By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
Hall of Fame Baseball Cards Graded PSA 5 EX
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Sold Out
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Baseball (391)
2020's (1)
2010's (3)
2000's (18)
1990's (49)
1980's (45)
1970's (103)
1960's (119)
1950's (47)
1940's (2)
1930's (2)
1920's (1)
1910's (1)
Listings 1 - 100 of 391
1936 World Wide Gum Big League - V355 #6

Arky Vaughan [PSA 5 EX]

$4,430.00
1954 Bowman - [Base] #65

Mickey Mantle [PSA 5 EX]

$4,211.10
1960 Topps - [Base] #350

Mickey Mantle [PSA 5 EX]

$1,406.10
2000 Skybox - Higher Level - Star Rubies #2 HL

Derek Jeter [PSA 5 EX] #/50

$1,130.00
1956 Topps - [Base] #130.1

Willie Mays (Gray Back) [PSA 5 EX]

$998.00
1952 Topps - [Base] #195

Minnie Minoso [PSA 5 EX]

$799.99
1966 Topps - [Base] #50

Mickey Mantle [PSA 5 EX]

$723.11
1961 Topps - [Base] #578

High # - Mickey Mantle [PSA 5 EX]

$718.60
1922 Strip Cards "G-4-22" - W501 #14

E.S. Rice [PSA 5 EX]

$691.10
1958 Topps - [Base] #30.1

Hank Aaron (Player Name in White) [PSA 5 EX]

$652.60
1965 O-Pee-Chee - [Base] #16

1965 Rookie Stars - Joe Morgan, Sonny Jackson [PSA 5 EX]

$581.10
1970 Topps - [Base] #712

High # - Nolan Ryan [PSA 5 EX]

$471.10
1967 Topps - [Base] #200

Willie Mays [PSA 5 EX]

$216.80
1992 Studio - Heritage Series #BC-14

Kirby Puckett [PSA 5 EX]

$579.99
1912 Hassan Triple Folders - T202 #_JAJE

James Archer, John Evers (Evers Makes a Safe Slide) [PSA 5 EX]

$559.10
1973 Topps - [Base] #615

High Number - 1973 Rookie Third Basemen (Ron Cey, John Hilton, Mike Schmidt) [P…

$340.00
1961 Topps - [Base] #388

Roberto Clemente (Called Bob on Card) [PSA 5 EX]

$274.00
1949 Bowman - [Base] - Gray Back #98.1

Phil Rizzuto (No Name on Front) [PSA 5 EX]

$449.99
1951 Bowman - [Base] #58

Enos Slaughter [PSA 5 EX]

2 from
$448.90
1969 Topps - [Base] #95

Johnny Bench [PSA 5 EX]

$340.00
1962 Topps - [Base] #320

Hank Aaron [PSA 5 EX]

$247.71
1958 Topps - [Base] #487

Sport Magazine '58 All Star Selection - Mickey Mantle [PSA 5 EX]

2 from
$373.00
1934-36 National Chicle Batter-Up - R318 #17

Lloyd Waner [PSA 5 EX]

$363.10
1966 Topps - [Base] #500

Hank Aaron [PSA 5 EX]

$341.10
1962 Post - [Base] #5.2

Mickey Mantle (Post Logo on Back; Stats in Yellow Box) [PSA 5 EX]

$518.40
1959 Topps - [Base] #478

Roberto Clemente (Called Bob on Card) [PSA 5 EX]

2 from
$341.10
1964 Topps - [Base] #440

Roberto Clemente [PSA 5 EX]

$302.60
1959 Topps - [Base] #380

Hank Aaron [PSA 5 EX]

$330.09
1956 Topps - [Base] #15.1

Ernie Banks (Gray Back) [PSA 5 EX]

$327.77
1953 Topps - [Base] #207

Whitey Ford [PSA 5 EX]

$317.95
1964 Topps - [Base] #150

Willie Mays [PSA 5 EX]

2 from
$297.10
1965 Topps - [Base] #16

1965 Rookie Stars - Joe Morgan, Sonny Jackson [PSA 5 EX]

2 from
$176.10
1971 Topps - [Base] #513

Nolan Ryan [PSA 5 EX]

$230.55
1961 Topps - [Base] #150

Willie Mays [PSA 5 EX]

$225.60
1958 Topps - [Base] #310

Ernie Banks [PSA 5 EX]

$192.60
1966 Topps - [Base] #580

High # - Billy Williams [PSA 5 EX]

$275.10
1961 Topps - [Base] #579

High # - Willie Mays [PSA 5 EX]

$275.10
1966 Topps - [Base] #1

Willie Mays [PSA 5 EX]

$264.10
1969 Topps - [Base] #190

Willie Mays [PSA 5 EX]

3 from
$181.60
1975 O-Pee-Chee - [Base] #5

'74 Highlights - Nolan Ryan [PSA 5 EX]

$253.10
1964 Topps - [Base] #541

High # - Phil Roof, Phil Niekro [PSA 5 EX]

$231.10
1959 Topps - [Base] #180

Yogi Berra [PSA 5 EX]

$231.09
1961 Topps - [Base] #344

Sandy Koufax [PSA 5 EX]

2 from
$220.10
1951 Bowman - [Base] #62

Lou Boudreau [PSA 5 EX]

$228.90
1975 O-Pee-Chee - [Base] #620

1975 Rookie Catchers-Outfielders - Gary Carter, Marc Hill, Dan Meyer, Leon Robe…

$225.60
1971 Topps - [Base] #600

Willie Mays [PSA 5 EX]

$214.60
1956 Topps - [Base] #200

Bob Feller [PSA 5 EX]

$209.10
1962 Topps - [Base] #575

High # - Red Schoendienst [PSA 5 EX]

$206.90
1951 Bowman - [Base] #290

Bill Dickey [PSA 5 EX]

$206.90
1960 Topps - [Base] #480

Yogi Berra [PSA 5 EX]

$203.60
1958 Topps - [Base] #285

Frank Robinson [PSA 5 EX]

2 from
$253.10
1965 Topps - [Base] #581

High # - Tony Perez, Kevin Collins, Dave Ricketts [PSA 5 EX]

$166.77
1958 Topps - [Base] #476

Sport Magazine '58 All Star Selection - Stan Musial [PSA 5 EX]

$120.00
1970 Topps - [Base] #660

High # - Johnny Bench [PSA 5 EX]

2 from
$178.41
1967 Topps - [Base] #423

Willie Mays, Willie McCovey [PSA 5 EX]

$192.60
1970 Topps - [Base] #600

Willie Mays [PSA 5 EX]

3 from
$159.60
1960 Topps - [Base] #564

High # - Willie Mays [PSA 5 EX]

$178.30
1963 Topps - [Base] #415

Bob Gibson [PSA 5 EX]

$176.10
1971 Topps - [Base] #250

Johnny Bench [PSA 5 EX]

2 from
$96.28
1963 Topps - [Base] #173

Bombers' Best (Tom Tresh, Mickey Mantle, Bobby Richardson) [PSA 5 EX]

$231.10
1966 Topps - [Base] #100

Sandy Koufax [PSA 5 EX]

$208.00
1975 Topps - [Base] #228

George Brett [PSA 5 EX]

2 from
$204.15
1954 Topps - [Base] #3.1

Monte Irvin (White Back) [PSA 5 EX]

$148.60
1956 Topps - [Base] #113.1

Phil Rizzuto (Gray Back) [PSA 5 EX]

$143.10
2005 Donruss Classics - Membership - VIP Awards Materials #MS-12

Hank Aaron [PSA 5 EX] #/10

$174.99
1969 Topps - [Base] #100

Hank Aaron [PSA 5 EX]

$174.45
1954 Bowman - [Base] #58

Pee Wee Reese [PSA 5 EX]

$168.40
1975 O-Pee-Chee - [Base] #660

Hank Aaron [PSA 5 EX]

$165.10
1961 Topps - [Base] #482

Most Valuable Players - Willie Mays [PSA 5 EX]

$159.60
1959 Topps - [Base] #212.1

Fence Busters (Hank Aaron, Eddie Mathews) (Gray Back) [PSA 5 EX]

$153.00
1969 Topps - [Base] #597

High # - Bobby Floyd, Larry Burchart, Rollie Fingers [PSA 5 EX]

$186.97
1959 Topps - [Base] #350

Ernie Banks [PSA 5 EX]

$165.10
1961 Topps - [Base] #307

World Series - Game #2 - Mantle Slams 2 Homers [PSA 5 EX]

$154.10
1962 Topps - [Base] #50

Stan Musial [PSA 5 EX]

$147.50
1957 Topps - [Base] #125

Al Kaline [PSA 5 EX]

$147.50
1957 Topps - [Base] #80

Gil Hodges [PSA 5 EX]

$147.50
1975 Topps Mini - [Base] #223

Robin Yount [PSA 5 EX]

$110.65
1968 Topps - [Base] #45

Tom Seaver [PSA 5 EX]

$109.56
1980 Topps - [Base] #482

Rickey Henderson [PSA 5 EX]

$109.52
1953 Bowman Color - [Base] #65

Robin Roberts [PSA 5 EX]

$145.30
1958 Topps - [Base] #321

Sluggers Supreme (Ted Kluszewski, Ted Williams) [PSA 5 EX]

$142.00
1973 Topps - [Base] #305

Willie Mays [PSA 5 EX]

$123.96
1979 O-Pee-Chee - [Base] #52

Ozzie Smith [PSA 5 EX]

$132.10
1994 Upper Deck - [Base] - Electric Diamond #19

Michael Jordan [PSA 5 EX]

$120.83
1961 Topps - [Base] #290

Stan Musial [PSA 5 EX]

$132.10
1997 Pinnacle Certified - [Base] #51

Derek Jeter [PSA 5 EX]

$120.00
1964 Topps - [Base] #21

Yogi Berra [PSA 5 EX]

2 from
$120.00
1962 Topps - [Base] #310

Whitey Ford [PSA 5 EX]

$120.00
1960 Topps - [Base] #420.1

Eddie Mathews (White Back) [PSA 5 EX]

$120.00
1958 Topps - [Base] #100.2

Early Wynn (Team Name in Yellow) [PSA 5 EX]

$120.00
1963 Topps - [Base] #138

Pride of the N.L. (Willie Mays, Stan Musial) [PSA 5 EX]

2 from
$114.10
1963 Topps - [Base] #2

League Leaders - 1962 American League Batting Leaders (Mickey Mantle, Floyd Rob…

2 from
$110.65
1970 Topps - [Base] #350

Roberto Clemente [PSA 5 EX]

$89.90
1960 Topps - [Base] #136

Sport Magazine 1960 Rookie Star - Jim Kaat [PSA 5 EX]

$88.79
1974 Topps - [Base] #20

Nolan Ryan [PSA 5 EX]

$84.20
1959 Topps - [Base] #439

Brooks Robinson [PSA 5 EX]

$83.17
1972 Topps - [Base] #299

Hank Aaron [PSA 5 EX]

$80.75
1975 Topps - [Base] #223.1

Robin Yount [PSA 5 EX]

2 from
$77.99
1973 Topps - [Base] #50

Roberto Clemente [PSA 5 EX]

3 from
$72.82
1979 Topps - [Base] #116

Ozzie Smith [PSA 5 EX]

3 from
$72.69
<< 1 2 3 4 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 4