendary Cuts - [Base] #182

Pie Traynor #/550

$4.85
1998 SPx Finite - [Base] #228

Scott Rolen [EX to NM] #/7,000

$4.85
2014 Panini Donruss - No-No's #1

Nolan Ryan

$4.57
2015 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Silver #90

Leo Durocher #/99

2 from
$3.99
2021 Panini Mosaic - V Tool - Mosaic Prizm #VT3

Rickey Henderson

$6.29
1998 Skybox Circa Thunder - Limited Access #1 LA

Jeff Bagwell

$6.29
2017 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Artist's Proof Gold #18.2

Variation - Joe DiMaggio (No Long Sleeves) #/99

$5.14
2021 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Blue & Carolina Blue Prizm #10

Craig Biggio

$4.28
2015 Panini Diamond Kings - [Base] - Gold #39

Don Drysdale #/25

$4.28
2011 Topps Lineage - [Base] - Mini 1975 Design #193

Joe Morgan

$4.28
2004 Donruss Elite - Career Best #CB-7

Chipper Jones [EX to NM] #/1,000

$4.28
2021 Topps Heritage - Then & Now #TN-15

Nolan Ryan, Shane Bieber

$3.99
1963 Topps - [Base] #125

Robin Roberts [Good to VG‑EX]

$2.84
2021 Topps Heritage - The Great One #GO-19

Roberto Clemente

$2.27
2012 Topps - 1987 Topps Minis #TM-92

Sandy Koufax

$2.27
2016 Panini Diamond Kings - Originals #DKO16

Kirby Puckett

$1.98
2015 Panini Elite - Gold Stars #13

Cal Ripken Jr.

$1.98
2000 Upper Deck Legends - Ones for the Ages #O1

Ty Cobb

$1.98
2000 Topps Chrome - [Base] #462

League Leaders - Mark McGwire, Ken Griffey Jr.

$1.98
1999 Skybox Metal Universe - [Base] #21

David Ortiz

$1.98
1998 Pinnacle Plus - All-Star Epix - Moment Orange #E9

Tony Gwynn

$1.98
1997 Fleer Ultra - Leather Shop #3

Cal Ripken Jr.

$1.98
1986 Topps Quaker Chewy Granola Bars - Food Issue [Base] #32

Tom Seaver

$1.98
2017 Panini Chronicles - Prizm #40

George Brett

$1.69
2014 Panini Classics - Home Run Heroes #11

Frank Thomas

$1.69
2010 Topps - Legendary Lineage #LL17

Cal Ripken Jr., Derek Jeter

$1.69
1998 Ultra - Double Trouble #7DT

Cal Ripken Jr., Roberto Alomar

$1.69
1996 Fleer Ultra - Respect #7

Cal Ripken Jr.

$1.69
1995 Topps Stadium Club - Virtual Reality #209

Frank Thomas

$1.69
1993 Topps Stadium Club - Season Milestones #2

George Brett

$1.69
<< 1 2 3 4 5 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 5