Buy Now, Ship Later: Save on shipping, consolidate orders, and avoid short-term delays due to high seasonal volume.

By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
Indianapolis Colts Hall of Fame Football Cards
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Sold Out
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Football (12,425)
2020's (1,185)
2010's (1,087)
2000's (6,358)
1990's (3,686)
1980's (87)
1970's (8)
1960's (10)
1950's (4)
Listings 1 - 100 of 12,425
2021 Panini Classics - Classic Combos Signatures - Black #CC-PJ

Peyton Manning, Jeff Saturday #/1

$1,681.10
2006 Leaf Rookies & Stars - Statistical Standouts - Logo Patch #SS-16

Marvin Harrison #/1

$1,130.28
2022 Panini Honors - Recollection Collection #18PL-ROH-PM

Peyton Manning (2018 Panini Limited - Ring of Honor) [Buyback] #/1

$801.10
2020 Panini National Treasures - Century Materials - Printing Plate Black #CM-ED

Eric Dickerson #/1

$218.78
2008 SPx - [Base] - Moments #62

Marvin Harrison #/1

$136.78
2006 Bowman Chrome - [Base] - Printing Plate Black #130

Dwight Freeney [Poor to Fair] #/1

$57.75
2010 Topps - [Base] - Printing Plate Yellow #130

Dwight Freeney #/1

$46.24
2011 Topps - [Base] - Printing Plate Yellow #191

Dwight Freeney #/1

$45.67
2011 Topps - [Base] - Printing Plate Cyan #191

Dwight Freeney #/1

$35.04
2008 Topps Triple Threads - Double Combo Relics Book - Sapphire #TTDCR-10

LaDainian Tomlinson, Willie Parker, Marshawn Lynch, Willis McGahee, Fred Taylor…

$142.22
2007 Upper Deck Trilogy - [Base] - Platinum #43

Marvin Harrison #/3

$48.84
2016 Panini Honors - Recollection Collection #11PNT-16

Raymond Berry (2011 Panini National Treasures) [Buyback] #/4

$231.10
2023 Panini Illusions - Trophy Collection Duals - Conference #TC-41

Peyton Manning, Anthony Richardson #/5

$121.09
2009 Donruss Limited - [Base] - Gold Spotlight #44

Peyton Manning #/5

$109.49
2005 Leaf Certified Materials - [Base] - Mirror Emerald Materials #52

Marvin Harrison #/5

$67.51
2007 Playoff NFL Playoffs - [Base] - Black Proof #44

Marvin Harrison #/5

$37.33
2003 Donruss Classics - [Base] - National Convention Embossing #44

Marvin Harrison [EX to NM] #/5

$26.98
2002 Donruss Elite - [Base] - 2002 National Convention Embossing #15

Marvin Harrison #/5

$26.98
2001 Donruss Classics - [Base] - Chicago Sun-Times #36

Marvin Harrison #/5

$26.98
2001 Leaf Rookies & Stars - [Base] - Chicago Sun-Times #62

Marvin Harrison #/5

$26.98
2001 Playoff Honors - [Base] - Chicago Sun-Times Collection #3

Marvin Harrison #/5

$24.35
2001 Score Select - [Base] - Chicago Sun-Times Collection #87

Marvin Harrison #/5

$23.53
2001 Playoff Absolute Memorabilia - [Base] - Chicago Sun-Times Collection #38

Marvin Harrison #/5

$23.53
2001 Playoff Preferred - [Base] - Chicago Sun-Times Collection #17

Marvin Harrison #/5

$23.53
2002 Playoff Honors - [Base] - Chicago Collection #37

Marvin Harrison #/5

$23.39
2011 Panini Crown Royale - Kings of the NFL - Materials Prime Signatures #18

Peyton Manning #/5

8d left (0) $9.99
2000 Pacific Paramount - Zoned In - 21st National Convention Anaheim #14

Marvin Harrison #/7

$73.25
2017 Panini Prizm - NFL MVPs - Gold Mojo Prizm #35

Peyton Manning [BGS 9 MINT] #/10

$471.10
2017 Panini Phoenix - Retired Patches #RP-PM

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/10

$230.88
2007 Upper Deck Trilogy - Materials - HoloGold Patch #TM-PM

Peyton Manning #/10

$470.17
2024 Panini Flawless - Flawless Achievements - Sapphire #FA-PMG

Peyton Manning [Uncirculated] #/10

$641.60
2009 Upper Deck Football Heroes - [Base] - Gold Autographs #32

Peyton Manning [SGC 8 NM/Mt] #/10

$406.00
2023 Panini Limited - Limited INK - Amethyst Spotlight #LI-PM

Peyton Manning [BGS Authentic] #/10

$290.63
2009 Donruss Limited - [Base] - Silver Spotlight #44

Peyton Manning #/10

$150.29
2016 Donruss Optic - Peyton Manning Tribute - Gold #12

Peyton Manning #/10

$153.83
2008 Ultimate Collection - Ultimate Generations Foursomes Jerseys - Holofoil Patches #UFGJ-27

Fran Tarkenton, Ken Anderson, Peyton Manning, Matt Ryan #/10

$147.78
2024 Panini Contenders Optic - Dominance - Gold Prizm #DOM-PMG

Peyton Manning #/10

$134.29
2011 Panini Crown Royale - [Base] - Green #78

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/10

$120.00
2020 Panini Chronicles - [Base] - Gold #41

Peyton Manning [CSG 10 Gem Mint] #/10

$109.56
2020 Panini Luminance - Flash - Green #F11

Peyton Manning #/10

$110.88
2017 Panini Absolute - Canton Absolutes - Prime #14

Peyton Manning #/10

$104.90
2015 Topps Peyton Manning Cardboard Icon Jumbos - [Base] - Red #1998

Peyton Manning #/10

$93.40
2024 Panini Zenith - [Base] - Gold Red Zone #43

Peyton Manning #/10

$92.53
2024 Topps Finest - [Base] - Red Geometric Refractor #35

Common - Peyton Manning #/10

$87.02
2017 Panini Rookies & Stars - Precision Passers - Gold #18

Peyton Manning #/10

$58.04
2021 Panini Legacy - Generations - Violet #G-5

Archie Manning, Peyton Manning #/10

$46.53
2009 Upper Deck Draft Edition - [Base] - Platinum #293

Draft Class - LaDainian Tomlinson, Drew Brees, Reggie Wayne #/10

$46.25
2017 Panini Plates & Patches - [Base] - Red #124

Legends - Edgerrin James #/10

$18.83
2020 Panini Legacy - Lasting Legacies - Violet #LL-PMA

Peyton Manning #/10

$41.42
2018 Panini Classics - [Base] - No Name #136

Legends - Edgerrin James #/10

$19.69
2004 Upper Deck - [Base] - UD Exclusives Vintage #83

Marvin Harrison #/10

$37.33
2018 Panini Illusions - Legacies Dual Memorabilia - Red #LD-10

Edgerrin James, Nyheim Hines #/10

$35.04
2006 Leaf Limited - [Base] - Gold Spotlight #38

Marvin Harrison #/10

$79.89
2005 Donruss Classics - [Base] - Timeless Tributes Platinum #41

Marvin Harrison #/10

$26.98
2002 Playoff Honors - [Base] - Premium Decade #37

Marvin Harrison #/10

$23.53
2024 Panini Mosaic - Epic Performers - Fluorescent Green Mosaic Prizm #EP-DF

Dwight Freeney #/10

$23.24
2016 Donruss Elite - Etched in Time - Blue #ET-MF

Marshall Faulk #/10

$23.24
2008 Prestige - [Base] - Tenth Anniversary #44

Marvin Harrison #/10

$22.44
2006 Donruss Classics - [Base] - Timeless Tributes Platinum #44

Marvin Harrison #/10

$21.50
2002 Pacific - [Base] - Pacific Nights Special Edition #192

Marvin Harrison #/10

$21.50
2005 Leaf Certified Materials - Certified Skills - Mirror Black #CS-44

Marvin Harrison #/10

$21.50
2009 Upper Deck Football Heroes - [Base] - Purple #77

Marvin Harrison #/10

$19.59
2009 Upper Deck Football Heroes - [Base] - Purple #80

Marvin Harrison #/10

$19.59
2007 Leaf Limited - [Base] - Spotlight Gold #43

Marvin Harrison #/10

$19.59
2015 Topps Peyton Manning Cardboard Icon Jumbos - [Base] - Red #2007.2

Peyton Manning #/10

$18.54
2015 Topps Peyton Manning Cardboard Icon Jumbos - [Base] - Red #2007.1

Peyton Manning #/10

$18.54
2015 Topps Peyton Manning Cardboard Icon Jumbos - [Base] - Red #2003

Peyton Manning #/10

$18.54
2015 Topps Peyton Manning Cardboard Icon Jumbos - [Base] - Red #2001

Peyton Manning #/10

$18.54
2015 Topps Peyton Manning Cardboard Icon Jumbos - [Base] - Red #2000

Peyton Manning #/10

$18.54
2015 Topps Peyton Manning Cardboard Icon Jumbos - [Base] - Red #1999

Peyton Manning #/10

$18.54
2015 Topps Peyton Manning Cardboard Icon Jumbos - [Base] - Red #2004

Peyton Manning #/10

$18.54
2015 Topps Peyton Manning Cardboard Icon Jumbos - [Base] - Red #2005

Peyton Manning #/10

$18.54
2015 Topps Peyton Manning Cardboard Icon Jumbos - [Base] - Red #2010

Peyton Manning #/10

$18.54
2015 Topps Peyton Manning Cardboard Icon Jumbos - [Base] - Red #2002

Peyton Manning #/10

$18.54
2015 Topps Peyton Manning Cardboard Icon Jumbos - [Base] - Red #2008

Peyton Manning #/10

$18.54
2015 Topps Peyton Manning Cardboard Icon Jumbos - [Base] - Red #2011

Peyton Manning #/10

$18.54
2023 Topps Composite - [Base] - Red Geometric Refractor #195

Topps Finest - Edgerrin James #/10

$17.50
2005 Playoff Absolute Memorabilia - Tools of the Trade - Spectrum Black #TT-62

Marvin Harrison [EX to NM] #/10

$16.73
2015 Topps - Past & Present Performers - Topps.com Online Exclusive 5x7 Jumbo Gold #PPP-HH

Marvin Harrison #/10

$16.68
2016 Panini Phoenix - Adrenaline Rush - Green #AR-EJ

Edgerrin James #/10

$12.04
2023 Panini Mosaic - [Base] - Green Swirl Mosaic Prizm #100

Peyton Manning #/11

$114.39
2016 Panini Honors - Recollection Collection #00PP-SN19

Marvin Harrison (2000 Playoff Prestige) [Buyback] #/13

$214.60
2024 Panini Donruss - [Base] - Season Stat Line #291

Eric Dickerson #/14

$29.52
2015 Panini Donruss - Throwback Rookies 1985 Signatures #3

Peyton Manning #/15

$910.50
2024 Panini Flawless - Career Progressions - Ruby #CP-MFK

Marshall Faulk #/15

$102.03
2024 Panini Contenders Optic - All-Time Contenders Autographs - Black Scope Prizm #ATC-EJS

Edgerrin James #/15

$80.75
2021 Panini National Treasures - Signatures - Holo Silver #S-DF

Dwight Freeney #/15

$60.04
2021 Panini Donruss Optic - [Base] - Purple Stars Prizm #113

Peyton Manning #/15

$58.04
2009 Playoff Absolute Memorabilia - Tools of the Trade Materials - Spectrum Jumbo Black Die-Cut Jersey Number Prime #10

Dwight Freeney #/15

$58.04
2007 Fleer Ultra - Dual Materials - Silver #UDM-MH2

Marvin Harrison #/15

$46.54
2024 Panini Spectra - Max Impact - Neon Pink Prizm #MI-MFK

Marshall Faulk #/15

$28.99
2001 Playoff Contenders - [Base] - 2002 Hawaii Trade Conference #36

Season Ticket - Marvin Harrison #/15

$26.98
2015 Panini Spectra - [Base] - Neon Green Prizm Die-Cut #78.1

Marshall Faulk (Colts) #/15

$12.04
2021 Panini Classics - Transitions - Green #T-18

Eric Dickerson #/15

$17.79
2022 Panini Classics - Monday Night Heroes - Green #MN-6

Eric Dickerson #/15

$9.17
2023 Panini Mosaic - [Base] - Gold Wave Mosaic Prizm #100

Peyton Manning #/17

$115.20
2021 Panini Immaculate Collection - Immaculate Numbers Memorabilia #INM-PMA

Peyton Manning #/18

$214.60
2000 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Destiny - [Base] - Red #053

Peyton Manning #/18

$107.66
2000 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Destiny - [Base] - Red #67

Peyton Manning #/18

$107.66
2016 Panini Prizm - Peyton Manning Tribute - Silver Prizm #PMT-4

Peyton Manning #/18

$69.54
<< 1 2 3 4 5 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 125