Buffalo Bills Hall of Fame Rookie Year Rookie Related Football Cards Ungraded

2009 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection - Ultimate Generations Six Jerseys #G6J-12

Matthew Stafford, Roger Staubach, Phil Simms, Jim Kelly, Peyton Manning, Tom Br…

$867.10

2018 Panini XR - Mirrored #M-5

Jim Kelly, Josh Allen #/75

$175.27

1970 Topps - [Base] #90

O.J. Simpson

18 from

$52.23

1970 Topps Super - [Base] #24

O.J. Simpson [Good to VG‑EX]

4 from

$92.77

1970 Topps Super Glossy - [Base] #22

O.J. Simpson

2 from

$86.79

1970 Topps Super - [Base] #24

O.J. Simpson

4 from

$37.43

1970 Topps - [Base] #90

O.J. Simpson [Poor to Fair]

9 from

$57.32

1970 Topps - [Base] #90

O.J. Simpson [Good to VG‑EX]

6 from

$51.99

2018 Panini Illusions - [Base] #19

Josh Allen, Jim Kelly

4 from

$42.83

1970 Topps Super Glossy - [Base] #22

O.J. Simpson [Poor to Fair]

4 from

$37.69

2013 Topps Supreme - Dual Autograph #SDA-RW

Andre Reed, Robert Woods #/20

$57.75

2007 Topps Co-Signers - [Base] - Blue Changing Faces Hyper Gold #38.2

John Elway, Trent Edwards [Noted] #/25

$57.74

1990 Pro Set - [Base] - Wrong Back #151

Thurman Thomas (Mike Dyal Back)

13 from

$7.27

1970 Kellogg's 3-D Super Stars - [Base] #48

O.J. Simpson

4 from

$35.04

1989 Score - [Base] #211

Thurman Thomas [BRCR 9]

$34.75

1974 Topps - [Base] #183

Joe DeLamielleure [EX MT]

$26.72

1995 Fleer Ultra - Promo Sheet #MAFF

Justin Armour, William Floyd, Dave Meggett, Brett Favre [EX to NM]

$24.40

1987 Topps - [Base] #362

Jim Kelly [Good to VG‑EX]

3 from

$12.04

2001 Fleer Legacy - Triple Threads #TT-TBH

LaDainian Tomlinson, Kevan Barlow, Travis Henry

2 from

$11.89

1969 Topps - Mini-Cards (4-in-1) #_NDMC

Jim Nance, Jim Dunaway, Ron Mix, Larry Csonka [Good to VG‑EX]

2 from

$11.03

2002 Fleer Tradition - [Base] - Tiffany #298

Rookies - Mike Williams, Dwight Freeney #/225

2 from

$32.45

1989 Score - [Base] #211

Thurman Thomas [EX to NM]

4 from

$6.00

1969 Topps - Mini-Cards (4-in-1) #_NDMC

Jim Nance, Jim Dunaway, Ron Mix, Larry Csonka [COMC RCR Poor]

$14.30

1998 Playoff Prestige - Alma Maters #7

R.W. McQuarters, Barry Sanders, Thurman Thomas

2 from

$31.87

1969 Topps - Mini-Cards (4-in-1) #_NDMC

Jim Nance, Jim Dunaway, Ron Mix, Larry Csonka

4 from

$12.30

1990 Topps - Wax Box Bottom Uncut Panels - With Disclaimer #ABCD

Jim Kelly, David Grayson, Henry Ellard, Derrick Thomas, Joe Montana, Vince News…

$15.20

1974 Topps - [Base] #183

Joe DeLamielleure

3 from

$17.79

1975 Topps - [Base] #209

1074 All Pro - O.J. Simpson, Lawrence McCutcheon [Poor to Fair]

$7.15

1989 Louis Rich Buffalo Bills Police - [Base] #2

Thurman Thomas

3 from

$7.02

2002 Fleer Tradition - [Base] - Mini #298

Rookies - Mike Williams, Dwight Freeney #/125

$14.34

2024 Panini Illusions - Rookie Idols Dual Memorabilia #RI-RC

Andre Reed, Keon Coleman

2 from

$10.89

1987 Wheaties NFL Posters - Cereal [Base] #25

Jim Kelly

$12.90

2003 Fleer Tradition - Classic Combinations - Memorabilia #CC-EJ2

Willis McGahee, Edgerrin James

2 from

$9.44

1996 Playoff Absolute - Quad Series #33

Eddie Kennison, Eddie George, Marvin Harrison, Eric Moulds

3 from

$11.18

1987 Topps - [Base] #362

Jim Kelly

16 from

$6.86

1989 Score - [Base] #211

Thurman Thomas

30 from

$4.85

2007 Topps Co-Signers - [Base] - Blue Changing Faces Hyper Silver #38.2

John Elway, Trent Edwards #/99

$11.74

1989 Pro Set - [Base] #32

Thurman Thomas [Poor to Fair]

$1.55

2014 Panini Totally Certified - Stitches in Time #ST-BUF

Jim Kelly, Sammy Watkins #/99

$9.74

1987 Topps - [Base] #362

Jim Kelly [Poor to Fair]

$9.74

1997 Pacific Revolution - Proteges #3

Thurman Thomas, Antowain Smith

3 from

$9.11

1987 Topps - [Base] #362

Jim Kelly [EX to NM]

2 from

$11.18

1986 Topps - [Base] #389

Bruce Smith

10 from

$6.71

2024 Topps Midnight - Constellations - Twilight #C-3

Andre Reed, Keon Coleman #/99

$7.44

1986 Topps - [Base] #388

Andre Reed [EX to NM]

2 from

$7.44

1986 Topps Album Stickers - [Base] #171-21

Bruce Smith, Jeff Davis

2 from

$4.28

1986 Topps - [Base] #388

Andre Reed

21 from

$4.16

2017 Donruss Optic - Illusions - Blue Prizm #4

Andre Reed, Zay Jones #/149

5 from

$2.99

1975 Topps - [Base] #209

1074 All Pro - O.J. Simpson, Lawrence McCutcheon [Good to VG‑EX]

2 from

$2.84

1988 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #6.58

Joe Montana (Tony Casillas 58, Shane Conlan 168)

2 from

$2.27

1988 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #36.175

Chris Burkett (John Elway 175)

10 from

$1.34

1989 Pro Set - [Base] #32

Thurman Thomas [Noted]

$6.29

1969 Topps - Mini-Cards (4-in-1) #_NDMC

Jim Nance, Jim Dunaway, Ron Mix, Larry Csonka [Poor to Fair]

$6.29

1988 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #34.30

Jim Kelly (Earl Ferrell 30, Jackie Shipp 223)

3 from

$3.01

1988 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #34.110

Jim Kelly (Barry Wilburn 110, Elvis Patterson 196)

3 from

$1.66

1974 Topps - [Base] #183

Joe DeLamielleure [Good to VG‑EX]

$13.19

1986 Topps - [Base] #389

Bruce Smith [EX to NM]

2 from

$7.14

1989 Topps - [Base] #45

Thurman Thomas [Good to VG‑EX]

$6.29

1989 Topps - [Base] #45

Thurman Thomas

32 from

$3.99

1999 Playoff Absolute SSD - [Base] #133

Antowain Smith, Thurman Thomas, Shawn Bryson, Doug Flutie, Andre Reed, Eric Mou…

4 from

$3.42

1988 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #35.134

Ronnie Harmon (Hanford Dixon 134, John Elway 147)

$3.35

1975 Topps - [Base] #209

1074 All Pro - O.J. Simpson, Lawrence McCutcheon

19 from

$2.64

1989 Pro Set - [Base] #32

Thurman Thomas [EX to NM]

$1.68

2010 Topps - Gridiron Lineage #GL-TS

Thurman Thomas, C.J. Spiller

102 from

$0.74

2003 Fleer Tradition - Classic Combinations - Blue #4 CC

Edgerrin James, Willis McGahee #/1,500

2 from

$4.80

2017 Donruss Optic - Illusions - Red Prizm #1

Jim Kelly, Nathan Peterman #/99

3 from

$3.99

1989 Panini Album Stickers - [Base] #226

Thurman Thomas

3 from

$4.84

2002 Fleer Tradition - [Base] #298

Rookies - Mike Williams, Dwight Freeney

3 from

$2.84

1987 Topps Album Stickers - [Base] #172

Jim Kelly [EX to NM]

2 from

$2.84

1988 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #34.51

Jim Kelly (John Rade 51)

3 from

$1.37

1988 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #34.54

Jim Kelly (Floyd Dixon 54, Stanley Morgan 246)

6 from

$1.31

1988 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #34.53

Jim Kelly (Scott Campbell 53, Boomer Esiason 160)

4 from

$1.06

2024 Topps Signature Class - Paramount Pairings #PP-15

Keon Coleman, Andre Reed

$3.70

1996 Pacific Dynagon - Gold Tandems #31

Kevin Greene, Eric Moulds

2 from

$3.42

1988 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #36.139

Chris Burkett (Mike Singletary 139. J.T. Smith 152)

2 from

$2.44

1988 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #8.58

Jerry Rice (Tony Casillas 58, Shane Conlan 168)

5 from

$2.20

1988 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #34.129

Jim Kelly (Jesse Solomon 129, Albert Bentley 211)

2 from

$2.90

1988 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #35.8

Ronnie Harmon (Dennis Gentry 8, Dwight Stephenson 219)

3 from

$2.61

2007 Topps Co-Signers - [Base] - Blue Changing Faces Gold #38.2

John Elway, Trent Edwards #/349

$2.67

1988 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #32.57

Curtis Adams (Mike Gann 57, Andre Reed 165)

3 from

$1.82

1990 Topps - Wax Box Bottom #A

Jim Kelly, David Grayson

$5.17

1987 Topps Album Stickers - [Base] #172

Jim Kelly

20 from

$2.50

1989 Pro Set - [Base] #32

Thurman Thomas

196 from

$1.66

2010 Topps Chrome - Gridiron Lineage #CGL-TS

Thurman Thomas, C.J. Spiller

95 from

$0.77

1988 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #34.83

Jim Kelly (Dennis Gibson 83, Pat Leahy 232)

3 from

$2.55

1995 Upper Deck Collector's Choice Update - You Crash the Game The Playoffs #CP7

Terry Kirby, Marshall Faulk, Darick Holmes, Curtis Martin, Brad Baxter

3 from

$2.27

1988 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #19.58

Eric Dickerson (Tony Casillas 58, Shane Conlan 168)

2 from

$2.55

2017 Donruss Optic - Illusions - Red Prizm #4

Andre Reed, Zay Jones #/99

2 from

$2.60

1989 Pro Set - [Base] #34

Marv Levy

7 from

$2.50

2007 Fleer Ultra - Ultra Comparisons #UC-PL

Paul Posluszny, Ray Lewis

2 from

$2.27

1988 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #6.58

Joe Montana (Tony Casillas 58, Shane Conlan 168) [EX to NM]

$2.44

1995 Upper Deck Collector's Choice Update - You Crash the Game The Playoffs #CP13

Sean Dawkins, Andre Reed, Irving Fryar, Kyle Brady, Ben Coates

$2.50

1999 Bowman's Best - Rookie Class Photo #C1

1999 Rookie Class Photo

8 from

$1.98

1988 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #30.140

Troy Stradford (Bruce Smith 140, Dwight Stephenson 154)

$2.15

1986 Topps Album Stickers - [Base] #173-23

Steve Young, Charles Romes

$8.59

2017 Donruss Optic - Illusions - Holo Silver Prizm #1

Jim Kelly, Nathan Peterman

5 from

$1.23

1991 Pro Set - [Base] #47.2

Super Bowl XXV Replay - Smith's Safety Boosts Bills' Lead (Bruce Smith) ("The O…

10 from

$0.86

1987 Topps Album Stickers - [Base] #169-21

Bruce Smith, Phil Freeman

3 from

$1.39

2017 Donruss Optic - Illusions - Holo Silver Prizm #4

Andre Reed, Zay Jones

5 from

$1.11

1991 Pro Set - [Base] #47.2

Super Bowl XXV Replay - Smith's Safety Boosts Bills' Lead (Bruce Smith) ("The O…

$1.40

Attributes

Players

Teams

Item Conditions

Sellers

Sold Out

Listing Format

Browse