This website uses technologies such as cookies to provide you a better user experience. To learn more refer to our Privacy Policy .

Top
Indianapolis Colts Pre-Rookie Card Football Cards
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Sold Out
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Football (101)
2020's (13)
2010's (11)
2000's (14)
1990's (54)
1980's (6)
1970's (2)
1900's (1)
Listings 1 - 100 of 101
2020 Panini Prestige - [Base] - Xtra Points Blue #65

Clayton Geathers

4 from
$1.69
2020 Panini Prestige - [Base] - Xtra Points Red #65

Clayton Geathers #/249

2 from
$2.55
1992 Pacific - [Base] #442

Quintus McDonald

2 from
$2.61
1996 Pacific Dynagon - Best Kept Secrets #BKS-38

Derwin Gray

$23.24
1991 Pacific - [Base] #595

Kerry Cash

6 from
$1.05
1991 Pacific - [Base] #200

Pat Tomberlin

6 from
$1.13
1991 Pacific - [Base] #198

Stacey Simmons

5 from
$0.74
2023 Panini Donruss Elite - Turn of the Century Autographs #TC-JAY

Jaylon Jones #/249

$17.73
1995 Bowman - [Base] #134

Brian Gelzheiser [EX to NM]

$8.59
1993 Courtside Draft Pix - Sean Dawkins #4

Sean Dawkins

9 from
$3.42
1993 Courtside Draft Pix - Sean Dawkins #1

Sean Dawkins

7 from
$2.84
2000 Pacific - [Base] #159

Isaac Jones, Paul Shields

2 from
$1.68
2023 Panini Certified - Mirror Signatures #MS72

Kenny Moore II #/199

$14.34
1995 Pinnacle Zenith - [Base] #Z124

Aaron Bailey

5 from
$1.39
1993 Courtside Draft Pix - Sean Dawkins #2

Sean Dawkins

6 from
$2.04
2007 Upper Deck Indianapolis Colts Super Bowl XLI - [Base] #25

Darrell Reid

$2.61
1996 Pacific Dynagon - [Base] #P-59

Ben Bronson

$8.29
1997 Pacific Dynagon Prism - Best-Kept Secrets #92

Chris Hetherington

4 from
$2.84
1996 Upper Deck Collector's Choice Update - [Base] #U154

Scott Slutzker

$4.68
1996 Upper Deck Collector's Choice Update - [Base] #U163

Sammie Burroughs

2 from
$1.92
2020 Panini Prestige - [Base] - Xtra Points Gold #65

Clayton Geathers #/75

$1.76
2020 Panini Prestige - [Base] #65

Clayton Geathers

7 from
$0.94
1998 Playoff Prestige - Alma Maters #16

Charles Woodson, Jim Harbaugh, Elvis Grbac

$22.10
1992 Pacific - [Base] #444

Mark Herrmann [Good to VG‑EX]

$1.23
2017 Panini Father's Day - [Base] - Galactic #79

Jerome Lane #/10

$7.44
2016 Panini Preferred - Retail Crown Royale Rookie Autographs - Pink #43

Antonio Morrison #/250

2 from
$2.96
1996 Upper Deck Collector's Choice Update - [Base] #U137

Jay Leeuwenburg

$3.30
1992 Fleer Ultra - [Base] #422

Rodney Culver

5 from
$1.67
2020 Panini Prestige - [Base] - Xtra Points Purple #65

Clayton Geathers #/100

2 from
$3.20
1992 Wild Card - Stat Smashers #SS-52

Rodney Culver

4 from
$1.12
1993 Pro Line Portraits - Wives #26

Ann Stark

10 from
$1.40
1994 Classic NFL Draft - Game Card #GC 8

Trey Alberts

3 from
$0.99
1995 Pacific - [Base] #246

Tony McCoy

$3.13
2020 Panini Prestige - [Base] - Xtra Points Signatures #65

Clayton Geathers

3 from
$6.28
2021 Panini Instant NFL - All-Pro #AP28

Luke Rhodes #/212

$3.35
2022 Panini Instant NFL - Studio Rookies #S19

Alec Pierce #/911

$3.35
1995 Bowman - [Base] #134

Brian Gelzheiser

$7.15
2020 Panini Prestige - [Base] - Xtra Points Green #65

Clayton Geathers

4 from
$0.98
1995 Playoff Absolute - Unsung Heroes #12

Devon McDonald

$1.40
1995 Playoff Prime - Unsung Heroes - Silver #12

Devon McDonald

2 from
$1.39
1993 Classic Draft Picks - [Base] #57

Devon McDonald

4 from
$1.23
1997 Pacific Crown Collection - [Base] #182

Bernard Whittington

2 from
$1.11
1997 Score Board Rookies - [Base] #56

Bertrand Berry

4 from
$1.15
1900-Present Authenticated Autographs - Business Cards #_JIIR

Jim Irsay [BAS BGS Authentic]

2 from
$92.13
2017 Panini Father's Day - [Base] - Thick Stock #79

Jerome Lane #/25

2 from
$3.91
1991 Pacific - [Base] #595

Kerry Cash [EX to NM]

$1.40
2000 Pacific - [Base] - Gold #148

Tony Blevins #/199

$12.04
2018 Panini Instant NFL - Panini All-Rookie Team - Green #8

Braden Smith #/10

$23.24
2000 Pacific - [Base] #148

Tony Blevins

2 from
$1.92
1988 Panini Album Stickers - [Base] #77

Indianapolis Colts, Hoosier Dome

$6.00
1988 Swell Football Greats Hall of Fame - [Base] #86

Lenny Moore [BAS Authentic]

$30.15
2020 Panini Prestige - [Base] - Xtra Points Green Signatures #65

Clayton Geathers

$7.44
1992 Wild Card - Red Hot Rookies - Silver #15

Rodney Culver

2 from
$1.52
2017 Panini Father's Day - [Base] #79

Jerome Lane #/499

15 from
$0.96
2020 Panini Prestige - [Base] - Xtra Points Orange #65

Clayton Geathers #/50

$1.92
1999 Collector's Edge Supreme - Homecoming #HC-17

Kelley Johnson, Marvin Harrison

11 from
$0.88
1992 Action Packed Rookie Update - [Base] #29

Rodney Culver

3 from
$0.99
1995 Pacific - [Base] #236

Aaron Bailey

$1.27
2017 Panini Father's Day - [Base] - Cracked Ice #79

Jerome Lane #/25

$4.84
1997 Collector's Edge Masters - [Base] #110

Trey Alberts

2 from
$3.30
1989 Vachon CFL Pannels - [Base] #FISMP

Scott Flagel, Bryan Illerbrun, Tom Spoletini, Doran Major, Anthony Parker

$10.55
2017 Panini Father's Day - [Base] - Foil #79

Jerome Lane #/50

3 from
$1.39
1992 Action Packed Rookie Update - 24 Kt. Gold Mint #29

Rodney Culver [Noted] #/250

$10.37
2000 Pacific - [Base] - Gold #159

Isaac Jones, Paul Shields #/199

$3.13
1989 NFL Franchise Game Player Cards - Board Game [Base] #_CLOD

Clifton Odom

$7.67
1993 Courtside Draft Pix - Sean Dawkins #2

Sean Dawkins [Noted]

$1.98
1988 Swell Football Greats Hall of Fame - [Base] #86

Lenny Moore

$2.55
2000 Pacific - [Base] - Premiere Date #148

Tony Blevins #/78

$13.20
1992 Wild Card - Running Wild - Gold #12

Rodney Culver

2 from
$1.40
1997 Pacific Philadelphia - Philadelphia - Gold #80

Tony McCoy

2 from
$1.40
1992 Pro Set Power - [Base] #312

Rodney Culver

5 from
$1.38
2005 SAGE Hit - Reflect - Gold Autographs #RA50

Jonathan Goddard #/100

$8.13
1993 Courtside Draft Pix - Sean Dawkins #5.2

Sean Dawkins (Autograph)

3 from
$23.54
1990 Action Packed Rookie Update - [Base] #49

Stacey Simmons

4 from
$0.86
1972 Sunoco NFL Action Player Stamps - [Base] #_FRMI

Fred Miller [Good to VG‑EX]

2 from
$1.63
1972 Sunoco NFL Action Player Stamps - [Base] #_FRMI

Fred Miller [COMC RCR Poor]

$1.63
2011 SAGE Five Star - Dual Autographs #A-38

Mark Herzlich, Anthony Castonzo #/200

3 from
$4.34
1997 Score Board Rookies - [Base] #21

Adam Meadows

$2.84
1996 Pacific Litho-Cel - Game Time #GT-44

Derrick Frazier

2 from
$2.73
1992 GameDay - [Base] #91

Larry Tharpe, Mike Brandon, Anthony Hamlet, Mike Pawlawski

3 from
$2.21
1992 GameDay - [Base] #310

Reggie Dwight, Anthony McCoy, Craig Thompson, Klaus Wilmsmeyer

$2.84
1996 Pacific Dynagon - Best Kept Secrets #BKS-41

Glen Sanders

$3.42
1996 Pacific Dynagon - Best Kept Secrets #BKS-40

Tony McCoy

2 from
$3.42
1988 Indianapolis Colts Police - [Base] #8

Ron Meyer

$3.36
1993 Bowman - [Base] #161

Devon McDonald

5 from
$0.99
1993 Bowman - [Base] #187

Willis Peguese

5 from
$0.99
2001-02 NFL Showdown 1st Edition - [Base] #183

Adam Meadows

$14.05
2000 Pacific - [Base] - Gold #148

Tony Blevins [Noted] #/199

$3.42
1993 Classic Draft Picks - [Base] - Gold #57

Devon McDonald #/5,000

$3.93
1992 Wild Card - Red Hot Rookies - Gold #15

Rodney Culver

$1.68
1995 Pacific - [Base] - Blue #246

Tony McCoy

$3.42
2002-03 NFL Showdown 1st & Goal - [Base] #041

James Cannida

4 from
$1.15
2010 Press Pass Portrait Edition - Face to Face #FF-12

Jonathan Dwyer, Javarris James

7 from
$1.12
1992 Wild Card - Red Hot Rookies #15

Rodney Culver

$1.98
1992 Wild Card - Running Wild - Silver #12

Rodney Culver

$3.42
2000 Pacific - [Base] - Premiere Date Missing Serial Number #159

Isaac Jones, Paul Shields

$3.41
2000 Pacific - [Base] - Copper Missing Serial Number #159

Isaac Jones, Paul Shields

$3.41
2000 Pacific - [Base] - Gold Missing Serial Number #159

Isaac Jones, Paul Shields

$3.41
2010 Sage - [Base] #26

Javarris James

2 from
$1.40
2000 Pacific - [Base] - Copper #148

Tony Blevins #/75

$7.44
<< 1 2 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 2