Gary Sheffield Autographed Baseball Cards

1989 Upper Deck - [Base] #13.2

Star Rookie - Gary Sheffield (Right Side Up SS on Front) [BAS BGS Aut…

$97.97

2022 Topps Archives Signature Series - Retired Player Edition Buybacks #90T-718

Gary Sheffield (1990 Topps) [Buyback] #/1

$255.83

2001 SP Authentic - [Base] #61

Gary Sheffield [JSA Certified COA Sticker]

$141.45

2024 Topps Triple Threads - Autograph Relic Combos - Amethyst #ARC-SRW

Gary Sheffield, Iván Rodríguez, Dontrelle Willis #/27

$175.28

2025 Topps Series 1 - 1990 Topps Baseball Autographs - Black #90A-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/10

$142.06

2025 Topps Chrome - Chrome Legends Autographs - Orange Refractor #CLA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

$169.78

2024 Topps Pristine - Pristine Pieces Autograph Relics - Gold Refractor #PPAR-GS

Gary Sheffield [SGC 10 GEM] #/50

$165.10

2015 Panini National Treasures - Game Ball Signatures #42

Gary Sheffield #/20

$158.78

2025 Topps Chrome - Chrome Legends Autographs - Orange Refractor #CLA-GS

Gary Sheffield [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/25

$149.70

2021 Topps Archives Signature Series - Retired Player Edition Buybacks #04TT-TT18

Gary Sheffield (2004 Topps Total Topps) [Buyback] #/1

$143.76

2023 Panini National Treasures - Definitive Ink - Holo Silver #DI-GS

Gary Sheffield #/10

$126.60

2025 Leaf Seasons in the Sun - Signature Souvenir - Holo Pattern Dots #SSO-GS1

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated] #/6

$52.64

2004 Donruss Diamond Kings - [Base] - Silver Framed Signatures #82

Gary Sheffield #/5

$115.24

2013 Topps Supreme - Retired and Active Autographs - Black #SA-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/5

$115.24

2004 Leaf Certified Cuts - [Base] - Marble Gold Position Materials Signatures #208

Gary Sheffield #/10

$58.33

2023 Leaf Metal - Autographs - Printing Plate Yellow #BA-GS1

Gary Sheffield #/1

$114.39

1992 Upper Deck - [Base] #84

Bloodlines - Gary Sheffield, Dwight Gooden [BAS BGS Authentic]

$103.75

2001 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection - Ultimate Signatures - Silver #GS

Gary Sheffield #/24

$41.83

1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.1

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (Denotes on Back) [BAS Authentic]

$81.26

1993 Classic Best Gold Minor League - Autographs #_GASH

Gary Sheffield [BAS BGS Authentic] #/2,050

$76.06

2025 Leaf A Bronx Legacy - Penstripes - Silver Spectrum Holofoil #P-GS1

Gary Sheffield #/2

$92.25

2006 Bowman Originals - Buyback Autographs #3.2

Gary Sheffield (2003 Bowman Chrome) [Buyback] #/6

$92.24

2004 Leaf Certified Materials - Fabric of the Game - AL/NL Autographs #FG-164

Gary Sheffield #/10

$55.91

2004 Leaf Certified Materials - Fabric of the Game - Autographs #FG-164

Gary Sheffield #/10

$55.91

2024 Panini National Treasures - Timeless Talents Signatures #TTS-GS

Gary Sheffield #/49

$86.79

2020 Topps Chrome Black - Chrome Black Autographs #CBA-GS

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated]

$49.70

1989 Donruss - [Base] #31.2

Rated Rookie - Gary Sheffield (*Denotes on Back) [BAS Authentic]

$68.66

2004 SP Authentic - SP Buyback Autographs #75

Gary Sheffield #/43

$80.74

2018 Panini Flawless - Legendary Signatures - Ruby #LS-GS

Gary Sheffield #/20

$79.60

2021 Topps Tier One - Prime Performers Autographs - Bronze Ink #PPA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

$64.94

1989 Topps - [Base] #343.1

Future Star - Gary Sheffield (Small Gap Between Hat and Future Stars Header) [B…

2 from

$54.30

2010 Topps Tribute - Relic Autographs #TAR-GS

Gary Sheffield #/99

$37.34

2024 Topps Five Star - Autographs #FSA-GS.1

Gary Sheffield [PSA 7 NM]

$69.25

2023 Topps Five Star - Silver Signatures #SS-GS

Gary Sheffield #/40

$69.25

1989 Score - [Base] #625

Gary Sheffield [BAS BGS Authentic]

$55.65

2021 Topps Tier One - Clear One Autographs #C1A-GS

Gary Sheffield #/10

$63.50

2005 Topps Pristine - [Base] #195

Base Rare - Gary Sheffield #/100

3 from

$46.25

2013 Topps Tribute - Tribute to the Stars Autographs #TSA-GS3

Gary Sheffield #/24

$61.49

2021 Topps Chrome Platinum Anniversary - Autographs - Gold Refractor #PA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/50

$58.27

2022 Topps Museum Collection - Archival Autographs - Copper #AA-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/50

$58.04

2022 Topps On Demand Dynamic Duals - [Base] - Autographs #12-A

Gary Sheffield, Dontrelle Willis

$58.04

2022 Topps Archives - 1992 Topps MLB Debut Autographs - Silver #72DB-GS

Gary Sheffield #/99

$32.17

2024 Panini Boys of Summer - Fabric of the Game Signatures - Leather #44

Gary Sheffield #/25

2 from

$28.99

2025 Leaf A Bronx Legacy - Penstripes - Green Spectrum Holofoil #P-GS1

Gary Sheffield #/5

$58.03

2021 Topps Archives Signature Series - Retired Player Edition Buybacks #16TA-158

Gary Sheffield (2016 Topps Archives) [Buyback] #/42

$57.75

2021 Topps Clearly Authentic Autographs - 1986 Topps Baseball - Green #86TBA-GS

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated] #/99

$32.44

2022 Topps Museum Collection - Archival Autographs #AA-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/125

$31.59

2021 Topps Chrome Platinum Anniversary - Autographs #PA-GS

Gary Sheffield

$29.29

2021 Topps Tier One - Tier One Talent Autographs #T1TA-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/300

3 from

$28.14

2010 Topps Tribute - Relic Autographs - Black #TAR-GS4

Gary Sheffield #/50

$57.74

2012 Topps Museum Collection - Signature Swatches Autograph Dual Relics #SSADR-GS

Gary Sheffield #/99

$57.74

2004 Fleer National Pastime - Signature Swings - Gold #SSA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

$35.21

2022 Topps Pristine - Slice of the Star Autograph Relics #SSAR-GA

Gary Sheffield

$34.87

2005 Playoff Absolute Memorabilia - Absolutely Ink - Spectrum Single Materials #AI-116

Gary Sheffield #/50

$34.87

1993 Fleer Ultra - [Base] #122

Gary Sheffield [CAS Certified Sealed]

$17.68

2024 Topps Inception - Dawn of Greatness Autographs - Blue #DGA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

$56.60

2022 Topps On Demand Dynamic Duals - [Base] - Blue Autographs #12-A

Gary Sheffield, Dontrelle Willis #/25

2 from

$55.45

1998 Topps - [Base] #166

Gary Sheffield [BAS Authentic]

$42.03

2023 Leaf Vivid - Autographs - Purple Prismatic #BA-GS1

Gary Sheffield #/2

$51.65

2004 Skybox Autographics - Autographs - Silver #A-GS

Gary Sheffield #/100

$50.85

2025 Topps Tier One - Autographed Tier One Relics - Blue Dual #AT1R-GS

Gary Sheffield #/99

2 from

$40.79

2013 Topps Supreme - Retired and Active Autographs - Black #SA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/5

$34.16

2025 Leaf Seasons in the Sun - Signature Souvenir - Holo Pink #SSO-GS1

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated] #/7

$47.40

2013 Topps Supreme - Retired and Active Autographs - Green #SA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/10

$40.50

2024 Topps Five Star - Autographs - Purple #FSA-GS.1

Gary Sheffield #/50

$46.83

2001 SP Authentic - Buyback Autographs #114

Gary Sheffield #/70

$46.77

2021 Topps Clearly Authentic Autographs - 1986 Topps Baseball #86TBA-GS

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated]

$46.54

2004 Topps Pristine - Personal Endorsements Autographs #PEA-GS

Gary Sheffield

2 from

$28.99

2020 Topps Archives - Fan Favorites Autographs - Silver #FFA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/99

$41.90

2025 Leaf Seasons in the Sun - Signature Seasons - Holo Platinum #SSE-GS1

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated] #/5

$46.25

2024 Topps Allen & Ginter X - Framed Mini Autographs #MA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

$46.25

2000 Topps - [Base] #105

Gary Sheffield [BAS Authentic]

$37.26

2001 Fleer Showcase - Autographics - Silver #_GASH

Gary Sheffield #/250

$45.38

2025 Topps Series 1 - 1990 Topps Baseball Autographs #90A-GSH

Gary Sheffield

$43.37

2023 Topps Allen & Ginter - Framed Mini Autographs - Black Frame #MA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

$42.79

2017 Topps High Tek - [Base] - Blue Rainbow Autographs #HT-GS

Gary Sheffield #/50

$42.09

2004 Playoff Honors - [Base] - Silver Signatures #133

Gary Sheffield #/25

$41.94

2025 Panini Three and Two - Legendary Signatures - 1st Off the Line FOTL Red #LS-GS

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated] #/6

$41.65

2018 Topps Tier One - Prime Performers Autographs - Silver Ink #PPA-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/10

$35.44

2020 Topps Chrome Black - Chrome Black Autographs #CBA-GS

Gary Sheffield

$40.79

2020 Topps Museum Collection - Signature Swatch Dual Relics #SSDA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/299

$40.79

2012 Topps - Golden Moments Autographs #GMA-GS

Gary Sheffield

2 from

$22.68

2013 Topps Supreme - Supreme Stylings Autographs #SS-GS

Gary Sheffield #/50

2 from

$25.96

2020 Topps Museum Collection - Signature Swatch Dual Relics - Copper #SSDA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/50

$40.50

2021 Topps Tier One - Prime Performers Autographs #PPA-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/300

$29.15

2021 Topps Tier One - Tier One Talent Autographs - Bronze Ink #T1TA-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/25

$29.00

2021 Topps Tier One - Tier One Talent Autographs - Bronze Ink #T1TA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

$29.00

2021 Topps Tier One - Tier One Talent Autographs - Silver Ink #T1TA-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/10

$35.85

2024 Leaf Press Pass Premium - Trophy Case Autographs - Silver Prism #TC-GS1

Gary Sheffield #/15

$35.04

2014 Topps - Upper Class - Autographs #UCA-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/50

$35.04

2012 Topps Tier One - Top Shelf Autographed Relics - Dual #TSDAR-GS.1

Gary Sheffield #/25

$35.04

2005 Donruss Signature Series - Signature Stars - Bat #SS-7

Gary Sheffield

$35.04

2003 Upper Deck Sweet Spot - Sweet Spot Signatures #GS-AU

Gary Sheffield

$46.54

2021 Topps Tier One - Tier One Talent Autographs #T1TA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/300

$40.50

2025 Leaf Seasons in the Sun - Signature Seasons - Holo Pink #SSE-GS1

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated] #/8

$34.75

2025 Leaf Seasons in the Sun - Signature Seasons - Holo Pattern Dots #SSE-GS1

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated] #/7

$34.75

2024 Topps Allen & Ginter - Mini Baseball Autographs #MA-GS

Gary Sheffield

3 from

$23.71

1993 O-Pee-Chee Premier - Star Performers #6

Gary Sheffield [BAS Seal of Authenticity]

$28.05

2013 Topps Supreme - Retired and Active Autographs - Orange #SA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/15

$34.18

2013 Topps Replacement Autographs - [Base] - Red #_GASH

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated] #/99

$32.45

Attributes

Players

Teams

Item Conditions

Sellers

Sold Out

Listing Format

Browse