Buy Now, Ship Later to save on shipping, consolidate your orders, and avoid peak holiday shipping times.

By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
Serial Numbered Hall of Fame Football Cards Ungraded
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Sold Out
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Football (482)
2020's (1)
2010's (114)
2000's (254)
1990's (113)
Listings 1 - 100 of 482
2018 Panini Playbook - Split 6 Signature Booklet - Printing Plate Magenta #S6S-2

Drew Pearson, Emmitt Smith, Michael Irvin, Roger Staubach, Tony Dorsett, Troy A…

$5,529.95
1999 Donruss Elite - Passing the Torch - Autographs #5.1

Emmitt Smith [Noted] #/1,500

$690.28
2007 Topps TX Exclusive - Pro Bowl Ticket Stubs Autographs #PB-PM

Peyton Manning [Noted] #/25

$778.08
2022 Panini Flawless Collegiate - Flawless Dual Signatures #DS-PITT

Dan Marino, Kenny Pickett [Noted] #/25

$505.31
2006 Upper Deck Exquisite Collection - Legendary Signatures #ELS-PH

Paul Hornung [Noted] #/25

$284.99
2012 Exquisite Collection - Dimensions Signatures #EB-JN

Joe Namath [Encased] #/60

$231.10
2016 Panini Clear Vision - C-Thru Signatures #3

Fran Tarkenton [Noted] #/40

$115.24
1997 Donruss Studio - [Base] - 8x10 Gold Portrait Proof Promos #8

John Elway [Noted] #/1,000

$103.75
1997 Donruss Studio - [Base] - 8x10 Gold Portrait Proof Promos #30

Brett Favre [Noted] #/1,000

$103.75
1997 Collector's Edge Excalibur - 22K Knights - Supreme Edge #02

John Elway [Noted] #/2,000

$102.89
2001 Press Pass - Jersey #JC/LT

LaDainian Tomlinson [Noted] #/400

$78.50
2002 Upper Deck - Autographed Buybacks #87

John Riggins (2001 Upper Deck NFL Legends) [Noted] #/52

$92.24
2013 Panini Totally Certified - Thanksgiving Day Signatures - Totally Red #96

Thanksgiving Day - Paul Hornung [Noted] #/25

$81.04
1998 NFL Hall of Fame Signature Series - [Base] - Autographs #_GEBL

George Blanda [Noted] #/2,500

$76.15
2002 Fleer Platinum - [Base] - Finish #19

Jerry Rice [Noted] #/100

$75.00
1995 Classic NFL Draft - 1st Round Picks - Printers Proof Missing Serial Number #12

Warren Sapp [Encased] #/97

$57.74
2007 Topps Co-Signers - [Base] - Blue Changing Faces Hyper Gold #38.2

John Elway, Trent Edwards [Noted] #/25

$57.74
2003 Fleer Platinum - Patch of Honor #PH-BF

Brett Favre [Noted] #/220

$56.89
2001 Playoff Honors - Game Day - Souvenirs Dual Football Prime Jersey #GD-31

Curtis Martin [Noted] #/25

$56.89
2008 SPx - Winning Trios - Numbered to 49 #WT33

Peyton Manning, Matt Schaub, Joe Flacco [Noted] #/49

$56.89
1997 Donruss Studio - Red Zone Masterpieces - 8x10 Promos #1

Troy Aikman [Noted] #/3,500

$56.60
1997 Donruss Studio - [Base] - 8x10 Gold Portrait Proof Promos #24

Steve Young [Noted] #/1,000

$56.60
1997 Donruss Studio - [Base] - 8x10 Gold Portrait Proof Promos #1

Troy Aikman [Noted] #/1,000

$56.60
1997 Donruss Studio - [Base] - 8x10 Gold Portrait Proof Promos #18

Jerry Rice [Noted] #/1,000

$56.60
1997 Donruss Studio - [Base] - 8x10 Gold Portrait Proof Promos #31

Dan Marino [Noted] #/1,000

$56.60
1997 Donruss Studio - [Base] - 8x10 Gold Portrait Proof Promos #36

Steve Young [Noted] #/1,000

$56.60
1997 Donruss Studio - Red Zone Masterpieces - 8x10 Promos #8

John Elway [Noted] #/3,500

$56.60
2013 Topps - Gridiron Legends Rings - Bronze #GLR-JK

Jim Kelly [Noted] #/75

$28.37
2013 Topps - Legendary Achievement Medals - Bronze #LAM-MA

Marcus Allen [Noted] #/75

$28.37
2014 Topps - Topps Defensive Club Commemorative Relics - Gold #TDC-DR

Darrelle Revis [Noted] #/25

$28.37
1998 NFL Hall of Fame Signature Series - [Base] - Autographs #_SOJU

Sonny Jurgensen [Noted] #/2,500

$53.15
2004 Fleer Showcase - Grace - Bronze Jersey #SG-BF

Brett Favre [Noted] #/100

$52.29
2008 Donruss Elite - Zoning Commission - Jerseys #ZC-2

Peyton Manning [Noted] #/299

$52.29
2002 SP Authentic - [Base] #222

Rookie Authentics - Julius Peppers [Noted] #/850

$52.29
2008 Prestige - Award Winners - Materials Prime #AW-8

Brett Favre [Noted] #/25

$26.42
2001 Pacific Private Stock - [Base] - Premiere Date #161

LaDainian Tomlinson [Noted] #/95

$46.68
2009 Certified - Fabric of the Game - Prime #131

Sonny Jurgensen [Noted] #/10

$46.20
2002 Upper Deck Graded - Game Jersey #G6-JR

Jerry Rice [Noted] #/50

$45.39
2016 Panini Immaculate Collection - [Base] #23

Joe Montana [Noted] #/99

$44.74
1998 NFL Hall of Fame Signature Series - [Base] - Autographs #_ACPA

Ace Parker [Noted] #/2,500

$39.65
2004 Playoff Absolute Memorabilia - Team Trios #TTR-1

Anquan Boldin, Emmitt Smith, Josh McCown [Noted] #/500

$41.65
1998 NFL Hall of Fame Signature Series - [Base] - Autographs #_ARWE

Arnie Weinmeister [Noted] #/2,500

$41.65
1998 NFL Hall of Fame Signature Series - [Base] - Autographs #_JIPA

Jim Parker [Noted] #/2,500

$41.65
2004 Flair - Gridiron Cuts - Red #GC-BF

Brett Favre [Noted] #/150

$40.79
2002 Playoff Prestige - League Leader Tandems - Jerseys #LL2

Brett Favre, Peyton Manning [Noted] #/250

$40.78
2000 Quantum Leaf - Shirt Off My Back #SB 12

Jerry Rice [Noted] #/100

$40.25
1997 Donruss Studio - [Base] - 8x10 Gold Portrait Proof Promos #14

Michael Irvin [Noted] #/1,000

$35.90
1998 NFL Hall of Fame Signature Series - [Base] - Autographs #_YATI

Y.A. Tittle [Noted] #/2,500

$35.90
1998 NFL Hall of Fame Signature Series - [Base] - Autographs #_MISI

Mike Singletary [Noted] #/2,500

$35.90
1998 NFL Hall of Fame Signature Series - [Base] - Autographs #_LERS

Lee Roy Selmon [Noted] #/2,500

$35.90
1998 NFL Hall of Fame Signature Series - [Base] - Autographs #_JOHA

John Hannah [Noted] #/2,500

$35.90
2004 Skybox L.E. - [Base] - Silver Jerseys #14

Peyton Manning [Noted] #/250

$35.04
2001 Playoff Absolute Memorabilia - Leather & Laces #LL33

Jerry Rice [Noted] #/550

$35.04
1994 Classic Pro Line Live - Autographs #_TIBR

Tim Brown [Noted] #/1,920

$34.75
2001 eTopps - Super Bowl Card Show Sweepstakes Entries #_RALE

Ray Lewis [Noted] #/2,000

$33.89
2002 Flair - Sweet Swatch Memorabilia - Patch #CMSS

Curtis Martin [Noted] #/150

$33.59
2008 Press Pass Legends - [Base] - Red #51

Ken Stabler [Noted] #/5

$21.44
1997 Donruss Studio - Red Zone Masterpieces - 8x10 Promos #20

Warren Moon [Noted] #/3,500

$30.15
1997 Donruss - Zoning Commission - Promos #19

Isaac Bruce [Noted] #/5,000

$29.29
2005 Leaf Limited - [Base] - Spotlight Gold #121

Jim Kelly [Noted] #/25

$29.29
2013 Score - [Base] - 2013 National #277

Franchise - Calvin Johnson Jr. [Noted] #/5

$29.29
1995 Signature Rookies Auto-Phonex - $2 Phone Cards - Autographs #26

Curtis Martin [Noted] #/3,750

3 from
$16.35
2004 Leaf Limited - Limited Threads - Die-Cut Positions #LT-48

Jim Kelly [Noted] #/50

$14.92
2004 Leaf Limited - Limited Threads - Die-Cut Positions #LT-35

Earl Campbell [Noted] #/50

$14.92
2005 Upper Deck Exquisite Collection - [Base] #28

Curtis Martin [Noted] #/150

$14.92
2004 Upper Deck Ultimate Collection - Ultimate Jerseys - Patch #UP-CC

Cris Carter [Noted] #/150

$14.92
1998 Pacific - Dynagon Turf - Titanium #12

Curtis Martin [Noted] #/99

$29.00
1995 Signature Rookies - [Base] - International Signatures #21

Terrell Davis [Noted] #/2,750

$25.84
2017 Panini Elite Draft Picks - [Base] - Aspirations Blue #53

John Elway [Noted] #/25

$13.04
2017 Panini Illusions - [Base] - Trophy Collection Red #52

Tyrod Taylor, Jim Kelly [Noted] #/50

$14.05
2002 Fleer Maximum - [Base] - To the Max #74

Brett Favre [Noted] #/250

$23.54
2008 Donruss Classics - Classic Singles - Jersey Number Jerseys Prime #CS-27

Raymond Berry [Noted] #/25

$23.54
2001 Playoff Absolute Memorabilia - Leather & Laces #LL17

Brian Urlacher [Noted] #/550

$23.54
2012 Panini Prominence - Black and Blue Materials #15

Ray Lewis [Noted] #/125

$13.19
2007 Leaf Limited - [Base] - Spotlight Silver #170

Otto Graham [Noted] #/20

$12.04
2007 UD Premier - Patches 3 - Gold #PP3-MH

Marvin Harrison [Noted] #/75

$12.04
2006 Playoff National Treasures - [Base] - Gold #66

John Mackey [Noted] #/25

$12.04
2018 Panini Majestic - Regal Runners - Gold #RR-TD

Terrell Davis [Noted] #/25

$23.24
2015 Panini Black Gold - Franchise Gold - White Gold Foil #FG-14

Marshall Faulk, Steven Jackson, Todd Gurley II [Noted] #/25

$23.24
2012 Panini Black - [Base] - Platinum #7

Ray Lewis [Noted] #/25

$23.24
2011 Panini Certified - [Base] - Mirror Red #298

Immortals - John Elway [Noted] #/100

$21.24
2015 Panini Playbook - [Base] - Gold #50

John Elway, Peyton Manning [Noted] #/199

$20.94
2007 Topps Co-Signers - [Base] - Blue Changing Faces Hyper Silver #32.1

Andre Johnson, Fred Biletnikoff [Noted] #/99

$18.94
1995 Signature Rookies - [Base] - Signatures #49

Curtis Martin [Noted] #/7,750

$18.94
2017 Panini Limited - Limited INK #LI-RJ

Rickey Jackson [Noted] #/49

$18.37
1997 Score Board Playbook - Standout Numbers - Magnified Silver #SN4

Brett Favre [Noted] #/2,700

$18.02
2004 Leaf Certified Materials - Gold Team - 24K #GT-3

Brian Urlacher [Noted] #/75

$17.79
2016 Panini Unparalleled - [Base] - Green #44

Jim Kelly [Noted] #/10

$17.79
2011 Panini Gold Standard - Golden Anniversary 1961 - Materials #2

Y.A. Tittle [Noted] #/50

$17.79
2013 Panini Totally Certified - Materials - Totally Gold Prime #47

Champ Bailey [Noted] #/25

$17.79
2012 Panini National Treasures - [Base] - Century Gold #198

Legends - Willie Davis [Noted] #/10

$17.79
2004 Fleer Platinum - [Base] - Jerseys #76.1

Ray Lewis [Noted] #/765

$17.79
2000 Pacific Paramount - [Base] - Platinum Blue #116

Tony Gonzalez [Noted] #/75

$17.79
1998 SP Authentic - [Base] - Die-Cut #34

Rookie Time Warp - Steve Young [Noted] #/500

$17.79
2002 Fleer Focus Jersey Edition - [Base] - Focus Jersey Numbers #81

Edgerrin James [Noted] #/32

$10.03
2001 SPx - Winning Materials - Bronze #WM-EJ

Edgerrin James [Noted] #/300

$9.17
2004 Leaf Limited - Limited Threads - Die-Cut Positions #LT-31

Don Maynard [Noted] #/50

$9.17
2011 Topps Five Star - [Base] #50

Terry Bradshaw [Noted] #/129

$9.17
2005 Ultimate Collection - Ultimate Patch #GJP-CM

Curtis Martin [Noted] #/50

$9.17
2004 Flair - Gridiron Cuts - Red #GC-LT

LaDainian Tomlinson [Noted] #/150

$17.77
<< 1 2 3 4 5 >>
Go to page
Page 1 of 5