By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
Gary Sheffield Serial Numbered Baseball Cards
Sort By
Listings
Listings 1 - 100 of 1,229
1993 Donruss - The Elite Series #28

Gary Sheffield #/10,000

3 from
$23.20
2025 Leaf A Bronx Legacy - Penstripes - Green Spectrum Holofoil #P-GS1

Gary Sheffield #/5

$58.03
2025 Topps Tier One - Autographed Tier One Relics - Blue Dual #AT1R-GS

Gary Sheffield #/99

$50.84
2023 Panini Chronicles - Revolution - Cosmic #62

Gary Sheffield #/99

$12.04
2024 Panini Boys of Summer - Fabric of the Game Signatures - Leather #44

Gary Sheffield #/25

2 from
$28.99
2024 Panini Impeccable - Impeccable Lumber Signatures - Holo Gold #ILS-GS

Gary Sheffield #/10

$28.99
2025 Topps Diamond Icons - Autographs #AC-GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

3d left (1) $9.99
2024 Leaf Vivid - [Base] - Green Crystals #23

Gary Sheffield #/4

$12.04
2022 Topps Pristine - [Base] - Orange Pristine Pulsar Refractor #72

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated] #/25

$11.75
2000 Pacific Prism - [Base] - Holographic Purple #76

Gary Sheffield #/99

$9.74
2002 Upper Deck Diamond Connection - Bat Around - Gold #BA-SAKS

Gary Sheffield, Bobby Abreu, Ryan Klesko, Sammy Sosa #/50

2 from
$26.69
2025 Topps Dynamic Duals - Online Exclusive [Base] - Purple #36

Gary Sheffield, Dwight Gooden #/99

$9.72
2025 Panini Crusade - [Base] - Red #135

Gary Sheffield #/299

$3.99
1997 Donruss - Power Alley #17

Green - Gary Sheffield #/3,750

4 from
$2.26
1998 Topps Stars - [Base] - Bronze #5

Gary Sheffield #/9,799

9 from
$1.00
2003 Donruss Diamond Kings - [Base] - Gold Foil #83

Gary Sheffield #/100

3 from
$6.00
2001 Fleer Focus - [Base] - Batting Avg./ERA #173

Gary Sheffield #/325

3 from
$2.55
2025 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Premium Box Set Prizm #128

Gary Sheffield #/199

11 from
$3.70
2003 Fleer Rookies & Greats - [Base] - Blue #2

Gary Sheffield #/250

6 from
$2.78
2024 Leaf Press Pass Premium - Retro - Red Prismatic Reflector #RB-35

Gary Sheffield #/10

$7.44
2025 Leaf Seasons in the Sun - Signature Seasons - Holo Pattern Dots #SSE-GS1

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated] #/7

$34.75
2025 Leaf Seasons in the Sun - Signature Seasons - Holo Platinum #SSE-GS1

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated] #/5

$46.25
2025 Leaf Seasons in the Sun - Signature Seasons - Holo Pink #SSE-GS1

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated] #/8

$34.75
2023 Leaf Metal - Autographs - Printing Plate Yellow #BA-GS1

Gary Sheffield #/1

$114.39
2003 Topps - [Base] - Gold #130

Gary Sheffield #/2,003

2 from
$4.57
2001 Fleer Triple Crown - [Base] - Home Runs Blue #26

Gary Sheffield #/43

$69.24
2021 Topps Archives Signature Series - Retired Player Edition Buybacks #16TA-158

Gary Sheffield (2016 Topps Archives) [Buyback] #/42

$57.75
2024 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Red Pulsar Prizm #205

Gary Sheffield #/399

2 from
$1.45
1994 Sportflics 2000 All-Star FanFest - [Base] #AS8

Gary Sheffield, Kirby Puckett #/10,000

2 from
$6.23
2004 Donruss Throwback Threads - Player Threads #PT-24

Gary Sheffield #/250

$35.04
2005 Donruss Studio - Heritage - Bats #SH-8

Gary Sheffield #/150

3 from
$3.98
2002 Topps Pristine - Fall Memories #FM-GS

Gary Sheffield #/1,600

8 from
$2.78
2005 Donruss Studio - Portraits Diamond Kings - Blue #SP-11

Gary Sheffield #/50

$7.44
2000 Pacific Prism - [Base] - Holographic Gold #76

Gary Sheffield #/480

2 from
$3.13
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones - [Base] - Blue #52-276

Gary Sheffield (2007 - 450 Career Home Runs (480 Total)) #/10

$21.59
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones - [Base] - Blue #52-275

Gary Sheffield (2007 - 450 Career Home Runs (480 Total)) #/10

$21.59
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones - [Base] #52-425

Gary Sheffield (2007 - 450 Career Home Runs (480 Total)) #/150

3 from
$1.40
1998 Donruss Preferred - Great X-Pectations #16

Gary Sheffield, Richard Hidalgo #/2,700

3 from
$4.28
2004 Fleer Genuine Insider - [Base] - Genuine Reflection #60

Gary Sheffield #/99

3 from
$7.14
1999 Flair Showcase - [Base] - Row 1 #69

Gary Sheffield #/3,000

6 from
$3.30
2022 Topps Pristine - [Base] - Blue Pristine Pulsar Refractor #72

Gary Sheffield [Uncirculated] #/75

$7.15
2024 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Blue Prizm #205

Gary Sheffield #/199

3 from
$1.96
2007 Topps Co-Signers - [Base] - Silver Red #60.2

Gary Sheffield, Magglio Ordonez #/199

2 from
$4.57
2024 Panini National Treasures - Material Treasures - Holo Silver #MT-GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

$20.67
2025 Topps Tier One - Tier One Legend Relics #T1LR-GS

Gary Sheffield #/99

$14.34
1997 Donruss Limited - Fabric of the Game #67

Gary Sheffield #/750

2 from
$6.29
1998 Flair Showcase - Row 0 #68

Gary Sheffield #/1,000

$23.54
2006 Topps - [Base] - Black #420

Gary Sheffield #/55

$28.99
2005 Donruss Elite - Face 2 Face - Gold #FF-13

Pedro Martinez, Gary Sheffield #/150

3 from
$3.42
2004 Topps - [Base] - Gold #370

Gary Sheffield #/2,004

4 from
$3.00
2002 Topps Traded - [Base] - Gold #T100

Gary Sheffield #/2,002

$5.99
1997 Donruss - Rocket Launchers #10

Gary Sheffield #/5,000

3 from
$2.54
2002 Fleer Genuine - Touch 'Em All Game Used Base #_GASH

Gary Sheffield #/350

$9.45
2025 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Red Power Prizm #128

Gary Sheffield #/99

$11.74
2001 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection - Ultimate Signatures #GS

Gary Sheffield #/150

2 from
$27.31
2025 Topps Tier One - Tier One Relics - Blue Dual #T1R-GS

Gary Sheffield #/99

$9.74
2007 Topps Co-Signers - [Base] - Bronze #60.2

Gary Sheffield, Magglio Ordonez #/275

$2.26
1997 SPx - Bound for Glory #10

Gary Sheffield [EX to NM] #/1,500

$4.85
2002 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection - [Base] #8

Gary Sheffield #/799

$5.99
2004 Leaf Limited - [Base] - Monikers Bronze Signatures #37

Gary Sheffield #/50

$23.24
2025 Panini Impeccable - [Base] - Holo Gold #61

Gary Sheffield #/10

$8.82
2024 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Orange Pulsar Prizm #205

Gary Sheffield #/399

2 from
$3.30
2025 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Blue Prizm #128

Gary Sheffield #/199

$2.27
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones - [Base] #52-152

Gary Sheffield (2007 - 450 Career Home Runs (480 Total)) #/150

$4.80
2025 Topps Tier One - Prime Performers Autographs #PPA-GS

Gary Sheffield #/199

$23.54
2006 Topps - [Base] - Gold #420

Gary Sheffield #/2,006

2 from
$11.73
2004 Donruss Elite Extra Edition - [Base] - Aspirations Die-Cut #44

Gary Sheffield #/89

$7.44
2023 Panini National Treasures - Definitive Ink - Holo Silver #DI-GS

Gary Sheffield #/10

$148.60
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones - [Base] - Black #52-116

Gary Sheffield (2007 - 450 Career Home Runs (480 Total)) #/25

$14.34
2024 Topps Brooklyn Collection - Autographs #AC-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/99

2 from
$20.94
2024 Leaf Press Pass Premium - Retro Autographs #RA-GS1

Gary Sheffield #/49

$29.29
2017 Topps High Tek - [Base] - Pattern 1 Green Rainbow #HT-GS

Gary Sheffield #/99

$3.97
2015 Panini National Treasures - Game Ball Signatures #42

Gary Sheffield #/20

$158.78
2025 Topps Tier One - Tier One Legend Relics - Holo Silver Dual #T1LR-GS

Gary Sheffield #/25

$58.04
2024 Leaf Vivid - [Base] - White Prismatic #23

Gary Sheffield #/6

$12.04
2024 Leaf Vivid - [Base] - White Lava #23

Gary Sheffield #/6

$12.04
2006 Topps Heritage - Chrome #4

Gary Sheffield #/1,957

6 from
$2.27
2004 SP Authentic - [Base] #164

All-Star Moments - Gary Sheffield #/999

4 from
$1.80
2004 Leaf Certified Cuts - [Base] - Marble Gold #208

Gary Sheffield #/25

$23.53
2025 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Purple Prizm #128

Gary Sheffield #/149

2 from
$1.54
2025 Panini Prizm - [Base] - Pulsar Prizm #128

Gary Sheffield #/499

$3.99
2024 Leaf Electrum - [Base] #28

Gary Sheffield #/99

$12.04
1992-98 ProMint 22K Gold - [Base] #36

Gary Sheffield #/50,000

$7.44
2003 Upper Deck Classic Portraits - [Base] - Gold #54

Gary Sheffield #/25

$23.24
2022 Topps Chrome Platinum Anniversary - [Base] - Platinum Toile Cream & Gold Refractor #425

Gary Sheffield #/50

$12.90
2008 Topps Moments & Milestones - [Base] #52-40

Gary Sheffield (2007 - 450 Career Home Runs (480 Total)) #/150

$6.29
2008 Upper Deck Spectrum - Dual Swatches #SDS-SC

Gary Sheffield, Miguel Cabrera #/99

$23.25
2007 Topps Co-Signers - [Base] - Silver Red #60.3

Gary Sheffield, Ivan Rodriguez #/199

$6.29
2013 Topps Tribute - Famous Four-Baggers Relics #FB-GSH

Gary Sheffield #/99

$18.94
2003 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection - Jersey #J-GS

Gary Sheffield #/99

$9.74
1997 Leaf - Warning Track #10

Gary Sheffield #/3,500

2 from
$7.14
2025 Panini Donruss - Bomb Squad - Holo #10

Gary Sheffield #/199

$6.29
2024 Panini Three and Two - Going Yard #3

Gary Sheffield #/99

$4.28
1998 Leaf Fractal Foundation - [Base] #21

Gary Sheffield [EX to NM] #/3,999

$2.84
2004 Donruss Elite - Elite Series #ES-3

Gary Sheffield #/1,500

3 from
$4.42
2007 Topps '52 - Debut Flashbacks - Chrome Refractor #DFC5

Gary Sheffield #/552

2 from
$18.48
2007 Topps Turkey Red - [Base] - Chrome Refractor #100

Gary Sheffield #/999

6 from
$4.57
2005 Upper Deck Trilogy - Generations Present - Gold Lumber #PR-GS

Gary Sheffield #/75

2 from
$7.21
2023 Panini Donruss - [Base] - Holo Red #97

Gary Sheffield #/2,023

7 from
$0.98
2010 Topps Tribute - Relic Autographs - Black #TAR-GS4

Gary Sheffield #/50

$57.74
<< 1 2 3 4 5 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 13