By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
Christy Mathewson Hall of Fame All Baseball Cards
Sort By
Listings
Listings 1 - 100 of 581
1912 Hassan Triple Folders - T202 #_JMCM

John Meyers, Christy Mathewson (Just Before the Battle) [SGC 2.5 GOOD…

$1,020.00
1961 Golden Press Hall of Fame - [Base] #24

Christy Mathewson [PSA 9 MINT]

$141.99
2009 Topps - Legends of the Game Encased Stamps #CM1

Christy Mathewson [PSA 8 NM‑MT] #/95

$120.00
1999 Upper Deck Century Legends - [Base] - Century #7

Christy Mathewson [SGC 92 NM/MT+ 8.5] #/100

$115.24
2019 Topps - [Base] #574.2

SSP - Legend Variation - Christy Mathewson [SGC 10 GEM]

$114.10
1961 Topps - [Base] #408

Baseball Thrills - Mathewson Strikes Out 267 Batters [PSA 8 NM‑…

$89.95
1963 Topps Bazooka - All-Time Greats #4

Christy Mathewson

$43.94
1961 Topps - [Base] #408

Baseball Thrills - Mathewson Strikes Out 267 Batters [PSA 7 NM]

$63.50
1961 Golden Press Hall of Fame - [Base] #24

Christy Mathewson [PSA 7 NM]

$63.50
2024 Topps Gilded Collection - [Base] - Gold Wave Refractor #56

Christy Mathewson #/75

$57.74
1999 Monty Sheldon Hand-Painted Baseball Art Promos Series 2 - [Base] #S-2 2

Christy Mathewson

$56.89
1968 Sports Memorabilia All Time Baseball Team - [Base] #5

Christy Mathewson

2 from
$45.39
1961 Golden Press Hall of Fame - [Base] #24

Christy Mathewson

5 from
$12.95
2002 Topps 206 - [Base] - Mini Blue Sweet Caporal Back #451

Christy Mathewson

$31.59
2022 Topps Brooklyn Collection - [Base] - Orange #3

Christy Mathewson #/25

$52.00
2023 Topps Gilded Collection - [Base] - Gold Wave Etch #43

Christy Mathewson #/75

$49.57
1961 Topps - [Base] #408

Baseball Thrills - Mathewson Strikes Out 267 Batters [SGC 60 EX …

$44.36
1961 Fleer Baseball Greats - [Base] #59

Christy Mathewson [BGS 5 EXCELLENT]

$47.40
1960 Fleer Baseball Greats - [Base] #2

Christy Mathewson [BGS 5 EXCELLENT]

$47.40
2020 The Bar Pieces of the Past Sports Edition - 1/1 Pieces Relics #_CHMA

Christy Mathewson (Name Misspelled as Matthewson on Back) [Uncirculated] #/1

2 from
$47.35
1985-97 Perez-Steele Great Moments - [Base] #6

Christy Mathewson #/5,000

$46.25
2023 Historic Autographs 1918: End of the Great War - Replica Dog Tag #_CHMA

Christy Mathewson #/249

$46.25
2002 Topps 206 - [Base] - Mini Black Sweet Caporal Back #451

Christy Mathewson

$46.25
2014 Panini Hall of Fame - Blue Shield - Green #3

Christy Mathewson #/10

$18.83
1989 St. Vincent U.S. Baseball Series 2 Stamps - Sheets #ORAN

Orange - Casey Stengel, Jim Rice, Reggie Jackson, Jerome Walton, Bob Knepper, A…

$16.34
2007 Upper Deck Premier - Premier Stitchings - Gold #PS-34

Christy Mathewson #/10

$35.04
2009 Topps Updates & Highlights - Legends of the Game Letter Patches #LGTLP-CM.N

Christy Mathewson (Letter N) #/50

$33.88
2015 Leaf Sportkings - [Base] - Mini Green #047

Christy Mathewson #/15

$33.32
1950-56 Callahan Hall of Fame - [Base] #_CHMA

Christy Mathewson [Poor to Fair]

$32.73
2019 PSA National Convention Fantasy Promos - [Base] #4

Christy Mathewson [Uncirculated] #/1,000

$30.15
1961 Topps - [Base] #408

Baseball Thrills - Mathewson Strikes Out 267 Batters [SGC 5 EX]

$30.14
1980 An Exhibit Card Hall of Fame Reprints - [Base] - Red #_CHMA

Christy Mathewson

$29.52
1993 Upper Deck B.A.T. Triple-Folders - Non-Numbered Inserts #_ADCM

Christy Mathewson, Art Devlin

$29.52
2019 Topps Transcendent - [Base] #11

Christy Mathewson #/100

2 from
$13.36
2019 Topps Update Series - 150th Anniversary Manufactured Medallion - Red #AMM-CM

Christy Mathewson #/25

$29.29
1973 TCMA 1913 Tom Barker Baseball Card Game Reprint - [Base] #_CHMA

Christy Mathewson

$29.29
1950-56 Callahan Hall of Fame - [Base] #_CHMA

Christy Mathewson [Good to VG‑EX]

$29.29
1961 Nu-Cards Baseball Scoops - [Base] #477

Christy Mathewson [PSA 7 NM]

$29.00
1974 Exhibits Baseball's Great Hall of Fame - [Base] - Black Ink #_CHMA

Christy Mathewson

$24.40
1950-56 Callahan Hall of Fame - [Base] #_CHMA

Christy Mathewson

7 from
$13.18
2003 SP Legendary Cuts - [Base] #25

Christy Mathewson #/1,299

$7.15
1996-98 Gold Performance 22k - [Base] - Gold #_FHOF

The First Five Hall of Famers (Babe Ruth, Walter Johnson, Christy Mathewson, Ty…

11 from
$4.84
2014 Panini Hall of Fame - Red Shield - Green #3

Christy Mathewson #/10

$28.99
1996 Bally The Grand 1936 Inaugural Election 60th Anniversary $5 Chips - [Base] #_CHMA

Christy Mathewson

$20.26
1980 An Exhibit Card Hall of Fame Reprints - [Base] - Cyan White Back #_CHMA

Christy Mathewson

2 from
$12.26
2024 Topps Update Series - Autumn Tales - Gold #AT-27

Christy Mathewson #/75

$26.99
2006 Upper Deck - First Class Legends - Silver Spectrum #FCL-63

Christy Mathewson [EX to NM] #/99

$25.84
2006 Upper Deck - First Class Legends - Silver Spectrum #FCL-63

Christy Mathewson #/99

$25.84
2006 Upper Deck - First Class Legends - Silver Spectrum #FCL-61

Christy Mathewson #/99

$25.55
2014 Panini Hall of Fame - Crusades - Purple #3

Christy Mathewson #/50

$25.55
1986 The Sporting News Conlon Collection Baseball Immortals Series 1 - [Base] #23

Christy Mathewson #/12,000

2 from
$16.34
2024 Topps Series 1 - Grand Gamers #GOG-23

Christy Mathewson [CGC 9.5 Mint+]

$24.39
2009 Topps - Turkey Red #TR30

Christy Mathewson [SGC 10 GEM]

$24.39
2019 Topps Archives - [Base] - Subset Variations #165

1975 Design Signature Omission - Christy Mathewson

$23.54
1988 CCC 1909-11 T206 Reprints - [Base] #_CHMA.3

Christy Mathewson (Portrait)

$23.54
2009 Topps - [Base] #195.2

SP Legend Variation - Christy Mathewson [EX to NM]

$23.54
2009 Topps Updates & Highlights - [Base] #UH186.2

SP Legend Variation - Christy Mathewson

6 from
$18.18
1972 TCMA 1909 Philadelphia Caramel E95 Reprints - [Base] #12

Christy Mathewson

3 from
$22.39
2010 Topps - [Base] #80.2

SP - Legend Variation - Christy Mathewson

6 from
$10.58
1944-52 National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum Postcards - [Base] - Albertype #_CHMA

Inducted 1936 - Christy Mathewson [Poor to Fair]

$22.12
2023 Topps Pristine - [Base] - Orange Refractor #23

Christy Mathewson #/25

$22.39
2025 Panini Impeccable - [Base] #91

Christy Mathewson #/99

$12.96
2001 Topps Chrome - Before There was Topps - Refractor #BT8

Christy Mathewson

$20.95
2024 Topps 206 - [Base] - Polar Bear Back #_CHMA

Christy Mathewson

$20.55
2002 Topps 206 - [Base] - Mini Black Polar Bear Back #451

Christy Mathewson

$14.05
1961 Nu-Cards Baseball Scoops - [Base] #477

Christy Mathewson

$9.74
1999 Fleer Sports Illustrated Greats of the Game - Record Breakers - Gold #4 RB

Christy Mathewson

2 from
$11.75
2022 Topps Brooklyn Collection - [Base] - Purple #3

Christy Mathewson #/15

$20.09
2009 Topps Updates & Highlights - [Base] #UH186.2

SP Legend Variation - Christy Mathewson [EX to NM]

$20.09
2019 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] - Members Only #29

Christy Mathewson

2 from
$17.79
2014 Panini Hall of Fame - Green Shield #3

Christy Mathewson #/75

$19.80
1982 Davco Hall of Fame Baseball Stars - [Base] #_CHMA

Christy Mathewson [Noted]

$18.65
1974 Exhibits Baseball's Great Hall of Fame - [Base] - Black Ink #_CHMA

Christy Mathewson [Poor to Fair]

$18.65
2014 Panini Golden Age - Box Topper Darby Chocolate 3-Card Panel #16-18

Lefty Grove, Cy Young, Christy Mathewson [Good to VG‑EX]

$18.65
1980 Perez-Steele Hall of Fame Art Postcards - First Series #3

Christy Mathewson #/10,000

$18.65
2003 eTopps Classic - [Base] #ETC34

Christy Mathewson [Uncirculated] #/868

$18.60
1995-2010 Danbury Mint 22K Gold - [Base] #94

Christy Mathewson [Uncirculated]

3 from
$10.60
2024 Topps Triple Threads - [Base] - Citrine #181

Christy Mathewson #/75

$17.79
2022 Topps Brooklyn Collection - [Base] - Blue #3

Christy Mathewson #/40

$17.79
1975 TCMA All-Time New York Giants - [Base] #_CHMA.2

Christy Mathewson (Black Text)

$17.79
1988 CCC 1909-11 T206 Reprints - [Base] #_CHMA.1

Christy Mathewson (Glove at Chest, NY on Sleeve)

2 from
$17.79
1983 Renata Galasso 1909-11 T206 Reprints - [Base] #_CHMA.2

Christy Mathewson (Pitching)

$17.79
1977 Shakey's All-Time Superstars - [Base] #6

Christy Mathewson

4 from
$17.79
2010 Topps Tribute - [Base] - Gold #15

Christy Mathewson #/50

$17.79
1976 Shakey's Baseball's Hall of Fame - [Base] #4

Christy Mathewson

$17.79
1960 Fleer Baseball Greats - [Base] #2

Christy Mathewson [Noted]

2 from
$17.78
1981-89 Metallic Hall of Fame Plaques - [Base] #_CHMA

1981 - Christy Mathewson

2 from
$16.35
2019 Historic Autographs Federal League - One-of-Ones - Thought Bubbles #CM-FL

Christy Mathewson #/1

$17.50
2009 Topps - [Base] #195.2

SP Legend Variation - Christy Mathewson

3 from
$14.95
1961 Golden Press Hall of Fame - [Base] #24

Christy Mathewson [Good to VG‑EX]

2 from
$14.56
1961 Topps - [Base] #408

Baseball Thrills - Mathewson Strikes Out 267 Batters [Good to VG̴…

$11.12
2011 Topps - Before There was Topps #BTT2

Christy Mathewson [CSG 9 Mint]

$17.49
1973 National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum Photo Pack - [Base] #_CHMA

Christy Mathewson

$12.67
1972 Laughlin Great Feats - [Base] - Orange Border #25

Christy Mathewson

2 from
$16.07
2019 Topps - Greatest Moments - Red #GM-2

Christy Mathewson #/10

$16.78
2024 Topps Update Series - Autumn Tales - Blue #AT-27

Christy Mathewson

2 from
$14.34
1978 Dover Great Baseball Players of the Past Postcards - [Base] #_CHMA

Christy Mathewson

$12.67
1977 Nostalgia Press T206 Reprints - [Base] #_CHMA

Christy Mathewson

$15.48
1961 Topps - [Base] #408

Baseball Thrills - Mathewson Strikes Out 267 Batters

8 from
$14.04
1992 The Sporting News Conlon Collection - Prototype #331

Christy Mathewson

4 from
$7.14
<< 1 2 3 4 5 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 6