Gary Sheffield Hall of Fame Baseball Cards

1993 Fleer - [Base] #356

Ryne Sandberg, Gary Sheffield [EX to NM]

$1.23

1993 Topps - Black Gold - Prizes #B

Winner B

24 from

$1.22

1993 Pinnacle - Team Pinnacle #6

Edgar Martinez, Gary Sheffield

4 from

$2.50

1993 Topps - [Base] - Inaugural Florida Marlins #403

1992 Topps All Stars - Gary Sheffield, Edgar Martinez

3 from

$3.99

2004 Playoff Absolute Memorabilia - Team Tandems #TAN-5

Gary Sheffield, Derek Jeter #/250

$23.53

1993 Topps - Black Gold - Redemptions #ABCD

Winner ABCD

6 from

$17.62

1993 Topps - Black Gold - Redemptions #AB

Winner A/B

25 from

$2.83

2002 Upper Deck Diamond Connection - Bat Around #BA-SJJM

Gary Sheffield, Andruw Jones, Chipper Jones, Greg Maddux

3 from

$11.75

2018 Panini Donruss - [Base] #215

Multiplayer Horizontal - All-Star Infielders

3 from

$1.21

1994 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] - 1st Day Issue #180

Tale of 2 Players - Gary Sheffield, Fred McGriff

4 from

$5.03

2018 Panini Donruss - [Base] - Press Proof Gold #215

Multiplayer Horizontal - All-Star Infielders #/99

$4.45

1993 Topps - Black Gold - Redemptions #D.2

Winner D (Winner B players pictured)

11 from

$2.57

1993 Upper Deck - [Base] #474

Four Corners (Gary Sheffield, Phil Plantier, Tony Gwynn, Fred McGriff)

18 from

$0.89

1993 Topps - Black Gold - Redemptions #B

Winner B [EX to NM]

2 from

$1.75

1993 Topps - Black Gold - Prizes #A/B

Winner A/B

9 from

$3.42

1993 Topps - Black Gold - Redemptions #B

Winner B

25 from

$1.35

1994 Sportflics 2000 All-Star FanFest - [Base] #AS8

Gary Sheffield, Kirby Puckett [EX to NM] #/10,000

$14.34

2001 SP Game Bat Edition Milestone - Piece of the Action Quad Bat #GHSK

Luis Gonzalez, Todd Helton, Gary Sheffield, Jeff Kent [EX to NM]

$12.90

2006 Topps Co-Signers - Changing Faces - HyperSilver Bronze #11-B

Gary Sheffield, Mickey Mantle #/75

$24.98

2004 Upper Deck Sweet Spot - Sweet Threads Dual - Jerseys #STD-SM

Gary Sheffield, Pedro Martinez #/150

$21.24

1993 Fleer - [Base] #356

Ryne Sandberg, Gary Sheffield

17 from

$0.80

1996 Select Certified Edition - Inter-League Preview #16

Gary Sheffield, Mike Mussina

5 from

$10.59

1996 Select - Team Nucleus #16

Andre Dawson, Charles Johnson, Gary Sheffield

2 from

$4.28

1993 Topps - Black Gold - Redemptions #CD.2

Winner C/D (Winner A/B players pictured)

5 from

$14.34

1997 Pinnacle - Team Pinnacle #10

Jeff Bagwell, Eric Young, Ken Caminiti, Chipper Jones, Mike Piazza, Barry Bonds…

$23.54

2005 Playoff Absolute Memorabilia - Team Quads #TQ-5

Gary Sheffield, Hideki Matsui, Mike Mussina, Jorge Posada #/150

$6.87

2022 Leaf Lumber - Silver Sluggers Relics #SS-09

Jorge Posada, Carlos Delgado, Bret Boone, Vernon Wells, Manny Ramirez, Todd Hel…

$45.39

1990 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #57.109

Mickey Tettleton (Roberto Alomar 109; Gary Sheffield 202)

$1.69

1990 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #12.109

Ozzie Smith (Roberto Alomar 109, Gary Sheffield 202)

2 from

$6.29

1997 SP - Marquee Matchups #MM16

Gary Sheffield (Vladimir Guerrero on Back)

12 from

$0.91

2004 Topps - [Base] #346

League Leaders - Preston Wilson, Gary Sheffield, Jim Thome [EX to NM]

$1.37

2005 Donruss Zenith - Mozaics #M-16

Gary Sheffield, Hideki Matsui, Mike Mussina [EX to NM]

$1.12

1994 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] - Members Only #180

Tale of 2 Players - Gary Sheffield, Fred McGriff [EX to NM]

$3.67

2003 Topps Bazooka - Stickers #17

Benito Santiago, Barry Larkin, Gary Sheffield, Carlos Delgado

$5.99

2005 Playoff Absolute Memorabilia - Team Quads - Spectrum #TQ-5

Gary Sheffield, Hideki Matsui, Mike Mussina, Jorge Posada [EX to NM] …

$23.20

2005 Donruss Elite - Face 2 Face - Bats #FF-13

Pedro Martinez, Gary Sheffield #/150

3 from

$9.73

2002 Upper Deck Diamond Connection - Bat Around - Gold #BA-SJJM

Gary Sheffield, Andruw Jones, Chipper Jones, Greg Maddux #/50

$46.24

2005 Donruss Elite - Face 2 Face #FF-13

Pedro Martinez, Gary Sheffield #/1,500

9 from

$1.40

2003 Fleer Platinum - Heart of the Order #14HO

Chipper Jones, Andruw Jones, Gary Sheffield

4 from

$3.01

1993 Topps - [Base] #403

1992 Topps All Stars - Gary Sheffield, Edgar Martinez

50 from

$0.76

2005 Donruss Elite - Face 2 Face - Black #FF-13

Pedro Martinez, Gary Sheffield #/500

2 from

$4.33

2001 SP Game Bat Edition Milestone - Piece of the Action Quad Bat #GHSK

Luis Gonzalez, Todd Helton, Gary Sheffield, Jeff Kent

$26.10

1993 Leaf - Gold Leaf Stars Update #5

Wade Boggs, Gary Sheffield

16 from

$0.99

1990 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #21.12

Jerome Walton (Ryne Sandberg 12, Gary Sheffield 326)

$3.69

1993 Pinnacle - Team Pinnacle #6

Edgar Martinez, Gary Sheffield [EX to NM]

2 from

$5.14

2008 Upper Deck Ballpark Collection - [Base] #208

Quad Swatch Memorabilia - Carlos Guillen, Brandon Inge, Gary Sheffield, Ivan Ro…

2 from

$5.72

1993 Topps - Black Gold - Redemptions #ABCD

Winner ABCD [CSG 9 Mint]

$34.47

1993 Topps - Black Gold - Redemptions #D.2

Winner D (Winner B players pictured) [Poor to Fair]

$3.65

1994 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] #180

Tale of 2 Players - Gary Sheffield, Fred McGriff

3 from

$1.39

1993 Topps - [Base] - Inaugural Colorado Rockies #403

1992 Topps All Stars - Gary Sheffield, Edgar Martinez

6 from

$1.23

2005 Topps Bazooka - 4 on 1 Stickers #25

Albert Pujols, Gary Sheffield, Magglio Ordonez, Chipper Jones

2 from

$2.42

2001 SP Game Bat Edition Milestone - Piece of the Action Triple Bat #SGB

Gary Sheffield, Shawn Green, Adrian Beltre [EX to NM]

$10.89

2004 Topps - [Base] #346

League Leaders - Preston Wilson, Gary Sheffield, Jim Thome

5 from

$1.39

2001 Upper Deck Reserve - Game-Used Base and Ball Triple #B-BSH

Barry Bonds, Todd Helton, Gary Sheffield

2 from

$21.24

2022 Leaf Lumber - Lumber Team 8's Relics - Platinum #LT8-08

Ted Simmons, Ben Oglivie, Robin Yount, Paul Molitor, Gorman Thomas, Christian Y…

$58.04

2008 Upper Deck A Piece of History - Franchise Members 4 #FM4-8

Jim Thome, David Ortiz, Frank Thomas, Gary Sheffield #/799

3 from

$5.99

1990 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #57.109

Mickey Tettleton (Roberto Alomar 109; Gary Sheffield 202) [EX to NM]

$2.84

1990 Topps Super Star Sticker Back Cards - [Base] #57.109

Mickey Tettleton (Roberto Alomar 109; Gary Sheffield 202) [Good to VG…

$2.27

2008 Upper Deck A Piece of History - Franchise Members 4 - Gold Jerseys #FM4-8

Jim Thome, David Ortiz, Frank Thomas, Gary Sheffield [EX to NM] #/99

$34.74

1993 Topps - [Base] - Factory Set Micro #403

1992 Topps All Stars - Gary Sheffield, Edgar Martinez

3 from

$1.30

1993 Topps - [Base] #403

1992 Topps All Stars - Gary Sheffield, Edgar Martinez [EX to NM]

2 from

$1.11

1993 Topps - [Base] - Gold #403

1992 Topps All Stars - Gary Sheffield, Edgar Martinez

24 from

$0.80

1993 Topps - Black Gold - Prizes #ABCD

Winner ABCD

2 from

$19.85

2006 Topps Co-Signers - Changing Faces - Silver Bronze #11-B

Gary Sheffield, Mickey Mantle #/125

2 from

$7.15

2001 Upper Deck Reserve - Game-Used Jersey Trios #J-BSH

Barry Bonds, Todd Helton, Gary Sheffield

$14.91

2005 Donruss Elite - Face 2 Face - Red #FF-13

Pedro Martinez, Gary Sheffield #/750

2 from

$7.73

2005 Donruss Zenith - Mozaics #M-16

Gary Sheffield, Hideki Matsui, Mike Mussina

6 from

$0.94

1993 Donruss - Spirit of the Game #SG12

Gary Sheffield, Fred McGriff

21 from

$0.93

2006 Topps Co-Signers - Changing Faces - Red #11-B

Gary Sheffield, Mickey Mantle #/150

$4.82

2006 Topps Co-Signers - Changing Faces - HyperSilver Red #11-B

Gary Sheffield, Mickey Mantle #/25

$7.44

2006 Topps Co-Signers - Changing Faces - Silver Gold #11-B

Gary Sheffield, Mickey Mantle #/50

$8.59

2006 Topps Co-Signers - Changing Faces - Silver Red #11-B

Gary Sheffield, Mickey Mantle #/100

3 from

$5.14

1993 Topps - Black Gold - Prizes #A/B

Winner A/B [EX to NM]

$9.28

1993 Pinnacle - [Base] #300

The Idols - Gary Sheffield, Barry Larkin

13 from

$0.76

2001 Upper Deck Vintage - [Base] #241

2000 Dodgers Lineup

$2.53

2006 Topps Co-Signers - Changing Faces - Silver Blue #11-B

Gary Sheffield, Mickey Mantle #/75

$10.59

1993 Topps - Black Gold - Redemptions #AB

Winner A/B [EX to NM]

$11.66

2009 SPx - Winning Materials 4 #WM4-OGTS

Jim Thome, Jason Giambi, Gary Sheffield, David Ortiz

$29.00

2007 Upper Deck Spectrum - Aligning the Stars #AS-GRS

Ken Griffey Jr., Manny Ramirez, Gary Sheffield #/99

$115.24

2005 Fleer Classic Clippings - Bat Rack #BR-VG/MR/SS/GS

Vladimir Guerrero, Manny Ramirez, Sammy Sosa, Gary Sheffield

$46.24

1990 Publications International Stickers - Uncut 36-Sticker Sheet #GS-RS

Gary Sheffield - Rick Sutcliffe

$10.59

1990 Publications International Stickers - Uncut 36-Sticker Sheet #RR-GS

R.J. Reynolds - Gary Sheffield

$10.59

2005 Donruss Elite - Face 2 Face - Gold #FF-13

Pedro Martinez, Gary Sheffield #/150

$3.76

2006 Topps Co-Signers - Changing Faces - Gold #11-B

Gary Sheffield, Mickey Mantle #/115

4 from

$6.58

1993 Leaf - Gold Leaf Stars #15

Gary Sheffield, Edgar Martinez

2 from

$1.39

2007 Topps Co-Signers - [Base] - Silver Red #60.3

Gary Sheffield, Ivan Rodriguez #/199

$1.97

2006 Topps Bazooka - 4 on 1 Stickers #8

J.D. Drew, Andruw Jones, Gary Sheffield, Vladimir Guerrero

$3.19

2004 Upper Deck Sweet Spot - Sweet Threads Dual - Jerseys #STD-SM

Gary Sheffield, Pedro Martinez [EX to NM] #/150

$23.54

1993 Pinnacle - [Base] #300

The Idols - Gary Sheffield, Barry Larkin [EX to NM]

$1.14

1993 Topps - Black Gold - Prizes #B

Winner B [EX to NM]

$2.54

2005 Donruss Elite - Face 2 Face - Bat/Jersey Combos #FF-13

Pedro Martinez, Gary Sheffield [EX to NM] #/75

$16.35

1993 Fleer - [Base] #356

Ryne Sandberg, Gary Sheffield [Noted]

$1.40

2003 Fleer Platinum - Heart of the Order - Materials #_JJS

Chipper Jones, Andruw Jones, Gary Sheffield (Chipper Jones Jersey) #/400

$9.74

2004 Donruss Classics - Timeless Triples #TT-6

Alex Rodriguez, Derek Jeter, Gary Sheffield #/500

2 from

$10.89

1996 Panini Fleer Album Stickers - [Base] - Block of Six #8-10/15-17

Chipper Jones, Quilvio Veras, Chris Hammond, Gary Sheffield, Greg Colbrunn, Moi…

5 from

$4.28

1993 Topps - Black Gold - Prizes #B

Winner B [Noted]

4 from

$1.40

2006 Topps Co-Signers - Changing Faces - Bronze #11-B

Gary Sheffield, Mickey Mantle #/150

2 from

$2.78

1994 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] - Golden Rainbow #180

Tale of 2 Players - Gary Sheffield, Fred McGriff

4 from

$1.12

2001 SP Authentic - UD Exclusives Game Jerseys Combos #UDC-SW

Gary Sheffield, Dave Winfield

$10.89

1998 Topps Finest - Mystery Finest Series 1 #M42

Gary Sheffield, Jeff Bagwell

$7.44

Attributes

Players

Teams

Item Conditions

Sellers

Sold Out

Listing Format

Browse