By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
Pre-Rookie Card Wrestling Cards
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Sold Out
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Wrestling (2,573)
2020's (221)
2010's (592)
2000's (579)
1990's (828)
1980's (325)
1970's (21)
1960's (1)
1950's (5)
1900's (1)
Listings 1 - 100 of 2,573
2023 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Gold #91

Crew - Mark Sterling

143 from
$0.55
2023 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Gold #97

All in the Family - Arn Anderson, Brock Anderson

151 from
$0.55
2021 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Gold #63

Tag Teams - Dax Harwood, Cash Wheeler

450 from
$0.57
2021 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Rainbow Foil #76

Crew - Paul Turner

314 from
$0.57
2021 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Rainbow Foil #63

Tag Teams - Dax Harwood, Cash Wheeler

263 from
$0.57
2022 Upper Deck Allure AEW - My Squad #MC-7

Top Flight

55 from
$0.57
2023 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - UD Canvas #C99

Big Bill

23 from
$0.57
2024 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Silver Foil #95

Announcers - "Smart" Mark Sterling

29 from
$0.57
2021 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Gold #76

Crew - Paul Turner

400 from
$0.57
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - Skybox Premium #PP-50

Alex Abrahantes

121 from
$0.57
2023 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Pyro #97

All in the Family - Arn Anderson, Brock Anderson

24 from
$0.57
2024 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Pyro #95

Announcers - "Smart" Mark Sterling

15 from
$0.57
2024 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Gold #95

Announcers - "Smart" Mark Sterling

20 from
$0.58
2023 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - Dazzlers - Blue #DZ-45

Juice Robinson

26 from
$0.58
2023 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Pyro #91

Crew - Mark Sterling

29 from
$0.58
2023 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - UD Canvas #C55

Juice Robinson

15 from
$0.58
2023 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Silver Foil #97

All in the Family - Arn Anderson, Brock Anderson

7 from
$0.59
2021 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - Canvas #C-23

Dax Harwood, Cash Wheeler

285 from
$0.60
2022 Upper Deck AEW Match Dated Moments - [Base] #22

All Out - (Sep. 4, 2022) - Stokely Hathaway Reveals His Long Term Plan as He Ha…

123 from
$0.60
2023 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Rampage #97

All in the Family - Arn Anderson, Brock Anderson

6 from
$0.63
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - Skybox Premium #PP-49

Mark Sterling

57 from
$0.63
2023 Upper Deck AEW New Arrivals - [Base] #10

(Oct. 1, 2023) - Adam Copeland

37 from
$0.66
2023 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - UD Canvas #C31

Action Andretti

14 from
$0.66
2019 Topps WWE NXT - [Base] #81

Aleister Black & Ricochet Def. Marcel Barthel & Fabian Aichner

3 from
$0.68
2017 Topps WWE Then Now Forever - Finishers and Signature Moves #F-47

The Revival

9 from
$0.68
2016 Topps WWE Then Now Forever - NXT Prospects #14

Shinsuke Nakamura

15 from
$0.70
2023 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - AEW Alliances Acetate #AL-18

Lee Moriarty, Big Bill

8 from
$0.70
2021 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Pyro #63

Tag Teams - Dax Harwood, Cash Wheeler

67 from
$0.70
2020 Topps Finest WWE - Finest Tag Teams #TT-16

Zack Gibson, James Drake

7 from
$0.70
2016 Topps WWE - NXT Prospects #10

Carmella

9 from
$0.70
1999 Topps WCW/nWo Nitro - Stickers #S11

60-Man, 3-Ring Battle Royal (World War 3)

7 from
$0.71
2023 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Rampage #91

Crew - Mark Sterling

6 from
$0.71
1987 Topps WWF - [Base] #30

The Islanders, Demolition [Good to VG‑EX]

2 from
$0.71
2021 Topps Heritage WWE - Allen & Ginter #AG-23

Sycho Sid

36 from
$0.74
2023 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Speckled Foil #91

Crew - Mark Sterling

8 from
$0.74
2008 TRISTAR TNA Wrestling Impact! - Thoughts by... "Big Sexy" Kevin Nash #BS-2

Samoa Joe

10 from
$0.75
1996-98 WWF Magazine Cards - [Base] #24

1-2-3 Kid, Sid [Poor to Fair]

7 from
$0.75
2016 Topps WWE - NXT Prospects #19

Jason Jordan [EX to NM]

$0.76
2010 Topps WWE Slam Attax Mayhem - [Base] #_JURO

Justin Roberts

4 from
$0.76
2014 Topps WWE Road to Wrestlemania - [Base] #47

The Rhodes Brothers, The Shield

4 from
$0.76
2016 Topps WWE Then Now Forever - NXT Prospects #9

No Way Jose

11 from
$0.76
2010 Topps WWE Slam Attax Mayhem - [Base] #_IRS

IRS

5 from
$0.76
2016 Topps WWE Road to Wrestlemania - [Base] - Tag Team Championship Bronze #98

NXT - Samoa Joe

6 from
$0.77
2016 Topps WWE Then Now Forever - NXT Prospects #2

Austin Aries

12 from
$0.77
2016 Topps WWE Then Now Forever - NXT Prospects #11

Samoa Joe

12 from
$0.77
2014 Topps WWE Road to Wrestlemania - [Base] - Bronze #56

Xavier Woods [EX to NM]

$0.77
2019 Topps WWE NXT - [Base] - Bronze #92

Matt Riddle Def. Adam Cole

2 from
$0.77
2021 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Pyro #76

Crew - Paul Turner

118 from
$0.77
2003 Fleer WWE Aggression - [Base] #58

Jamie Noble [EX to NM]

$0.77
2023 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Speckled Foil #97

All in the Family - Arn Anderson, Brock Anderson

10 from
$0.78
1990 Classic WWF - [Base] #47

The Bushwhackers [Poor to Fair]

2 from
$0.80
2014 Topps WWE Road to Wrestlemania - [Base] #88

The Shield Defy Authority

7 from
$0.80
2016 Topps WWE Then Now Forever - NXT Rivalries #9

Austin Aries vs. Baron Corbin

8 from
$0.80
2020 Topps WWE Women's Division - Roster Cards #RC-2

Alicia Taylor

5 from
$0.80
2010 TRISTAR TNA Icons - [Base] #64

The Next Generation - Samoa Joe

2 from
$0.81
1999 Comic Images WWF SmackDown! - [Base] #52

Test

9 from
$0.81
1999 Comic Images WWF SmackDown! - [Base] #44

Big Show

13 from
$0.81
2003 Fleer WWE Aggression - [Base] #45

Bill DeMott

3 from
$0.81
2021 Topps WWE NXT - We Are NXT #NXT-18

Flash Morgan Webster

4 from
$0.82
1987 Topps WWF - [Base] #30

The Islanders, Demolition

22 from
$0.82
2017 Topps WWE Women's Division - Matches and Moments WWE #WWE-13

Team Raw

11 from
$0.82
1999 Topps WCW/nWo Nitro - [Base] #47

Dean Malenko

15 from
$0.82
2016 Topps WWE Road to Wrestlemania - [Base] #106

NXT - The Vaudevillains

2 from
$0.83
1999 Comic Images WWF SmackDown! Chromium - [Base] #63

Big Show Lays Out Half The Ministry On Raw

6 from
$0.83
2016 Topps WWE Then Now Forever - NXT Rivalries #8

Austin Aries vs. No Way Jose

7 from
$0.83
2015 Topps Heritage WWE - [Base] #102

NXT - Baron Corbin

5 from
$0.83
2021 Topps WWE Women's Division - Roster #R-26

Alicia Taylor

13 from
$0.83
1999 Topps WCW/nWo Nitro - [Base] #21

Billy Kidman

4 from
$0.83
1988 Wonderama NWA - [Base] #_CHEC.2

Checklist - Cards 51-100

4 from
$0.83
2014 Topps WWE Road to Wrestlemania - [Base] - Bronze #56

Xavier Woods

2 from
$0.83
1986 Monty Gum Super Wrestling Stars - [Base] #81

The Sheepherders [EX to NM]

$0.83
2012 TRISTAR TNA TENacious - [Base] #37

Bobby Roode

10 from
$0.83
2013 TRISTAR TNA Impact Wrestling Live - [Base] #6

Austin Aries

8 from
$0.83
2014 Topps WWE Road to Wrestlemania - [Base] - Bronze #72

Rusev

$0.83
2010 TRISTAR TNA The New Era - [Base] #37

Robert Roode

$0.83
2013 Topps Best of WWE - [Base] - Blue #90

Vickie Guerrero hires Brad Maddox as...

$0.83
2010 Aquarius TNA Playing Cards - [Base] #9S

Alex Shelley

$0.83
2010 Aquarius TNA Playing Cards - [Base] #KD

Alex Shelley, Jay Lethal

$0.83
2004 Tesla WWE CCG - SE #S.E. 46

Orlando Jordan

2 from
$0.83
2004 Tesla WWE CCG - SE #S.E. 14

Eugene

3 from
$0.83
2004 Tesla WWE CCG - [Base] #109

R - Airplane Spin - Eugene

2 from
$0.83
2004 Tesla WWE CCG - [Base] #246

M - Orlando Jordan

$0.83
2015 Topps Heritage WWE - [Base] #110

NXT - Tyler Breeze

11 from
$0.83
2014 Topps WWE Road to Wrestlemania - [Base] - Bronze #83

Lana

$0.83
1994 Action Packed WWF - [Base] #32

Adam Bomb

11 from
$0.83
1994 Action Packed WWF - [Base] #34

Earthquake

19 from
$0.83
2016 Topps Heritage WWE - [Base] #69

NXT - Samoa Joe

14 from
$0.83
2017 Topps WWE NXT - Matches and Moments #41

The Revival

6 from
$0.86
2011 TRISTAR TNA Signature Impact Wrestling - [Base] #89

Samoa Joe

4 from
$0.86
2010 Topps WWE Slam Attax Mayhem - [Base] #_TOCH

Tony Chimel [EX to NM]

$0.88
2009 Topps WWE Slam Attax - [Base] #_JOMA

Josh Mathews

$0.88
1991 Classic WWF Superstars - [Base] #85

General Adnan [EX to NM]

2 from
$0.88
2021 Topps Chrome WWE Slam Attax - [Base] #29

Flash Morgan Webster

3 from
$0.88
2016 Topps WWE Then Now Forever - NXT Prospects #6

Dash Wilder

8 from
$0.88
1991 Classic WWF Superstars - [Base] #149

Earthquake

11 from
$0.88
2010 Topps WWE Slam Attax Mayhem - [Base] #_TOCH

Tony Chimel

5 from
$0.88
1991 Championship Marketing WCW - [Base] #21

Beautiful Bobby Punishes Opponent

2 from
$0.88
2016 Topps WWE - NXT Prospects #20

Mojo Rawley [Good to VG‑EX]

$0.89
1999 Topps WCW/nWo Nitro - Stickers #S5

Nash v. Giant (Slamboree)

6 from
$0.89
2018 Topps Heritage WWE - Tag Teams and Stables #TT-8

Bludgeon Brothers

4 from
$0.89
<< 1 2 3 4 5 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 26