By clicking “Accept” you agree to our use of cookies and marketing tracking technologies as described in our Privacy Policy .

Top
Hall of Fame Football Cards Aftermarket Auto Graded
Sort By
Listings
 
Attributes
Players
Teams
Item Conditions
Sellers
Sold Out
Listing Format
Browse
Skip Navigation Links.
Football (84)
2010's (3)
2000's (6)
1990's (46)
1980's (12)
1970's (10)
1960's (6)
1950's (1)
Listings 1 - 84 of 84
1998 Collector's Edge 1st Place - [Base] #135.3

Peyton Manning (1998 Top Rookie AFC) [PSA/DNA Authentic Card &&n…

$471.10
1991 Upper Deck - Football Heroes - Joe Namath #18.2

Joe Namath (Autograph) [PSA/DNA 8 NM‑MT] #/2,500

$800.00
2019 Panini Contenders Optic - 2007 Contenders Tribute Autographs #TRI-CJ

Calvin Johnson [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto] #/25

$799.99
2005 Upper Deck Reflections - Signature Reflections #SR-JB

Jim Brown [PSA/DNA 8 NM‑MT]

$581.09
1991 Fleer Ultra - [Base] #236

Reggie White [PSA/DNA 6 EX‑MT]

$470.00
1993 Topps - [Base] #166

Jerome Bettis [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$372.08
1970 Topps - [Base] #30

Bart Starr [PSA/DNA 5 EX]

$341.09
1995 Chicago Bears 1985 Super Bowl Champs 10th Anniversary Phone Collection - [Base] #_WAPA

Walter Payton [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto] #/25,000

$339.99
1992 Topps Stadium Club - [Base] #683

Brett Favre [PSA/DNA 7 NM]

$334.50
1993 Skybox Impact - Kelly's Heroes/Magic's Kingdom #KEL/MAG 1.2

Jim Kelly, Magic Johnson (Jim Kelly Autograph) [PSA/DNA Authentic Car…

$307.00
1989 Topps - [Base] #1

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$286.10
1984 Miami Dolphins Police - [Base] #_DAMA

Dan Marino [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$283.90
2000 Topps Season Opener - Autographs #A4

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$236.82
2016 Panini Classics - [Base] #154

Legends - Franco Harris [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$231.10
1997 SP Authentic - [Base] #173

Warren Moon [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$81.90
1994 Select - Franco Harris Autograph #_FRHA

Franco Harris [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto] #/5,000

$231.09
1988 Giant Eagle Pittsburgh Steelers Police - [Base] #26

Rod Woodson [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$187.09
1977 Topps - [Base] #177

Steve Largent [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

2 from
$157.39
1997 Upper Deck NFL Legends - [Base] #166

Ken Stabler [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$77.30
1979 Topps - [Base] #310

James Lofton [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$141.99
1989 Pro Set - [Base] #462

Mike Haynes [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$48.90
1994 Score - [Base] #67

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$129.90
1991 Pinnacle - [Base] #66

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$114.10
1990 Pro Set - Super Bowl MVP's #24

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$114.10
1988 Swell Football Greats Hall of Fame - [Base] #36

Dick Butkus [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$103.74
1995 Upper Deck Joe Montana - Box Set [Base] #32

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$102.60
1995 Upper Deck Joe Montana - Box Set [Base] #26

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$102.60
1995 Upper Deck Joe Montana - Box Set [Base] #25

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$102.60
1995 Upper Deck Joe Montana - Box Set [Base] #18

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$102.60
1995 Upper Deck Joe Montana - Box Set [Base] #14

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$102.60
1995 Upper Deck Joe Montana - Box Set [Base] #11

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$102.60
1995 Upper Deck Joe Montana - Box Set [Base] #10

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$102.60
1995 Upper Deck Joe Montana - Box Set [Base] #7

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$102.60
1994 Upper Deck Collector's Choice - [Base] #36

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$102.60
1992 Upper Deck Gold - [Base] #G36

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$102.60
1991 Upper Deck - Football Heroes - Joe Montana #8

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$102.60
1991 Pro Set - [Base] #3

Award Winner - Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$102.60
1990 Score - [Base] #1

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$102.60
1984 Topps - [Base] #359

Instant Replay - Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$102.60
1983 Topps - Stickers #11

Tony Dorsett [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$102.60
1962 Topps - [Base] #102

Y.A. Tittle [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$101.45
1992 Pro Line Portraits - [Base] #410

Dick Butkus [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$99.15
1990 Pro Set - [Base] #185

Don Shula [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$94.54
1995 Upper Deck Joe Montana - Box Set [Base] #41

Bill Walsh [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$91.10
1995 Upper Deck Joe Montana - Box Set [Base] #40

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$91.10
1995 Upper Deck Joe Montana - Box Set [Base] #39

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$91.10
1995 Upper Deck Joe Montana - Box Set [Base] #36

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$91.10
1995 Upper Deck Joe Montana - Box Set [Base] #30

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$91.10
1995 Upper Deck Joe Montana - Box Set [Base] #28

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$91.10
1995 Upper Deck Joe Montana - Box Set [Base] #24

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$91.10
1995 Upper Deck Joe Montana - Box Set [Base] #6

Joe Montana [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$91.10
1956 Topps - [Base] #44

Joe Schmidt [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$91.10
1977 Touchdown Club - [Base] #28

Charley Trippi [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$80.75
1980 Topps - [Base] #330

Tony Dorsett [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$80.43
1962 Topps - [Base] #92

Hugh McElhenny [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$79.60
1962 Topps - [Base] #32

Lou Groza [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$78.45
1978 Topps - [Base] #315

Tony Dorsett [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

15h left (7) $59.00
1962 Topps - [Base] #8

Gino Marchetti [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$68.10
1977 Touchdown Club - [Base] #44

Bill Dudley [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$63.50
1997 Upper Deck NFL Legends - Autographs #AL-7

Dan Fouts [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$58.90
1995 Classic Pro Line - Autographs #_ROLO

Ronnie Lott [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto] #/1,900

$57.75
1994 Fleer - [Base] #359

Ronnie Lott [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$57.75
1990 Pro Set Super Bowl XXV Silver Anniversary - Box Set [Base] #100

Herb Adderly [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$57.74
1965 Philadelphia - [Base] #8

Lenny Moore [PSA/DNA 6 EX‑MT]

$49.69
2000 Fleer Greats of the Game - Retrospection Collection #5 RC

Paul Hornung [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$47.40
2000 Fleer Greats of the Game - [Base] #2

Paul Hornung [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$47.40
1993 Playoff Contenders - [Base] #114

Willie Roaf [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$47.40
1972 Topps - [Base] #59

Roger Wehrli [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$47.40
1962 Topps - [Base] #59

Joe Schmidt [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$47.40
2003 Topps - Hall of Fame #_ELBE

Elvin Bethea [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$46.24
1972 Sunoco NFL Action Player Stamps - [Base] #_CHJO.1

Charlie Joiner [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$45.09
1997 Skybox Premium - [Base] #164

Aeneas Williams [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$41.65
1972 The Wonderful World of Pro Football USA Player Stamps - [Base] #344

Roger Wehrli [PSA/DNA 3 VG]

$41.65
1989 Topps - [Base] #206

Eric Dickerson [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$40.50
1983 Topps - [Base] #155

Dan Dierdorf [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$40.50
1999 Topps - Hall of Fame #HOF2

Billy Shaw [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$40.49
1993 Pro Set Power - [Base] #95

Richard Dent [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$37.05
1990 Pro Set - [Base] #798

Twenty-Second Annual Pro Football HoF Photo Contest - Third Place, Black and Wh…

$37.05
1986 Topps - [Base] #236

Charlie Joiner [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$35.90
1991 Pro Set - [Base] #4

Award Winner - Art Shell [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$34.74
2001 Upper Deck NFL Legends - [Base] #31

Paul Hornung [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$31.30
2018 Panini Classics - [Base] #127

Legends - Dick LeBeau [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$22.10
1985-88 Football Immortals - [Base] #77

Ollie Matson [PSA/DNA Authentic Card & Auto]

$19.17
1971 Topps - [Base] #144

Bob Lilly [PSA/DNA 6 EX‑MT]

17h left (3) $7.00
Go to page
Page 1 of 1