This website uses technologies such as cookies to provide you a better user experience. To learn more refer to our Privacy Policy .

Top
Pre-Rookie Card Wrestling Cards
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Sold Out
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Wrestling (2,608)
2020's (467)
2010's (569)
2000's (616)
1990's (697)
1980's (233)
1970's (21)
1960's (1)
1950's (4)
Listings 1 - 100 of 2,608
1974 Yamakatsu New Japan Pro Wrestling - [Base] #29

Andre the Giant [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$3,330.00
1974 Yamakatsu New Japan Pro Wrestling - [Base] #25

Andre the Giant [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$2,780.00
2015 Topps WWE Undisputed - NXT Prospects - Silver #NXT15

Bayley #/25

$1,130.28
1995 BBM Pro Wrestling - [Base] #34

Sabu [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$1,129.99
1999 Topps WCW Embossed - Authentic Signatures #_DATA

Dave Taylor

$799.99
1982 Big Wrester Magazine Stickers - [Base] #_BRHA

Bret Hart

$689.89
1974 Yamakatsu New Japan Pro Wrestling - [Base] #25

Andre the Giant [PSA 6 EX‑MT]

$635.00
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - Metal-X #MX-25

HOOK

$580.00
2022 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Autographs #60

Jamie Hayter [PSA 9 MINT]

$577.80
1974 Yamakatsu New Japan Pro Wrestling - [Base] #29

Andre the Giant [PSA 6 EX‑MT]

$525.00
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Printing Plate Magenta #11

Julia Hart #/1

$470.28
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - Jambalaya #13 OF 20

Tay Melo

$470.27
1974 Yamakatsu New Japan Pro Wrestling - [Base] #25

Andre the Giant [PSA 5 EX]

2 from
$394.99
1978 Amada Kings of the Squared Ring - Mini #_AGAI.3

Andre the Giant, Antonio Inoki [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$341.10
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Silver Autographs #98

HOOK

$340.27
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - Intimidation Nation - Autographs #IN-15

Jamie Hayter #/25

$340.27
2015 Topps WWE Undisputed - NXT in Line Autographs #NA-BL

Becky Lynch

$323.78
2008 TRISTAR TNA Wrestling Cross the Line - Autographs Quad - Red #C4-5

James Storm, Robert Roode, Homicide, Hernandez #/25

$340.00
2021 Topps WWE Women's Division - Roster Autographs - Purple #A-CJ

Cora Jade #/99

$339.99
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Silver Autographs #11

Julia Hart

2 from
$282.53
2022 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - Main Features - Gold Spectrum #MF-15

Ruby Soho [CGC 9.5 Mint+] #/1

$286.10
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - Metal-X #MX-21

Anna Jay

$285.28
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Green Autographs #95

Wheeler Yuta #/10

$285.27
2022 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - 2020 Buyback Autos - Canvas #C-22

Anna Jay #/15

$285.00
2022 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Pyro Autographs #60

Jamie Hayter #/25

$284.99
2022 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Exclusives #80

Hook [CGC 10 Gem Mint] #/100

$284.99
1995 BBM Pro Wrestling - [Base] - 1997 2nd Printing #34

Sabu [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$283.90
2002 Fleer WWE Royal Rumble - [Base] #14

Randy Orton [PSA 9 MINT]

$283.90
2014 Topps WWE - NXT Prospects #17

Sasha Banks [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$283.90
1981 Takara Wrestling Game - [Base] #ATG8.1

8 White - Andre the Giant [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$283.35
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - Skybox Premium - Star Emeralds Autographs #PP-41

Brody King #/10

$257.78
2014 Topps Chrome WWE - NXT Prospects #16

Sami Zayn [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$231.10
2022 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Red Mat Relics #60

Jamie Hayter #/50

2 from
$175.27
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Silver Autographs #95

Wheeler Yuta

$230.27
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - 1997-98 Retro - Precious Metal Gems Red #R-19

Anna Jay #/90

2 from
$225.82
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Silver Autographs #83

Danhausen

2 from
$174.18
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - Skybox Premium - Star Rubies #PP-38

Swerve Strickland #/50

$230.00
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - 1997-98 Retro - Precious Metal Gems Red #R-41

Ruby Soho #/90

$230.00
2016 Topps WWE Undisputed - NXT Prospects - Gold #NXT-16

Elias Samson #/10

$229.99
2018 Ring of Honor All In - [Base] #18

MJF [SGC 7 NM]

$228.90
2018 Ring of Honor All In - [Base] #18

MJF [PSA 7 NM]

$228.90
2014 Topps WWE - NXT Prospects #16

Sami Zayn [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$228.90
1999 Comic Images WWF SmackDown! Chromium - [Base] #30

The Hardy Boyz With Michael Hayes [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$228.90
1996-98 WWF Magazine Cards - [Base] #19

Triple H [PSA 9 MINT]

$228.35
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - Skybox Premium - Star Sapphires #PP-38

Swerve Strickland

$208.28
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #120

The Rock, Rocky Maivia, Owen Hart [PSA 9 MINT]

2 from
$114.10
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Precious Metal Gems Red #83

Danhausen #/90

$202.50
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Precious Metal Gems Red #11

Julia Hart #/90

2 from
$202.45
2022 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Exclusives #60

Jamie Hayter #/100

$114.10
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Silver Autographs #90

Swerve Strickland

$175.28
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - 1997-98 Retro - Precious Metal Gems Red #R-47

Jamie Hayter #/90

$175.28
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Green Autographs #4

Dante Martin #/10

2 from
$86.79
2022 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - High Gloss #53

Dante Martin #/10

$175.00
2022 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Dynamite Autographs #53

Dante Martin #/5

$175.00
1981 Takara Wrestling Game - [Base] #ATG5.1

5 White - Andre the Giant [Good to VG‑EX]

$175.00
2016 Leaf Signature Series Wrestling - Team Effort #TE-19

Nick Jackson, Matt Jackson

$67.82
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Precious Metal Gems Red #92

Rush #/90

3 from
$46.54
2015 Topps WWE Undisputed - NXT in Line Autographs #NA-BM

Murphy [BGS 10 BLACK LABEL]

$174.99
1978 Amada Kings of the Square Ring Menko - [Base] #_ANGI.3

Andre the Giant [PSA 6 EX‑MT]

$174.95
1978 Amada Kings of the Square Ring Menko - [Base] #_ANGI.2

Andre the Giant [PSA 5 EX]

$174.95
2018 Ring of Honor All In - [Base] #28

Britt Baker [PSA 9 MINT]

$173.90
1997 Cardinal World Wrestling Federation Trivia Game - [Base] #_MANK

Mankind [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$173.90
1988 Wonderama NWA - [Base] #173

Ron Simmons [PSA 10 GEM MT]

$170.59
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - Metal-X #MX-26

Danhausen

2 from
$129.89
2013 Capcom King of Pro-Wrestling - [Base] #BT04-042 C

Kenny Omega [BAS BGS Authentic]

$167.29
2013 Capcom King of Pro-Wrestling - [Base] #BT04-042 C

Kenny Omega [BGS Authentic]

2 from
$167.29
1997 Cardinal World Wrestling Federation Trivia Game - [Base] #_ROMA

Rocky Maivia [PSA 8 NM‑MT]

$152.18
1981 Takara Wrestling Game - [Base] #ATG7.1

7 White - Andre the Giant [Good to VG‑EX]

$158.50
2022 Upper Deck AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Autographs #53

Dante Martin

$147.78
1981 Takara Wrestling Game - [Base] #ATG2.2

2 White - Andre the Giant [Good to VG‑EX]

$147.50
2014 Topps Chrome WWE - NXT Prospects #16

Sami Zayn [PSA 9 MINT]

$147.50
1995 BBM Pro Wrestling - [Base] #34

Sabu

$84.20
1997 Panini WWF Superstars Album Stickers - [Base] #122

Rocky Maivia, The Rock, Bret Hart [SGC 7 NM]

$49.70
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Precious Metal Gems Red #136

High Series - Jamie Hayter #/90

$142.77
2016 Leaf Signature Series Wrestling - [Base] - Green #52

Marlena #/5

$141.99
1978 Amada Kings of the Square Ring Menko - [Base] #_ANGI.1

Andre the Giant

$136.50
2016 Topps WWE Then Now Forever - Autographs #_SHNA

Shinsuke Nakamura [BGS 8.5 NM‑MT+] #/99

$135.40
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Precious Metal Gems Red #13

Anna Jay #/90

$121.10
2014 Topps WWE - NXT Prospects #4

Bayley [SGC 9 MINT]

$121.10
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Precious Metal Gems Green #60

Claudio Castagnoli #/10

$120.28
1994-2001 JusToys Bendables Figure Cards - [Base] #_STCO

Steve Austin

$120.00
1981 Takara Wrestling Game - [Base] #ATG2.1

2 Red - Andre the Giant [CSG 5.5 Excellent+]

$120.00
1981 Takara Wrestling Game - [Base] #ATG2.1

2 Red - Andre the Giant

$120.00
1955-56 Parkhurst Wrestling - [Base] #6

Bobo Brazil [Poor to Fair]

$120.00
2002 Fleer WWE Absolute Divas - Material Girls #_STKE.2

Stacy Keibler (Event-Worn Top)

$69.53
1988 Wonderama NWA - [Base] - Brown Back #30

Road Warriors [EX to NM]

$52.17
1996-98 WWF Magazine Cards - [Base] #122

The Sophomore Jinx? [Poor to Fair]

2 from
$38.49
1996-98 WWF Magazine Cards - [Base] #141

Rocky Maivia, The Rock [Noted]

$115.24
2016 Topps Heritage WWE - NXT University of Central Florida Mat Relics #_CA

Carmella #/199

$115.24
2015 Topps WWE Undisputed - NXT in Line Autographs #NA-SZ

Sami Zayn

$86.57
2001 Fleer WWF The Ultimate Divas Collection - Ring Accessories #LI

Lita

2 from
$80.74
2015 Topps WWE Undisputed - NXT Prospects - Red #NXT8

Carmella

2 from
$23.24
1978 Amada Kings of the Square Ring Menko - [Base] #_ANGI.2

Andre the Giant [PSA 4 VG‑EX]

$115.20
1981 Baseball Magazine Viva! Lucha Libre - [Base] #_MIMA

Mil Mascaras [Poor to Fair]

$115.14
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - [Base] - Precious Metal Gems Red #95

Wheeler Yuta #/90

$114.39
2022 Skybox Metal Universe AEW All Elite Wrestling - Palladium - Gold Spectrum #P-15

Ruby Soho #/25

$114.39
1978 Amada Kings of the Square Ring Menko - [Base] #_ANGI.3

Andre the Giant [Good to VG‑EX]

2 from
$86.45
1978 Amada Kings of the Square Ring Menko - [Base] #_AGAI

Andre the Giant, Antonio Inoki [CSG 1.5 Fair]

$114.10
1988 WWF Super Stars Playing Cards - [Base] #9D.1

Bam Bam Bigelow [SGC 9.5 Mint+]

$114.10
1988 WWF Super Stars Playing Cards - [Base] #9S.1

Bam Bam Bigelow [SGC 9 MINT]

$114.10
<< 1 2 3 4 5 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 27