By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
Indianapolis Colts Rookie Card All Football Cards Graded PSA
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Sold Out
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Football (520)
Listings 1 - 100 of 520
1998 Topps Chrome - [Base] #165

Draft Picks - Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$1,447.77
1998 Upper Deck - [Base] #1

NFL Star Rookie - Peyton Manning [PSA 8.5 NM‑MT+]

$104.90
2024 Panini Donruss Elite - [Base] #160

Rookies - Laiatu Latu [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/999

$69.24
2012 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Retail Purple Refractor #1

Andrew Luck [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/499

10 from
$103.70
2012 Topps Chrome - [Base] - Retail Orange Refractor #1

Andrew Luck [PSA 10 GEM MT]

2 from
$46.20
1994 Topps - [Base] #445

Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

$41.65
1996 Topps - [Base] #426

96 Draft Pick - Marvin Harrison [PSA 9 MINT]

$34.75
2024 Panini Spectra - [Base] - Universal Prizm Die-Cut #122

Rookies - Laiatu Latu [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/10

5d left (4) $12.50
2020 Panini Donruss Optic - [Base] - Black Pandora Prizm #172

Rated Rookies - Michael Pittman Jr. [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/25

5d left (3) $5.50
1998 Bowman Chrome - [Base] #1

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

7d left (0) $0.99
1998 Skybox Thunder - [Base] #239

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$57.75
2001 Fleer Legacy - [Base] #112

Rookie - Reggie Wayne [PSA 9 MINT] #/999

$34.75
1998 Bowman Chrome - [Base] - Interstate #1

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

$153.00
2023 Panini Select - [Base] - Silver Prizm #43

Concourse - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT]

5d left (1) $0.99
1996 Select Certified Edition - [Base] - Premium Stock #91

Marvin Harrison [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$341.10
1999 Bowman Chrome - [Base] #161

Edgerrin James [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

2 from
$12.85
1998 Topps - [Base] #360

Draft Picks - Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

4 from
$46.24
2023 Panini Donruss Optic - [Base] - Blue Hyper Prizm #247

Rated Rookie - Anthony Richardson [PSA 9 MINT]

6 from
$23.25
2020 Panini Mosaic - [Base] - Reactive Blue Mosaic Prizm #276

NFL Debut - Jonathan Taylor [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$148.60
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Neon Green Pulsar Prizm #343

Rookies - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$87.65
1996 Fleer Metal - [Base] #135

Marvin Harrison [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$34.75
2024 Panini Prizm - [Base] - No Huddle Neon Green Prizm #303

Rookies - Adonai Mitchell [PSA 9 MINT] #/10

$440.10
1998 Bowman Chrome - [Base] #1

Peyton Manning [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$335.60
2020 Panini Donruss Optic - [Base] #167

Rated Rookies - Jonathan Taylor [PSA 9 MINT]

$24.39
1998 Bowman's Best - [Base] #112

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$102.59
1994 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] #327

Marshall Faulk [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$35.90
1994 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] - Super Teams Winners Super Bowl XXIX #327

Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

$231.10
1994 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] - Members Only #327

Marshall Faulk [PSA 8.5 NM‑MT+]

$231.10
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Silver Prizm Autographs #343

Rookies - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT]

2 from
$286.10
2023 Panini Donruss - [Base] #343

Rated Rookie - Anthony Richardson [PSA 9 MINT]

15 from
$17.49
2020 Panini Select - [Base] - Blue Prizm Die-Cut #62

Concourse - Michael Pittman Jr. [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$35.90
2020 Panini Mosaic - [Base] - Mosaic Prizm #280

NFL Debut - Jacob Eason [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$12.90
2020 Panini Mosaic - [Base] - Silver Prizm #280

NFL Debut - Jacob Eason [PSA 10 GEM MT]

4 from
$11.52
2018 Panini Select - [Base] - Silver Prizm #2

Concourse - Quenton Nelson [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$34.75
1994 SP - [Base] #3

Premier Prospects - Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

27 from
$23.48
1999 Bowman's Best - [Base] #115

Edgerrin James [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$12.89
1998 Skybox EX 2001 - [Base] #54

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$63.92
2018 Panini Contenders - [Base] - Stubs #242

Rookie Ticket/Rookie Ticket Variation - Jordan Wilkins [PSA 9 MINT] #…

$47.39
1999 Skybox EX Century - [Base] #69

Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$34.74
2023 Panini Prestige - [Base] - Xtra Points Premium Orange #302

Rookies - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/50

$66.94
2020 Panini Prizm - [Base] - No Huddle Blue Prizm #331

Rookie - Jacob Eason [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/79

$13.48
2023 Panini Donruss Optic - [Base] - Blue Prizm Autographs #247

Rated Rookie RPS - Anthony Richardson [PSA 9 MINT] #/99

$79.60
2023 Panini Origins - [Base] #40

Anthony Richardson [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$22.10
2003 Bowman Chrome - [Base] - Gold Refractor #126

Dallas Clark [PSA 9 MINT] #/50

$635.00
1994 Score - [Base] #277

Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$40.50
2023 Panini Donruss Optic - [Base] - Purple Shock Prizm #247

Rated Rookie - Anthony Richardson [PSA 9 MINT]

3 from
$27.85
2023 Panini Donruss Optic - [Base] #247

Rated Rookie - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT]

5 from
$29.00
2023 Panini Donruss - [Base] #343

Rated Rookie - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT]

7 from
$24.40
2020 Panini Mosaic - [Base] - No Huddle Purple Prizm #214.1

Rookies - Michael Pittman Jr. [PSA 9 MINT] #/50

$47.35
1999 Collector's Edge Odyssey - [Base] #65

Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT]

4 from
$30.14
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Silver Prizm #343

Rookies - Anthony Richardson [PSA 9 MINT]

8 from
$12.85
1998 Ultra - [Base] #201

Rookie - Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$70.40
2001 Quantum Leaf - [Base] #228

Rookie - Reggie Wayne [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$17.50
2020 Panini Donruss Optic - [Base] - Aqua Prizm #162

Rated Rookies - Jacob Eason [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/299

$24.39
1998 Topps Finest - [Base] #121

Rookie - Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$69.25
1999 Fleer Mystique - [Base] #107

Rookie - Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT] #/2,999

$35.90
2023 Panini Donruss Optic - [Base] - Blue Hyper Prizm #247

Rated Rookie - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$63.50
1999 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] #155

Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT]

$34.75
2001 Topps - [Base] - Topps Collection #344

Reggie Wayne [PSA 9 MINT]

3 from
$32.45
1994 Fleer Ultra - [Base] #133

Marshall Faulk [PSA 9 MINT]

$34.75
1989 Score - [Base] #272

Andre Rison [PSA 9 MINT]

8 from
$16.35
2012 Playoff Prestige - [Base] #229.2

Rookie Variation - Andrew Luck (Draft Day) [PSA 8.5 NM‑MT+]

$58.90
2023 Panini Donruss Optic - [Base] - Holo Prizm #247

Rated Rookie - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT]

4 from
$40.50
2012 Topps Chrome - [Base] #1.1

Andrew Luck (Throwing Ball) [PSA 10 GEM MT]

29 from
$19.80
2020 Panini Select - [Base] - Silver Prizm #353

Field Level - Jonathan Taylor [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$39.35
2018 Donruss Optic - [Base] - Blue Prizm #177

Rated Rookie - Nyheim Hines [PSA 9 MINT] #/149

$18.65
2020 Panini Illusions - [Base] - Trophy Collection Red #14

Jonathan Taylor [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/99

$30.15
2018 Donruss Optic - [Base] - Gold Prizm #127

Rookies - Deon Cain [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/10

$70.39
2014 Panini Prizm - Autographed Rookie - Red Power Prizm #AR-DM

Donte Moncrief [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/75

$47.39
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] #343

Rookies - Anthony Richardson [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$18.65
1999 Fleer Tradition - [Base] #277

Rookie - Edgerrin James [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$28.99
2020 Panini Mosaic - [Base] - Red Mosaic Prizm #236

Rookies - Jacob Eason [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$24.39
2020 Panini Prizm - [Base] #331.2

SP - Rookie Variation - Jacob Eason (Negative) [PSA 9 MINT]

$12.89
2019 Panini Prizm - [Base] #347

Rookies - Parris Campbell [PSA 9 MINT]

6 from
$11.74
2019 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Green Prizm #347

Rookies - Parris Campbell [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$15.20
2019 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Red White & Blue Prizm #347

Rookies - Parris Campbell [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$18.65
1998 Bowman - [Base] #1

Peyton Manning [PSA 9 MINT]

6 from
$53.15
1972 Topps - [Base] #297

High # - Ray May [PSA 5 EX]

$34.75
1998 Bowman - [Base] #1

Peyton Manning [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

5 from
$34.74
1987 Topps - [Base] #378

Bill Brooks [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$24.37
1994 Bowman - [Base] #2

Marshall Faulk [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

2 from
$11.67
2012 Topps - [Base] #140.1

Andrew Luck (Ball Partly Out of Frame) [PSA 9 MINT]

$19.63
1996 Topps Finest - [Base] #243

Marvin Harrison [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$29.00
2023 Panini Illusions - [Base] #46

Anthony Richardson [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$34.75
2018 Panini Select - [Base] - White Prizm #5

Concourse - Darius Leonard [PSA 10 GEM MT] #/75

$70.40
2018 Panini Select - [Base] #290

Field Level - Darius Leonard [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$18.65
2020 Panini Donruss - [Base] - Optic Preview Red and Green Prizm #P-312

Rated Rookie - Jacob Eason [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$7.15
2024 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Gold Prizm #305

Rookies - Anthony Gould [PSA 9 MINT] #/10

$99.15
2012 Topps Platinum - [Base] #150

Rookie - Andrew Luck [PSA 9 MINT]

$15.20
2020 Panini Mosaic - [Base] - Red Mosaic Prizm #280

NFL Debut - Jacob Eason [PSA 9 MINT]

$7.15
2023 Panini Donruss Optic - [Base] - Pink Prizm #247

Rated Rookie - Anthony Richardson [PSA 9 MINT]

4 from
$16.93
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Lazer Prizm #345

Rookies - Josh Downs [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$32.41
1999 Fleer Focus - [Base] #149

Rookie - Edgerrin James [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/2,500

$15.20
1999 Playoff Momentum SSD - [Base] #154

Rookie - Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$29.00
1999 Fleer Focus - [Base] #149

Rookie - Edgerrin James [PSA 9 MINT] #/2,500

$34.75
2019 Panini One - [Base] - Red #16

Rookie Patch Autographs - Parris Campbell [PSA 9 MINT] #/25

$41.64
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] #343

Rookies - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT]

9 from
$29.87
2023 Panini Mosaic - [Base] - Reactive Blue Mosaic Prizm #282

Rookies - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT]

2 from
$87.65
2019 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Red Prizm #347

Rookies - Parris Campbell [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$41.64
2023 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Green Wave Prizm #343

Rookies - Anthony Richardson [PSA 10 GEM MT]

2 from
$58.90
<< 1 2 3 4 5 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 6