Buy Now, Ship Later to save on shipping, consolidate your orders, and avoid peak holiday shipping times.

By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
Mario Nintendo Non-Sports Cards
Sort By
Listings
Listings 1 - 100 of 456
1985 Nintendo Super Mario Bros. Disc Menko - [Base] #4270267891

Mario [CGC 9.5 Mint+]

$312.50
2023 Kayou Super Mario - CP #CP-2

Hello Mario

$57.97
1989 Bandai Super Mario Bros. 3 - Trading Cards [Base] - Japanese #4

Raccoon Mario [EX to NM]

$196.99
2022 Panini Super Mario - [Base] #163

Silver - Mario [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$165.76
1993 Banpresto Super Mario World - [Base] - Prism #6

Mario vs Mechakoopa [PSA 9 MINT]

$163.95
1985 Nintendo Super Mario Bros. Disc Menko - [Base] #5814748515

Mario [CGC 9 Mint]

$158.50
2020 Bandai Super Mario Bros. History Wafer Cards - [Base] - Japanese #9

Super Mario Sunshine [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$140.68
1985 Nintendo Super Mario Bros. Disc Menko - [Base] #4870247073

Mario [CGC 9 Mint]

$147.49
1992 Banpresto Super Mario World - [Base] - Prism #6

Jumping Piranha Plant vs Mario [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$115.20
1993 Banpresto Super Mario World - [Base] - Prism #17

Mario vs Rex [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$115.20
1992 Banpresto Super Mario World - [Base] - Prism #9

Mario vs Sumo Bro [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$115.20
1996 Amada Nintendo Super Mario 64 - Course Guide #G7

Mario (Course 11 & 12) [EX to NM]

$115.14
1996 Amada Nintendo Super Mario 64 - Course Guide #G4

Mario (Course 6 & 7) [Good to VG‑EX]

$115.14
2023 Kayou Super Mario - UR #UR-1

Mario

$27.79
1993 Banpresto Nintendo Super Mario Kart Part 5 - [Base] #7

Mario, Donkey Kong Jr., Bowser

$26.35
1993 Banpresto Nintendo Super Mario Kart Part 5 - [Base] #11

Mario, Princess Peach

$26.35
1993 Banpresto Nintendo Super Mario Kart Part 5 - [Base] #9

Mario, Thwomp

$26.35
1989 Bandai Super Mario Bros. 3 - Trading Cards [Base] - Japanese #10

Goomba's Shoe Mario [PSA 9 MINT]

$103.70
1990 Amada Nintendo Super Mario World - [Base] #12

Mario [CGC 6.5 EX/NM+]

$103.64
1985 Nintendo Super Mario Bros. Menko - [Base] #90364

Mario [CGC 6.5 EX/NM+]

$98.00
2020 Bandai Super Mario Bros. History Wafer Cards - [Base] - Japanese #12

New Super Mario Bros. Wii

$24.91
1991 Nagasakiya Super Mario World - [Base] #18

Wiggler, Mario [EX to NM]

$23.47
2021 Ensky Super Mario Bros Sticker Collection Neo - [Base] - Japanese #051

Mario

$23.47
2012 Top Seika Gum Cards Super Mario U - Retrospective #_FIMA.1

Fire Mario (1985) [EX to NM]

$23.47
1992 Banpresto Super Mario World - [Base] - Prism #6

Jumping Piranha Plant vs Mario [Poor to Fair]

$23.47
2009 Enterplay Mario Kart Wii - [Base] #5

Mario

$23.47
1985 Nintendo Super Mario Bros. Menko - [Base] #22222

Mario, Lakitu [CGC 6 EX/NM]

$92.24
1985 Nintendo Super Mario Bros. Menko - [Base] #90364

Mario [CGC 6 EX/NM]

$92.24
1985 Nintendo Super Mario Bros. Disc Menko - [Base] #6852407125

Mario [CGC 8 NM/Mint]

$92.24
1985 Nintendo Super Mario Bros. Disc Menko - [Base] #7610010131

Mario [CGC 8 NM/Mint]

$92.24
1993 Bandai Nintendo Super Mario Kart - [Base] #4

Mario

4 from
$9.63
1993 Kellogg's Apple Jacks Nintendo Power - [Base] #_MARI

Mario

$55.27
2008 Enterplay Nintendo Super Mario Galaxy - [Base] #1

Mario

$20.60
1989 Bandai Super Mario Bros. 3 - Trading Cards [Base] - Japanese #7

Raccoon Mario

5 from
$52.29
2010 Enterplay Super Mario Bros. Wii - [Base] #1

Mario [EX to NM]

$19.16
1993 Bandai Nintendo Super Mario Kart - [Base] - Foil #12

Green Shell [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$69.20
1996-97 Nintendo Power MarioKart 64 - [Base] #MARI

Mario [Good to VG‑EX]

$64.37
2010 Enterplay Super Mario Bros. Wii - Puzzles - Foil #F23

Puzzle 2 - Propeller Mario

2 from
$28.72
1985 Amada Nintendo Famicom Menko - [Base] #95610.2

Mario (Punching up) [Poor to Fair]

$37.88
1985 Amada Nintendo Famicom Menko - [Base] #95610.1

Mario (Kicking)

$37.88
1993 Banpresto Nintendo Super Mario Kart - [Base] - Prism #6

Mushroom [PSA 6 EX‑MT]

$57.74
1993 Banpresto Super Mario Kart - [Base] #1

Super Mario Kart

$57.70
1996 Amada Nintendo Super Mario 64 - [Base] #9

Bowser, Mario

$57.64
1996 Amada Nintendo Super Mario 64 - [Base] #2

Mario

$57.64
1996 Amada Nintendo Super Mario 64 - [Base] #1

Mario

$57.64
1989 Amada Nintendo Super Mario Bros 3 - [Base] #32

Frog Mario

$57.64
1996 Amada Nintendo Super Mario 64 - [Base] #7

Mario

$57.64
1996 Amada Nintendo Super Mario 64 - [Base] #6

Mario

$57.64
1990 Top Sun Super Mario World - [Base] #_BLYO

Mario and Blue Yoshi

5 from
$4.84
2020 Mattel Mario Kart Uno - [Base] #BL+2

Mario

$14.63
1992 Merlin Nintendo Album Stickers - [Base] #255

Mario Golf (Foil) [PSA 7 NM]

$56.32
1992 Merlin Nintendo Album Stickers - [Base] #92

Mario & Luigi [PSA 7 NM]

$56.32
2020 Bandai Super Mario Bros. History Wafer Cards - [Base] - Japanese #1

Super Mario Bros.

$56.10
2020 Bandai Super Mario Bros. History Wafer Cards - [Base] - Japanese #4

Super Mario Land

$55.52
2012 Top Seika Gum Cards Super Mario U - [Base] #_MARI

Mario [Good to VG‑EX]

$13.70
1993 Bandai Nintendo Super Mario Kart - [Base] #12

Green Shell

4 from
$5.99
1992 Merlin Nintendo Album Stickers - [Base] #196

Mario (Foil) [PSA 5 EX]

$52.87
2015 Nintendo Super Mario Bros. Playing Cards - [Base] #10S

Mario

$52.80
2015 Nintendo Super Mario Bros. Playing Cards - [Base] #10S

Mario [PSA 9 MINT]

$52.00
2012 Top Seika Gum Cards Super Mario U - [Base] #_ACMA

Super Acorn Mario [Good to VG‑EX]

$13.41
1993 Bandai Nintendo Super Mario Kart - [Base] #20

Mario [Good to VG‑EX]

$13.41
2021 Ensky Super Mario Bros Sticker Collection Neo - [Base] - Japanese #004

Mario

$13.41
2012 Top Seika Gum Cards Super Mario U - [Base] #_FIMA

Fire Mario [Good to VG‑EX]

$13.41
2012 Top Seika Gum Cards Super Mario U - [Base] #_SUMA

Super Mario [Poor to Fair]

$13.41
2013 Top Seika Gum Cards Super Mario 3D World - [Base] #_FIMA

Fire Mario [EX to NM]

$13.41
2022 Panini Super Mario - Limited Edition #_MARI

Mario [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$47.39
1991 Nintendo Bandai Carddass Super Mario World - [Base] #23

Mario [EX to NM]

$47.12
1996 Nintendo Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars - [Base] #MARI

Mario

3 from
$18.83
2015 Nintendo Mario Trump Retro Art Playing Cards - [Base] #KS

Mario

$11.97
2016 Mattel Super Mario Uno - [Base] #Y+2

Mario (+2)

$11.97
2009 Enterplay Mario Kart Wii - FunTats #T2

Mario

$11.97
2023 Nintendo Wal-Mart Exclusive Pre-Order Super Mario Wonder - [Base] #_WUMA

Wubba Mario

3 from
$9.10
1992 Banpresto Super Mario World - [Base] - Prism #33

Mario vs Bowser [Good to VG‑EX]

$46.24
1992 Banpresto Super Mario World - [Base] - Prism #35

Princess Peach, Mario [EX to NM]

$46.24
2024 Lithos RantCPU - Promo Exlusives #29

Spicy Meatball

3 from
$4.84
1992 Merlin Nintendo Album Stickers - [Base] #146

Mario [PSA 5 EX]

$41.37
1992 Epoch Barcode Battler Nintendo Super Mario Edition - [Base] #_JUMP

Jump (Mario) [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$40.50
1985 Nintendo Super Mario Bros. Disc Menko - [Base] #5369258147

Mario [CGC 7 Near Mint]

$40.50
1985 Nintendo Super Mario Bros. Disc Menko - [Base] #0477704868

Mario [CGC 7 Near Mint]

$40.50
1985 Nintendo Super Mario Bros. Disc Menko - [Base] #4872286852

Mario [CGC 7.5 Near Mint+]

$40.50
1985 Nintendo Super Mario Bros. Disc Menko - [Base] #2952641745

Mario [CGC 7.5 Near Mint+]

$40.50
1993 Kellogg's Tony's Tips Nintendo - [Base] #_MAKA

Super Mario Kart

2 from
$23.54
2016 Mattel Super Mario Uno - [Base] #YS

Mario (Skip)

$10.54
1985 Amada Nintendo Famicom Menko - [Base] #44763.2

Mario

2 from
$8.29
2011-20 Nintendo 3DS AR Cards - [Base] #A-2

Mario

5 from
$3.22
2016 Mattel Super Mario Uno - [Base] #GR

Mario (Reverse)

2 from
$6.00
1993 Banpresto Super Mario World - [Base] - Prism #3

Mario, Luigi, Princess Peach

$35.04
2022 Panini Super Mario - [Base] #145

Gold - Mario [PSA 6 EX‑MT]

$23.08
2020 Bandai Super Mario Bros. History Wafer Cards - [Base] - Japanese #3

Super Mario Bros. 3 [PSA 9 MINT]

$34.74
2020 Bandai Super Mario Bros. History Wafer Cards - [Base] - Japanese #21

New Super Mario Bros. U Deluxe [PSA 9 MINT]

$34.74
1985 Nintendo Super Mario Bros. Disc Menko - [Base] #9256148515

Mario [CGC 7 Near Mint]

$34.74
1993 Banpresto Super Mario World - [Base] - Prism #17

Mario vs Rex [EX to NM]

$34.70
1993 Banpresto Super Mario World - [Base] - Prism #2

Mario vz Reznor

$34.70
1993 Banpresto Super Mario World - [Base] - Prism #21

Mario vs Koopa Troopa, Para Troopa [EX to NM]

$34.70
1993 Banpresto Super Mario World - [Base] - Prism #21

Mario vs Koopa Troopa, Para Troopa

$34.70
1993 Banpresto Super Mario World - [Base] - Prism #22

Mario vs Caped Koopas

$34.70
1993 Banpresto Super Mario World - [Base] - Prism #16

Mario vs Charging Chuck [EX to NM]

$34.70
1993 Banpresto Super Mario World - [Base] - Prism #11

Mario vs Kamek

$34.70
1993 Banpresto Super Mario World - [Base] - Prism #5

Mario & Baby Yoshi [EX to NM]

$34.70
1993 Banpresto Super Mario World - [Base] - Prism #20

Mario & Dolphin

$34.70
<< 1 2 3 4 5 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 5